PARTNERS IN TRUE CRIME

Now, as new allegations emerge in a civil lawsuit, questions about the investigation are more urgent than ever.

In this explosive episode of Partners in True Crime, hosts Cindy and Rob Dorfmann welcome retired FBI investigator Stewart Fillmore and Terry L. Hunt Jr. for an examination of the Noah Presgrove case through the lens of federal investigative experience and oversight.

Together, they explore the unanswered questions, conflicting witness accounts, forensic evidence, and investigative challenges that have fueled growing demands for answers.

Could the FBI become involved? What would justify federal intervention? And what investigative steps might help uncover the truth?

As Noah's family continues its pursuit of answers, we examine whether additional investigative resources, forensic expertise, and independent scrutiny could help move this case forward.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

What happens when a mother vanishes, decades pass, and the fight for justice is far from over?

In Episode 26 of Justice for Lonene Rogers, Partners in True Crime welcomes renowned crime scene investigator Sheryl “Mac” McCollum, a nationally recognized forensic expert and founder of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute.

Mac joins hosts Cindy and Rob Dorfmann and Alison Duiker for a compelling conversation about the mysterious disappearance of Lonene Rogers, the challenges of investigating decades-old cases, and the forensic techniques that can help uncover the truth.

As Lonene's family continues its relentless pursuit of answers, Mac brings her experience in criminal investigations, crime scene analysis, and cold case investigations to examine the questions that remain unanswered.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Is it time for federal authorities to take a closer look at the mysterious death of Noah Presgrove?

In this explosive new episode of Partners in True Crime, Rob and Cindy welcome special guest Terry L. Hunt Jr. for an important discussion about the investigation into the death of 19-year-old Noah Presgrove and the possibility of federal oversight.

On September 4, 2023, Noah's body was discovered along a rural Oklahoma highway following a Labor Day weekend party. His death was officially attributed to multiple blunt-force injuries, but critical questions surrounding what happened that night remain unanswered.

More than three years later, Noah's family and supporters are still searching for answers.

Could federal involvement help bring new attention, resources, and accountability to this investigation?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

October is Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and this week on Partners in True Crime, Rob and Cindy welcome special guest Rose Tarquinio for an important conversation about domestic violence, its devastating impact on victims and families, and the ongoing fight for justice.

As we continue our investigation into the disappearance and murder of Lonene Rogers, we turn our attention to an issue that affects millions of people: domestic violence and the countless victims who suffer in silence.

Through the lens of Lonene's story, this episode explores the importance of recognizing the warning signs of abuse, supporting survivors, raising awareness, and demanding accountability.

Domestic violence isn't always physical. Emotional abuse, intimidation, threats, manipulation, and financial control can be just as devastating. For many victims, finding a safe way out can be extraordinarily difficult.

This episode is about more than one case. It's about giving victims a voice, honoring those whose lives have been lost, and reminding survivors that they are not alone.

Join us for this special Domestic Violence Awareness Month episode of Justice for Lonene Rogers.

IF YOU OR SOMEONE YOU KNOW NEEDS HELP:

National Domestic Violence Hotline
Call: 1-800-799-7233
Text: START to 88788
Website: www.thehotline.org

Free, confidential support is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

Subscribe to Partners in True Crime for continuing coverage of the Lonene Rogers case and our pursuit of answers, accountability, and justice.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

What does a seasoned small-town law enforcement officer make of the mysterious death of Noah Presgrove?

In this compelling episode of Partners in True Crime, hosts Rob and Cindy Dorfmann welcome Thomas Reader, a retired Texas City Marshal who has worked alongside FBI Agent Stewart Filmore, to share his unique perspective on the Noah Presgrove case.

Drawing on his years of law enforcement experience, Reader examines the circumstances surrounding Noah's death through the eyes of a small-town Texas marshal—someone who understands the challenges of investigating suspicious deaths in rural communities, where everyone knows everyone and finding the truth can be complicated.

What questions would an experienced marshal ask? What investigative steps would he consider essential? And what stands out to him about the evidence and circumstances surrounding Noah's death?

Join us for an insightful conversation as we continue our pursuit of answers and justice for Noah Presgrove.

