April 02, 2025

Parenting Wars: “Gentle Parenting” vs. “Tough Love”

46 minutes

**Exciting news! With You in the Weeds has been nominated for “Best Local Podcast” in Inside Columbia magazine’s “Best of Columbia” contest! You can help us win by voting TODAY and EVERY DAY through April 30th. Here’s the link to cast your vote and thanks so much for your support!**

Welcome to our brand-new series, Parenting in the Weeds! This series is dedicated to parents who feel tired, confused, or frustrated - because let's be honest, parenting isn't just hard; sometimes, it feels impossible. In this episode, we dive into the challenges of parenting today and explore the tension between two popular approaches: gentle parenting and tough love parenting.

John, Lynn and Austin discuss the strengths and weaknesses of each and introduce a balanced framework - love and limits - that can help parents find a more effective and sustainable way to raise their children. Whether you're a parent or someone who interacts with kids in any capacity, there's something in this episode for you!

Here’s what we cover:

Understanding the extremes:

Gentle Parenting: Focuses on emotional attunement, empathy, and attachment but can sometimes lack necessary boundaries.

Tough Love Parenting: Emphasizes structure, discipline, and authority but can sometimes be overly rigid and emotionally distant.

A Better Way – Love and Limits:

Parenting is about balancing emotional connection and boundaries.

Parenting the way God parents us means we are offering love while providing guidance.

Structure without relationship leads to rebellion, and unchecked emotions can create chaos.

Practical Parenting Takeaways:

Reflect on whether your parenting leans too heavily on love or limits and make adjustments, tailoring your approach to each child’s unique needs.

If you default to tough love, ask for feedback from your kids, acknowledge any past mistakes, and be willing to apologize.

If you lean towards gentle parenting, start setting and enforcing boundaries - even if your child protests at first.

Be prepared for the extinction burst - behavior may initially escalate when limits are introduced but will stabilize over time.

The truth is that parenting is challenging, but the good news is that you're not alone! God sees and cares about where you are in your parenting journey, and he is with you in the weeds of parenting.

Recommended Resources:

Parenting from the Inside Out – Dan Siegel

The Connected Parent – Karen Purvis & Lisa Qualls

Boundaries with Kids – Dr. Henry Cloud & Dr. John Townsend

If you want to remember what you learned in this episode, subscribe to our newsletter at withyouintheweeds.com to receive our weekly episode summary and to find our library of resources on all the topics we cover.

Your reviews and ratings help us reach more people so please leave a review and a 5-star rating!

If this conversation resonates with you, share it with someone who needs encouragement in their own healing journey and join the WYITW community on IG & FB @withyouintheweeds.com.

...more

View all episodes

By With You in the Weeds

4.9

8686 ratings