When a dating reality show called “MILF Manor” was announced not long ago, the reaction was immediate and unanimous: Wasn’t that a fake show on “30 Rock”? It does seem like a desperate TV exec, over a decade after the “MILF Island” episode of “30 Rock,” cribbed the concept of a reality show about hot moms for their own pitch.
But in practice, “MILF Manor” is somehow more tawdry than its fictional predecessor. “MILF Island” (tagline: "25 super-hot moms, 50 eighth grade boys, no rules”) seemed more akin to “Survivor” than a dating show. The bikini-clad moms competed in challenges, and the boys voted them off the island. “MILF Manor,” on the other hand, seems more akin to the scene-setting portion of a YouPorn clip than a dating show.
The eight hot moms who arrive at the Mexican villa, ready to date some younger men, quickly realize that the dating pool is made up of their own sons — one of them as young as 20. And while some attempts at romance are made, the show (at least the first two episodes) revolves more around forcing mother-son pairs into uncomfortably sexual situations: sharing rooms, touching their son’s bodies while blindfolded, and disclosing sexually graphic secrets. It’s the wink-wink-nudge-nudge it’s not really incest but isn’t it so taboo? formula that has produced an ever-growing wave of fauxcest porn featuring stepsiblings and stepparents. As Naomi Fry put it in her essay “The Mother Lovers of' ‘MILF Manor,’” the show is “haunted by the spectre of incest.”
It’s a striking contrast to another recent dating show about older women, “Back in the Groove,” which took “How Stella Got Her Groove Back” as its inspiration (down to the occasional presence of Taye Diggs as a host). “Back in the Groove” features three women in their early 40s, each looking for a fresh start after a season of struggle, who will be dating from a pool of 24 younger men. Though there’s a similar twist — one mom’s son turns out to be among the suitors — their relationship is treated respectfully rather than pruriently. And, more broadly, the show allows its three leads to be complete people with varied and complex desires, rather than setting them up for mockery and humiliation.
In this episode, we discuss the two shows — especially “MILF Manor” — and what it means that we need special, niche dating shows about older women dating younger men, plus the incursion of porn trends into reality TV and the freak-show-to-prestige-show reality TV spectrum. Enjoy! xo
Share Rich Text
We’ve been watching…
Comfy rewatches. I’ve spent the last couple of months in a bit of a depressive slump, which has reached its nadir in the past two weeks. Winter, which I used to love, is a bitch to get through now that I’m so careful about indoor socializing. The weather has been gray. I’ve been working through some old griefs that have resurfaced lately. Everything is fundamentally fine, but the zest has been lacking from life — and even from TV. Yes, I’ve been struggling to enjoy TV shows. That’s how you know you’re in a funk.
The best I’ve been able to do is fall back on an old favorite, “Lovesick,” which I’ve been watching in the evenings. If you’ve never seen it, it’s a delightful little show about a group of friends in Glasgow navigating love and friendship; the spine of the show is that one friend, Dylan, has contracted chlamydia and needs to contact all of his former sex partners to notify them. Despite this premise, it is, at its heart, a romcom. -Claire
I started Rian Johnson’s new Columbo-style procedural show, “Poker Face,” which stars Natasha Lyonne as a human lie detector who is on the run and solves a new case every week. I have only watched the pilot, but it was fantastic, and the case-of-the-week format allows for Johnson to get some really high-quality guest stars (Dascha Polanco! Benjamin Bratt! Adrien Brody!). -Emma
We’ve been reading…
Honestly, I’m having a bout of winter exhaustion which is impacting my ability to pay attention while I’m reading. Maybe it’s the fact that the sun has barely been out for the last two weeks, and thus I'm feeling antsy and a little low. So starting new books has been a bit of a slog. I have however been finding comfort in Heather Havrilesky’s Ask Polly columns, which feel like a salve on the days that feel the most hopeless. -Emma
Clearly we’re both in a deep pit of the winter doldrums. I look back on my carefree summer self as if she were a completely different person, someone who could process multiple complex sentences in a row without needing a nap. Anyway! Articles have been my salvation this week, perhaps the emotional highlight of which was the opportunity to leave my apartment to go to the cardiologist. After my appointment, I sat in a nearby diner, ate a stack of pancakes, and read Molly Fischer’s delicately cutting New Yorker profile of former New York Times Book Review editor and current opinion columnist Pamela Paul. Paul held a hugely influential position in the publishing world at the time when I covered books regularly, and her new role as an opinion writer (a terrible opinion writer) has been, um, retrospectively illuminating. So is the New Yorker profile. Then Paul put out a column revisiting, inexplicably, the “American Dirt” kerfuffle from several years ago, which inspired an immensely satisfying response from Max Read. Nothing like a little book world drama to make you feel alive again. -Claire
We’ve been listening to…
The latest episode of “If Books Could Kill,” about the ‘90s runaway bestseller, “Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus.” Extremely unsurprisingly, this bible of gender essentialism was written by a misogynist grifter! I honestly only knew the broad strokes of this book — I absolutely first heard about it via “Clueless” — so this deep dive was both fascinating and disturbing. -Emma
That episode is one of the few things that actually made me laugh this week! Thank you to Michael and Peter for your service. -Claire
We’ve been buying…
It’s incredible that I have reached 35 and yet I am still discovering so many new ways in which I have been doing my makeup wrong for years. I recently went down a rabbithole of makeup tutorial TikToks which led me to refresh my makeup. (Plus, a bunch of my most-loved products were fully running out.) I picked up the Dibs Beauty Desert Island Duo in shade 2, Charlotte Tilbury Lip Liner in Pillow Talk, my tried and true Make Up For Ever HD Foundation, and Make Up For Ever Ultra Matte HD loose setting powder which comes with a very cute little powder puff to apply it. -Emma
Emma, that’s because they keep coming up with new ways to do makeup! I promise you, it’s not your fault.
I have been trying to gently get back into exercise with a weekly yoga class, but all of my sports bras either have gaping cups or make me feel like my ribs are being cracked. Why is it so hard to find a sports bra for someone with essentially no boobs but a ribcage more than 28 inches around? I finally decided to invest in the Alo Yoga Wild Thing bra, which came highly recommended for my body type (flat), and it’s a winner — both comfortable and cute. And with just one yoga class a week, I only need to be able to afford one sports bra, right? -Claire