The Catholic Thing

Reality Is Greater Than Their Ideas


Listen Later

By Robert Royal
Last week, Pope Francis spent 40 minutes - a long time for a busy man - with representatives of DIALOP, a group that engages in Christian-Marxist "dialogue." It was formed in 2014 after he met with some of the founders. It will probably only be remembered as a mere blip compared with much more momentous things that he's done. But for the hundreds of millions of people who suffered and are still suffering under Communist regimes - and for many of us who worked with St. John Paul II towards the demise of the Soviet Union and other murderous Marxist outposts - the disinterment of this long-dead corpse is no small matter.
Given Marxism's record of tyranny and death - a body count three times as great as Nazism's (itself National Socialism) - where was the pope's principle in Evangelii gaudium [231] that, "Realities are greater than ideas"? There are good reasons why there's no Christian-Nazi dialogue. Why does Communism get a pass?
Even in its heyday a half-century ago, the Christian-Marxist "dialogue" did little other than weaken Christian resistance to what every modern pope has condemned as a fundamentally evil ideology. Leo XIII prophesied in Rerum novarum (1891), just a few years after Marx's death, that if socialist ideas were "carried into effect the working man himself would be among the first to suffer." [4]
It's a great historical irony that it was the largely Catholic workers of Polish Solidarność who lit the fuse that blew up Communism. In Argentina, Jorge Mario Bergoglio sometimes argued that "God's faithful people" didn't want Marxism. But at the recent Vatican meeting, he praised the search for a kind of common humanitarian project, "instead of rigid approaches that divide, let us cultivate, with open hearts, discussion and listening."
Who takes Communism seriously today, real Communism as we know it from history - a nightmare, not the "dreaming of a better world" that Pope Francis and others see in humanitarian initiatives of this sort? It's precisely sentimental dreaming that enabled unprecedented carnage.
You have to wonder what Marx would have thought of all this. Anyone familiar with his "scientific socialism" knows that he scorned the softheaded humanitarian socialisms that existed in his day - and still do in ours. Marx, with typical Enlightenment hubris about the powers of atheist reason, believed that he'd demonstrated how the revolution would take place by inexorable laws of history: The forces of capitalist production would increasingly exploit the workers, large numbers of the poor would rise up and, almost without the need for violence, simply "expropriate the expropriators."
Of course, this never happened despite Marx's "science of history," because there is no such science. Communism conquered places where "capitalism" hardly existed: primarily Russia and China (then Laos, North Korea, Vietnam). You might try to argue that Cuba sort of resembled what Marx thought would happen everywhere under capitalism. But that has to be balanced against the fact that Cuba was wealthier - and even less oppressive - before Communism than in its current disastrous state. (I've been there and seen it.)
Eastern European countries had Communism imposed on them by the USSR after World War II. The Soviets almost succeeded via proxy wars in Africa and Latin America. But the actual Marxist vision about the "arc of history" didn't go as expected. It was monstrous everywhere it's been tried, producing over 100 million dead in the course of a century or so.
Yet the dream - the deadly illusion - continues. It's interesting that Communism and the social justice movements more generally have moved away from their classic foci - politics and economics - and into the realm of culture. They had to.
During the 1980s, as the Cold War was coming to an end, you sometimes heard complaints from Marxists that the embourgeoisement of workers - i.e., greater prosperity - in capitalist countries was undermining revolutionary...
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Catholic ThingBy The Catholic Thing

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

28 ratings


More shows like The Catholic Thing

View all
Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast by Dr. Taylor Marshall

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast

4,045 Listeners

The Thomistic Institute by The Thomistic Institute

The Thomistic Institute

747 Listeners

First Things Podcast by First Things

First Things Podcast

713 Listeners

Pints With Aquinas by Matt Fradd

Pints With Aquinas

6,576 Listeners

All Things Catholic with Dr. Edward Sri by Ascension

All Things Catholic with Dr. Edward Sri

1,343 Listeners

The Catholic Current by The Station of the Cross

The Catholic Current

384 Listeners

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn by Scott Hahn

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn

37 Listeners

Return To Tradition by Anthony Stine

Return To Tradition

351 Listeners

American Catholic History by Noelle & Tom Crowe

American Catholic History

823 Listeners

Godsplaining by Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Godsplaining

1,229 Listeners

U.S. Grace Force with Fr. Richard Heilman and Doug Barry by U.S. Grace Force

U.S. Grace Force with Fr. Richard Heilman and Doug Barry

569 Listeners

Evangelization & Culture Podcast by Word on Fire Institute

Evangelization & Culture Podcast

202 Listeners

The Pillar Podcast by The Pillar Podcast

The Pillar Podcast

650 Listeners

Catholic Saints by Augustine Institute

Catholic Saints

1,045 Listeners

The LOOPcast by CatholicVote

The LOOPcast

723 Listeners