Tried PSA’s new buyback on a fresh 17-card submission. They offered on 3 slabs; I sold 1 and passed on 2. Here’s the exact math, comps logic, and my quick framework so you can decide when to take the offer and when to hold.Timestamps 0:00 Intro — PSA’s buyback in plain English 0:52 The 3 offers (Brink / Strickland / Brady) 2:48 Why I accepted the Strickland 4:05 Why I passed on Brink + Brady 5:10 My “Offer vs Net” checklist (use this!) 6:40 Is this good for the hobby? 7:35 Top 5 times I’d take PSA’s offer 8:30 Final takeaways + next steps
Thanks to our monthly supporters
<ul>
 <li>Azilllatheodd</li>
 <li>Klendathu</li>
 <li>Tatershed</li>
 <li>Justin Burch</li>
 <li>Always_Eaton</li>
 <li>Chris Crimminger</li>
 <li>Casey Miller</li>
 <li>Ryan Bruder</li>
 <li>Kevin Quiles</li>
 <li>Evan Hastie</li>
 <li>Donut</li>
 <li>Josh Stewart</li>
 <li>Zach LaFountain</li>
</ul>

Tried PSA’s new buyback on a fresh 17-card submission. They offered on 3 slabs; I sold 1 and passed on 2. Here’s the exact math, comps logic, and my quick framework so you can decide when to take the offer and when to hold. Timestamps 0:00 Intro — PSA’s buyback in plain English 0:52 The 3 offers (Brink / Strickland / Brady) 2:48 Why I accepted the Strickland 4:05 Why I passed on Brink + Brady 5:10 My “Offer vs Net” checklist (use this!) 6:40 Is this good for the hobby? 7:35 Top 5 times I’d take PSA’s offer 8:30 Final takeaways + next steps Thanks to our monthly supporters Azilllatheodd Klendathu Tatershed Justin Burch Always_Eaton Chris Crimminger Casey Miller Ryan Bruder Kevin Quiles Evan Hastie Donut Josh Stewart Zach LaFountain

Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

Welcome to the Sports Cards Are Dope podcast, hosted by Dr. Tyler Tarver (@tarvercards), an aggressively average dude with an above-average obsession for those glorious, four-cornered lil treasures we call sports cards!

This isn’t just a podcast; it’s a celebration of sports, pop culture, and the universal joy of pulling a card so dope you immediately start calculating how many shares of Apple you can buy with it. Whether you’re a seasoned pro, a curious rookie, or someone who just wants to hear how Michael Jordan, Marvel movies, and Saved by the Bell all connect through cardboard, you’ve found your proverbial home.

Here, we keep it (mostly) positive as we dive into the wild world of collecting: rookie chases, market trends, and how these little slices of nostalgia tie into fandom, investing, and, yes, incredible relationships! Also, expect plenty of stories, pop culture tangents, and more than a few questionable analogies.

So grab your penny sleeves, settle in, and let’s talk sports cards more than your spouse would ever allow! SPORTS. CARDS. ARE. DOPE. (and so are you 🎧✨)!

Now quit reading, hit follow, and let’s dance you beautiful chicken nugget.

Sports

Leisure

Basketball

Hobbies

Welcome to the Sports Cards Are Dope podcast, hosted by Dr. Tyler Tarver (@tarvercards), an aggressively average dude with an above-average obsession for those glorious, four-cornered lil treasures we call sports cards! This isn’t just a podcast; it’s a celebration of sports, pop culture, and the universal joy of pulling a card so dope you immediately start calculating how many shares of Apple you can buy with it. Whether you’re a seasoned pro, a curious rookie, or someone who just wants to hear how Michael Jordan, Marvel movies, and Saved by the Bell all connect through cardboard, you’ve found your proverbial home. Here, we keep it (mostly) positive as we dive into the wild world of collecting: rookie chases, market trends, and how these little slices of nostalgia tie into fandom, investing, and, yes, incredible relationships! Also, expect plenty of stories, pop culture tangents, and more than a few questionable analogies. So grab your penny sleeves, settle in, and let’s talk sports cards more than your spouse would ever allow! SPORTS. CARDS. ARE. DOPE. (and so are you 🎧✨)! Now quit reading, hit follow, and let’s dance you beautiful chicken nugget.

Share Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

Sign up to save your podcasts

Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

More shows like Sports Cards are Dope

Mojobreak The Hype - A Sports Card Podcast

Sports Card Strategy Show

Sports Card Investor

Stacking Slabs

Sports Cards Nonsense

Sports Cards Live

Ball Card Show

Cards To The Moon

Geoff Wilson Show

Sports Card Lessons Podcast

The True Sports Cards Show

"Happy Hobby Sports Cards" Podcast!

Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe

The Hobby Handbook

Cut the Nonsense