Subscribe to Partners in True Crime and join us as we continue investigating the unanswered questions surrounding Noah's death.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Cold Case Investigator Jeff Walters, the investigator who helped crack the Lonene Rogers case by obtaining a confession from Alison Duiker’s father, Bud Rogers, joins Partners in True Crime for an important new episode.

Jeff sits down with Rob and Cindy to share his perspective on the July habeas corpus hearing and what the latest courtroom developments could mean for the case moving forward.

After decades of unanswered questions surrounding Lonene’s disappearance and presumed murder, the case is now approaching a critical crossroads. Will Bud Rogers negotiate a plea deal—or will he take his chances at trial? Jeff discusses what he witnessed, how he views the legal battle unfolding, and what he believes may happen next.

For Alison, the fight for answers about what happened to her mother has lasted most of her life. Now, with the possibility of a criminal prosecution moving closer, the question is whether the case will finally reach a courtroom—or end with a plea.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A newly recorded statement raises more questions in the mysterious death of 19-year-old Noah Presgrove.

In Episode 17, retired Illinois State Police Crime Scene Investigator Jodi Barth joins Partners in True Crime to examine a recent recorded statement from a woman who says she overheard Jack Newton and two other young men at a pizza restaurant discussing what they allegedly did to Noah.

What could this account mean for the investigation? Jodi breaks down the statement from an investigator’s perspective, including what she believes should be examined, corroborated, and compared against the existing evidence.

Jodi also takes a fresh look at the larger case, walking through evidence, reported circumstances, and unanswered questions that she believes do not fit neatly together. From the events surrounding Noah’s final hours to the condition and location of his body and other details investigators have had to reconcile, Jodi explains which aspects stand out to her and why.

The allegations discussed in this episode have not been established as fact. No criminal charges are implied by discussing the recorded statement. The episode presents the witness’s account and Jodi Barth’s analysis and opinions.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

For more than four decades, Alison Duiker fought for answers about what happened to her mother, Lonene “Lonnie” Rogers. Now, that fight has become something bigger.

In Episode 23 of Partners in True Crime: Justice for Lonene Rogers, Rob and Cindy explore what it means to pay it forward when one family's search for justice becomes a lifeline for another.

Our guest Shyla Jump knows firsthand the agony of having someone you love disappear. Shyla joins us to share her story of her missing grandmother Charlotte and discuss the emotional reality faced by families searching for a missing loved one—and the importance of having people willing to stand beside them when answers seem impossible to find.

After everything Alison has endured in the decades-long fight for her mother, she understands a painful truth: families of the missing should never have to fight alone.

This episode is about turning pain into purpose. It's about families helping families, refusing to allow the missing to be forgotten, and using everything learned through one fight for justice to help another.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

What can Noah Presgrove’s injuries tell us about what happened during the final hours of his life?

In Episode 16 of Partners in True Crime: What Happened to Noah Presgrove?, Rob and Cindy sit down with Dr. Michelle DuPre, forensic pathologist, to take a closer look at the medical evidence surrounding Noah’s death.

Noah was found along Highway 81 on the morning of September 4, 2023. His death was officially attributed to multiple blunt-force injuries, but one enormous question remains:

What caused them?

Dr. DuPre examines the case from a forensic pathology perspective, discussing Noah’s injuries and what patterns of trauma may—and may not—be able to tell us about the circumstances surrounding his death.

Could Noah’s injuries have resulted from one event, or could there have been multiple traumatic events? What questions should investigators be asking when examining the medical findings? And how does forensic pathology help distinguish between competing theories?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

For more than four decades, Alison Duiker has fought for answers and justice for her mother, Lonene “Lonnie” Rogers. But she hasn’t fought alone.

In Episode 22 of Partners in True Crime: Justice for Lonene Rogers, Rob and Cindy sit down with Marion Jenkins, a woman whose support, determination and compassion have made her one of the important people standing beside Alison in the fight for Lonnie.

Why do we call Marion “Lonnie’s Angel”?

Marion shares her connection to Lonnie’s story, how she became involved, and what compelled her to keep pushing for answers in a case that has spanned more than four decades.

This episode is about more than an investigation. It’s about the people who refuse to allow a missing woman to be forgotten—and the extraordinary relationships that can develop when people come together in the pursuit of justice.

As the case enters a new chapter, Marion joins Alison, Rob and Cindy to reflect on Lonnie, the long road to justice, and why giving up was never an option.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices