Sam and Dean find themselves trapped in a hotel with a dozen pagan gods who want to use them as bargaining chips to stop the apocalypse. Things only get more complicated when Gabriel shows up, posing as Loki.

Matt has a talking Strong Bad plush doll and he lets you know it, we discuss our various hotels stays, and the problems with this episode (even though we still really like it).

PS - Eyeball scooping.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Dean has had enough and is ready to say yes to Michael. Too bad for him, Sam and Bobby won't let that happen. And Cas? Well he's pissed and wants to beat Dean up so he does. On top of all that, Adam is back!

We discuss Phantom of the Opera, Return to Oz, and how dumb the angels are.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

A town full of people aware that the apocalypse has started after angels have warned them. At least that's what Sam and Dean think is going on at first until a very drunk Castiel tells them the truth.

We discuss what brought Cas to set up his outgoing message, point out that the things people say in this town feels too real, and for the blooper we left it unedited because it needed to be told it its entirety.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Sam and Dean die (again), and this time we see what happens in the afterlife as they both end up in Heaven. Cas let's them know this is a good opportunity to find the angel who talks to God.

We discuss how the crying emoji got used a lot when writing notes, how good it must be to sleep in Heaven, and are so excited for Jess to see the return of her favorite character (the hardest secret we had to keep).

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

The dead are rising and there crave...a normal life? Something strange is happening in Bobby's hometown which includes his own wife coming back from the dead. Is it too good to be true?

We are joined by Jess's friend Summer and we discuss how cool Kim Rhodes is, how Sioux Falls is NOT a podunk town, and how PG had a zombie cat.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

One small town where suddenly everyone cannot satisfy their hunger. Hunger for food, sex, alcohol, money, you name it. When Sam, Dean, and Castiel arrive to investigate a rogue Cupid, they discover Famine, the Horseman, is in town.

We wonder if anyone in this town ate a baby, quickly pitch Sam's cologne ad, and figure that Dean craves Cas.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Anna has escaped from Heaven's prison and she isn't back to help the Winchesters, but to unmake them by traveling back and time to prevent them from being born.

We discuss how different Anna is being written, why it still makes no sense for characters to cut their own hands, and happy that we can now call them Team Free Will.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

Sam is eating bacon cheeseburgers, blasting classic rock, and thinks hunting is sweet? Oh crap. That's not really Sam. But then where's Sam?!

We talk about how much this episode made us want a burger, Dean's complete and utter obliviousness, and why not to be Trevor.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

To help a friend of John's, Sam and Dean agree to have themselves committed to a psychiatric hospital to hunt a monster that is feeding on the patients. Problems arise when they both start to lose their grip on reality.

We discuss the many issues we have with the medical staff, wonder if Jared knows how to properly boop, and still feel bad for the monster's pain.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook

It's all hands on deck as Sam, Dean, Castiel, Ellen, and Jo all head out to get the colt and then kill Lucifer with it. After things don't go their way, there are casualties.

In an episode where Matt accidentally recorded on the wrong audio input, we discuss what a spaghetti junction is, the fun camera tricks, and all of our ugly crying. So much ugly crying.

Patreon

Twitter

Instagram

Tumblr

Facebook