The Mother has unleashed a new kind of monster. One scary enough that it brings in Sam, Dean, Bobby, Rufus, Samuel, and Gwen! Uh oh...how many are gonna die? And which ones?!

We discuss how yet again the white nightgown is a bad sign, the missed opportunities with Gwen, and the need for a hunter lawyer.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Balthazar gives Sam and Dean the key that will unlock the room where he hid all of the weapons he stole from Heaven. To keep it and them safe from Raphael's soldier, he sends them to another world where Supernatural is a TV show and everyone knows the Winchester brothers as actors Jared and Jensen. Yes really.

Martha is back because of course it was for this episode! And we discuss how PG got Jess hooked on another show, how every moment in this episode is another joke, and just what The French Mistake actually means.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

As people start to die horribly with no explanation, Sam and Dean begin to suspect the mannequins are the killers. To make it worse, the reason it happens is just oh so wrong and sad.

A poorly written episode where we root for the ghost, are let down from the previous cliffhanger, and can't help but point out the mustache crew.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Sam is sent coordinates to a town he had a case in the previous year. As memories slowly come back, he risks letting the creature they're after go, and tearing down the Hell wall in his mind.

We discuss how it's possible the deputy still has a face, how stressed out Jess got, and we get proof that the no closure award is canon.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Sam wakes up, he has his soul back, and he is finally the Sam we all know and love. Back in the saddle again, it's time for a hunt for...dragons?

Matt recaps the episode in a different voice, Jess talks about classic rock, and PG points out that a humanities professor shouldn't have that nice of a house.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Out of options, Dean decides to strike a deal with Death to get Sam's soul back. Death wants Dean to learn a lesson and has him play a game. And Sam will stop at nothing to keep his damaged soul from getting back into his body. Even if it means killing Bobby.

We immediately lose focus due to a bug, discuss all the weird spells that may or may not exist, and why Matt is going to write his Congressman.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Meg shows up allowing Sam and Dean to find an unlikely ally against Crowley. They call Castiel in for good measure and decide it's time to force the King of Hell to give back Sam's soul.

Meagan, our second place winner of Fandom Trumps Hate, joins us as we discuss the wasted potential of the Alpha Shapeshifter, ask lots of questions just where this porn video came from, and are surprised to learn about Jess's new feelings on Meg.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Are aliens flying around in UFOs and actually abducting people? Sam and Dean don't think so until Dean has a close encounter.

We discuss the troubles in parenting, the proper terms for fairies, and wondering if strong men had a place in this episode.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

A strange case where everyone seems suspicious. Even the family dog.

We share the wonderful new review we received, wonder what sleeping has to do with a soul, and spend way too much time trying to figure out what's in the kitchen bowl.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Finally finding out that Sam has no soul, Dean takes the lead on there next hunt together only for it to bring him at odds with Samuel when they trap the Alpha Vampire.

We groan about the return of the Campbells, question a weird writing goof with a red-shirt casualty, and discuss maybe better ways to interrogate the oldest monster.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook