In this episode of Super SUS, we share the heartbreaking story of Emma Walker, a 16-year-old cheerleader from Knoxville, Tennessee. Emma's radiant personality and infectious positivity left a lasting impact on everyone around her. We take a closer look at her high school relationship with Riley Gaul, a football player and her first love, which began as a typical teenage romance but quickly became toxic.

We explore the unsettling dynamics of their relationship, as Riley’s behavior grew increasingly controlling and possessive. Despite Emma’s efforts to separate herself from him, the situation escalated in shocking ways, including Riley fabricating a fake kidnapping in a desperate attempt to manipulate her.

Together, we examine the series of events surrounding Emma’s story and reflect on the profound emotional toll it took on her family and friends. We also underscore the importance of recognizing the warning signs of emotional abuse and controlling behaviors in relationships and the necessity of taking action before it’s too late.

If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence, please reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 or text 'START' to 88788.

Support the show

On this episode of Super SUS, we unravel the heartbreaking and horrifying story of Ann Hoover, a kind-hearted Pittsburgh resident whose dream of transforming an old South Oakland row home into her sanctuary led to an unimaginable nightmare.

We explore Ann’s initial optimism and determination to rebuild her dream home, only to find it shattered by her neighbor, Roy Kirk. What started as friendly encounters quickly morphed into a series of escalating tensions—neglected renovations, unsettling behavior, and rising hostility that foreshadowed the grim events to come.

Join us as we walk through the haunting details of the case, from the small red flags in Roy’s demeanor to the horrifying moment when Ann’s life was stolen. We dissect the events leading up to her gruesome murder and dismemberment, painting an unnerving picture of how a seemingly ordinary neighbor can harbor such darkness.

If you or someone you know is struggling, please know that help is available. You can call or text the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 for confidential support and assistance, anytime. You are not alone—there is always someone ready to listen and help.

Support the show

On this episode of Super SUS, we unravel the haunting case of Bryce Laspisa, a 19-year-old college student who vanished under mysterious circumstances in 2013. Together, we walk you through Bryce’s unsettling final hours, from his odd behavior to the eerie road trip that ended with his abandoned car near Castaic Lake, California.

We explore the most chilling theories surrounding his disappearance—was it an attempted suicide? Did he choose to disappear and start over? Or was foul play involved? We even consider the possibility of amnesia and the heartbreaking implications it could have on Bryce and his loved ones.

Through detailed storytelling and thoughtful analysis, we reflect on the pain and unanswered questions that continue to impact Bryce’s family and friends. Join us for a gripping deep-dive into one of the most perplexing disappearances in recent history.

If you or someone you know is struggling, please know that help is available. You can call or text the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 for confidential support and assistance, anytime. You are not alone—there is always someone ready to listen and help.

Support the show

In this episode, we take a deep dive into the tragic and haunting murder of Sherri Rasmussen, a brilliant and compassionate 29-year-old nurse whose life was senselessly taken in her Los Angeles townhome in 1986. What initially appeared to be a burglary gone wrong would later prove to be far more complex.

We discuss how the case was mishandled in its early days, with critical pieces of evidence overlooked and investigators failing to connect the dots. For over two decades, Sherri's family refused to give up, advocating passionately for answers as the case remained buried beneath a mountain of incomplete work and dead ends.

But the story doesn’t stop there. The episode explores the pivotal moment in 2009 when a determined detective reopened the case. With advancements in forensic technology and a fresh set of eyes, chilling new details emerged that would finally turn the tides of this decades-old mystery.

Through careful storytelling, we walk you through the twists and turns of the investigation, unravel how hidden truths eventually came to light, and examine the tireless pursuit of justice by Sherri's loved ones.

This episode serves as a reminder of the cracks that can exist in even the most trusted systems and of the unyielding resolve of those who refuse to allow a memory to fade.

Support the show

On this gripping episode of Super SUS, we unravel the haunting true crime case of Ali Abulaban, a TikTok influencer whose obsession with fame and control led to the unthinkable. Ali's tumultuous marriage to Ana Abulaban was marked by narcissism, domestic abuse, and his growing fixation on social media stardom. Tragically, his escalating behavior culminated in the 2021 murders of Ana and her friend, Rayburn Barron.

