PARTNERS IN TRUE CRIME

WHEN A TIP DETAILS A POSSIBLE LOCATION OF MOLLY AND COLT, PAULA JUMPS INTO ACTION AND ORGANIZES A SEARCH...WE SEND A FILM CREW TO DOCUMENT IT...JACKIE BATES GIVES US AN UPDATE ON HIS FEELINGS ABOUT THE CASE, AND A TIPSTER REVEALS A CONNECTION TO THE EYEWITNESS FROM THE LAST EPISODE.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

How far would you go to get the truth about a missing loved one? In 2021, Paula received a tip from someone who wanted to meet in person; he said he would tell her what happened to Molly and Colt because he was there. You heard some of this recording a few weeks ago but now we are diving deep into this conversation and revealing the horrifying details of what he saw. Is this witness the key to finding out what happened to Molly and Colt? We'll let you decide.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Even though the bodies of Molly and Colt have not been found yet, there are still traces of their DNA somewhere out there...just a microscopic fiber could be enough to solve this case. Today, we are lucky enough to have veteran CSI tech and homicide detective Jodi Barth take us through a fascinating forensic analysis of the case. Media attention is vital to keeping this case alive and KXII Texoma News has been on this story from day 1. We are thrilled to have reporter Caroline Cluiss join us and give us her thoughts on the case.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Today is a very emotional episode it is the 9 year anniversary of Molly and Colt's disappearance. In the beginning of the investigation, there were dozens of tips and witnesses who had information. A lot of that information was saved on audio recordings...and today we are going to release one of those recordings from someone who was with Molly right before she got into the car with Conn and Colt...Molly's cousin Paula will navigate us through the tip and reveal disturbing information...and then Paula's emotional plea to the public. 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

One year after Molly and Colt went missing, Paula Fielder hired private investigator Philip Klein to look into the case. Klein brought Trace Sargent, the top K9 handler in human remains to the area where the car was found...and what her K9's found was shocking but it matched up with a lot of the theories that have been told over the years...Paula Fielder has been on this case from Day 1, crusading with other family members to get justice for Molly and Colt. For the first time, Paula reveals her theory about what happened adding new information about the early days of the investigation and Trace has a call to action that we hope will bring some movement to the case.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Although this case has dozens of rumors and theories, one heartbreaking theory has been consistent from the first week that Molly and Colt went missing- that Molly was held captive and tied to a tree for several days after the high speed chase. In today's episode we talk to Misty, Molly's cousin who has been investigating this case with Paula from day one she has her own information about that tip from the early days. Then...we release a recording that was given to us and even though the information is disturbing it does match up with the other theories about the tree...could this person have the answers?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

If you went missing wouldn't you expect law enforcement to start searching for you at the last place they knew you were? When Conn Nipp drove his girlfriend's Honda into the woods, Molly and Colt jumped out of the car and took off into the woods...rattlesnakes, deep canyons, dried creek beds make that area a death trap... is it possible that they could have been taken by the elements? Two weeks later a deputy stumbled upon the car...but a formal search of the land around the car was never conducted. Why?

This week we speak to Jackie Bates, the deputy who joined the investigation in 2020. Jackie recently filed a search warrant to search the land where the car was found...but things don't go as planned. Then someone's conscience is rattled after hearing Paula's story about the freezer...after a few sleepless nights they decided to give us a call and reveal some shocking information...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

 Two weeks after Molly and Colt disappeared, law enforcement finally finds the car that Conn Nipp was driving during the high speed chase. But there are no clues in the car to suggest foul play and the investigation stalls again...Molly's family is frustrated and they hire Phil Klein a private investigator. Phil starts to piece together what he believes happened to Molly and Colt when a mysterious 911 call discussing what happened to Molly rattles the dispatch operator...Phil leads us through his investigation and his thoughts on that 911 call. Then we speak to the man who left us a tip last week, a local outlaw reveals a shocking connection to Molly and reveals his theories about what happened.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

When a young girl comes forward with shocking information, Molly's cousin Paula reveals a tip in the early days of the investigation that might be connected. Then, a private investigator who specializes in Native American missing persons cases shares new information about Molly and Colt's case and gives her thoughts on what needs to happen next. 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Can you imagine what it would feel like if your best friend went missing when you were just a teenager? On this episode we do a deep dive with two of Molly's best friends who take us through their emotional journey in this mysterious case and give their thoughts on what they think may have happened to Molly and Colt. One of Molly's friends also recalls a chilling supernatural encounter with Molly . Then, why was Conn's cousin Sheriff Joe Russell the only person to interview him in the early days of the investigation? We analyze his formal statement and a police statement from Conn's own sister... 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices