RR The Wire 2330Z November 27, 2023
PRECEDENCE: ROUTINE RR
DTG: 233027Z NOV 23
ICOD: 230027Z NOV 23
CONTROLS: Public Release
QQQQ
BLUF: UNREST CONTINUES IN IRELAND. PRISONER EXCHANGE IN GAZA HIGHLIGHTS IRREGULARITIES.
-----BEGIN TEARLINE-----
-International Events-
Ireland: Unrest continues following the proposal of new hate speech laws. The proposed legal changes criminalize a substantial amount of online and physical content. AC: Rather than being a new law itself, the proposals so far have been amendments to CJ Bill (22), which is itself a “modernization” of a 1989 law regarding hate speech. However, the newly proposed amendments appear to criminalize the possession of “hate” content, which based on the proposed definitions of “hate content”, can really be any content.
Middle East: Israel and Hamas have conducted prisoner swaps during the tenuous ceasefire. Among the 17 hostages returned to Israel was Abigail Mor Edan, a 4 year old Israeli-American girl. AC: Per an NBC news report which interviewed her family members, her great-aunt was revealed to be Elizabeth Hirsh Naftali, a wealthy Los Angeles real estate investor at the heart of the ongoing corruption scandals within the White House. Naftali was appointed by President Biden to the U.S. Commission for the Preservation of America’s Heritage Abroad. In July 2022 (eight months prior to this appointment), Naftali purchased one of Hunter Biden’s paintings at his first art show in Hollywood. Before the scandals, Naftali was known as a major donor to the Democratic party, and hosted a fundraiser event featuring VP Kamala Harris last year. If these familial ties are true, the direct involvement of the US to secure the release of hostages with direct familial (and financial) ties to the current US government is almost certainly a conflict of interest, the follow-on effects of which cannot be determined at this time.
-Analyst Comments-
Regarding concerns for free speech in Ireland, the recent riots in Dublin appear to have given politicians the political capital needed to usher in a new wave of legislation to target political enemies. As these proposed changes stand, owning a copy of virtually any classic book, having a meme on your phone, and possessing a diary or unapproved news articles can be construed as a criminal act under these proposals. Though these newest updates are getting much attention at the moment, the efforts to restrict speech have been underway for a long time. For instance, in a press statement last year, MoJ McEntee stated that these modernizations are intended to be “effective in securing convictions”, as only about 50 people have been prosecuted for hate speech since 1989.
Over the past few months, authorities have concentrated efforts to restrict individual freedoms in Ireland (as has been a trend throughout Europe at large). In fact, in July Green Party Senator Pauline O'Reilly stated that: “We are restricting freedom but we are doing it for the common good”. Considering Ireland’s history and culture, and the open admission of textbook tyranny taking place in the most literal sense, these efforts are likely to result in boiling points being reached, as has happened following the Dublin terror attack.
As global tensions remain high, even the smallest incident can result in a flashpoint of events occurring nearly-simultaneously: 1- Citizens revolting (in some regard, however minor it may be), and 2- Authoritarians taking advantage of both the outrage, and the unrest to grant themselves even more power. This trend has remained constant over the past few years, and likely will result in even more kinetic actions (and draconian “laws”) in the near future. Public outrage is usually temporary, however intense it may seem at the time. Laws, however, tend to outlast the outrage and remain concerning long into the future.