We take you deep into the chilling details of this case, shedding light on Ali's troubled personality and the devastating impact of his actions. Through thoughtful discussion, we explore critical themes such as the toxic intersection of domestic violence and unchecked narcissism, as well as the ways social media can amplify unhealthy dynamics in relationships.

If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence, please reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 or text 'START' to 88788.

Support the show

In this gripping episode of Super SUS, Ande and Amethyst dig deep into the heartbreaking double murder of Rhoni Reuter in the small town of Deerfield, Illinois. It’s 2007, and Rhoni, the pregnant girlfriend of former Chicago Bear Shaun Gayle, is brutally murdered in her home alongside her unborn daughter.

We unravel the complex investigation, focusing on Marni Yang, one of Shaun’s numerous love interests, who quickly emerges as the prime suspect. Through bugged conversations, forensic breakthroughs, and compelling witness accounts, we piece together how obsessive jealousy escalated into a devastating act of violence.

Along the way, we reflect on the greater implications of this case and discuss the lessons it teaches about navigating relationships with honesty and integrity. It’s a chilling story of love, betrayal, and the pursuit of justice—and one you won’t want to miss.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we dive into the chilling and mysterious circumstances surrounding the death of Tamla Horsford. Tamla was tragically found dead in a friend's backyard after what was supposed to be a fun adult sleepover. We explore the unsettling history of Forsyth County, Georgia, and how it might intertwine with the apparent lapses in the investigation by local authorities.

As we delve deeper, we discuss the significant physical injuries Tamla sustained, which seem to contradict the conclusion of a simple fall. We examine the questionable police procedures and the alleged racial undertones that cast a shadow over the case. Tamla's vibrant life and the events leading up to that fateful night are central to our discussion.

Together, we shine a light on the relentless efforts of Tamla's family and friends as they fight for justice. Their campaign has garnered widespread support through social media and petitions, emphasizing the collective call for the investigation to be reopened. Join us as we seek to unravel the truth behind Tamla Horsford's untimely death and underscore the vital importance of justice for her and her loved ones.

To sign the petition, click HERE

To contact Tamala's advocates, you can email them here: [email protected]

Justice for Tamla Horsford FB: https://www.facebook.com/JusticeForTam

Support the show

In this gripping episode, we dive into Part 2 of the Rodney Alcala story. We explore his horrific crimes, starting with the abduction and rape of Tali Shapiro in 1968, followed by the brutal murder of Cornelia Crilley, and the heart-wrenching death of young Robin Samsoe in 1979. We delve into how Alcala used his photography hobby to lure his victims, his movements between Los Angeles and New York, and his unsettling appearance on 'The Dating Game' while actively on a killing spree. The episode highlights the twists and missed opportunities in the investigation that allowed him to continue his reign of terror for over a decade.

Support the show

In this episode, we delve into the chilling story of Rodney Alcala, infamously known as 'The Dating Game' Killer. The hosts start by discussing the broader fascination with serial killers before exploring Alcala's appearance on the popular 1970s TV show 'The Dating Game.' They detail Alcala's secret double life as a serial murderer and predator, sharing accounts of his horrifying crimes, including the brutal attacks and murders he committed both before and after his TV appearance. The episode also touches on the recent movie 'Woman of the Hour,' directed by Anna Kendrick, which dramatizes Alcala's unsettling story.

Support the show

In the fourth episode of SuperSus, Amethyst and Ande explore a true crime story from the 1950s involving love, betrayal, and murder. The duo discusses the mysterious murder of Peter Fabiano, a beauty salon owner and World War II veteran who was fatally shot on Halloween night in Sun Valley, California. The case unfolds with an intricate web of relationships, featuring Peter's wife Betty, her close friend Joan Rabel, and Joan's associate Goldyne Pizer, who ultimately confessed to the crime. Through their discussion, the hosts highlight the complex dynamics of a love triangle gone wrong and the dark events that led to Peter's untimely death.

Support the show