The Devil Within

The Devil Within

By EVIO CreativeTrue Crime
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    1,377

    Followers

  • Typical duration

    25 min

    per episode

  • If it hooks

    58%

    finish an episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

The Devil Within episodes

  • The Girl in the Red Coat - Part One

    🩸 THE DEVIL WITHIN

    THE GIRL IN THE RED COAT

    EPISODE ONE: Into the Silent Woods

    (Chapters 1–3)

    In Episode One, we step into the cold, haunted shadow of Glastenbury Mountain—home to the

    legend of the Bennington Triangle and the mysterious, enduring disappearance of Paula Jean

    Welden, an 18-year-old Bennington College sophomore who walked onto the Long Trail one

    November afternoon in 1946… and was never seen again.

    Across three cinematic chapters, we explore:

    CHAPTER 1 — The Mountain That Remembers

    The strange history of Glastenbury Mountain, a place the Abenaki once warned was alive… a

    place where sound dies, compasses falter, and the forest seems to lean in and listen. Here we

    meet Paula: quiet, restless, radiant in her bright red parka—stepping onto the trail with no idea

    she is walking into a legend.

    CHAPTER 2 — The Search That Found Nothing

    The frantic multi-day search that drew hundreds into the freezing woods with lanterns, dogs, and

    fading hope. No footprints. No torn cloth. No trace. Even the red coat refused to be found.

    Searchers spoke of “silent pockets,” strange warmth in the air, radios that lagged by a heartbeat,

    and the creeping sense they were being watched by something old and patient.

    CHAPTER 3 — The Forest That Eats People

    Paula’s story is only one thread in a pattern of disappearances stretching across five years: a

    woodsman, a veteran, a child, a hiker. Five vanished. One mountain. Zero answers. As folklore

    and fact twist together, Glastenbury begins to look less like wilderness… and more like a

    presence that chooses who gets to walk back out.

    CALL TO ACTION (Episode One)If this episode stayed with you, if Paula’s red coat still appears in your imagination like a beacon

    in the trees, follow, rate, and review The Devil Within. Your support keeps the darkness lit.

    Explore the Evio Creative slate:

    The Devil Within • Criminal Mischief • Taboo Treasures • The Devil’s Ledger • The Ides of

    April

    Visit eviocreative.com and follow us on Instagram:

    @thedevilwithinpod • @eviocreative • @idesofaprilpod • @taboo_treasures

    SPONSORS (Episode One)

    QUINCE — Luxury essentials without the luxury markup

    👉 quince.com/IDES for free shipping & 365-day returns

    MINT MOBILE — Premium wireless for just $15/month

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

    EXPRESSVPN — Protect your data everywhere

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to four months free

    MOOD — Legal THC & CBD shipped nationwide

    👉 mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off

    OLLIE — Human-grade dog food delivered to your door

    👉 ollie.com/IDES for 60% off

    MONARCH MONEY — The modern way to manage your finances

    👉 monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    26 min
  • THE DEVIL’S LEDGER — Week of November 17th

    THE DEVIL’S LEDGER —

    Week of November 17th
    Featuring: The Creepiest Thing I Heard This Week — “The Empty Place Setting”
    Welcome back to The Devil’s Ledger, your weekly tour through everything happening across the Evio Creative Network. With Thanksgiving around the corner, we begin—as always—with The Creepiest Thing I Heard This Week.
    This time, we’re telling a story pulled straight from Midwestern legend: The Empty Place Setting — a Thanksgiving tradition kept alive by a family haunted by loss, ritual, and three slow knocks that return every year without fail.
    From there, we travel across the Evio network for a packed week of new episodes, deep dives, historical reckonings, and true-crime investigations.
    🎙️ THE CREEPIEST THING I HEARD THIS WEEK
    “The Empty Place Setting”
    A family in suburban Ohio sets an extra place at the Thanksgiving table every year — not for a late guest, but for a son who vanished thirty years ago. And every Thanksgiving night, when the house has gone still, someone knocks three times on their back door. Always three. Always slow. Always at the exact hour he disappeared.
    Footprints in the frost.
    Empty doorsteps.
    A ritual no one dares to break.
    This week’s Ledger opens with the tradition the Dawsons have kept alive — and the mystery that refuses to die.
    🔥 THIS WEEK ON THE DEVIL WITHIN
    The Thanksgiving Disappearance of Paula Jean Welden
    This Thanksgiving, The Devil Within heads into the fog-shrouded woods of the Bennington Triangle—the most notorious missing-persons cluster in New England history.
    We examine:
        •    Paula Jean Welden’s final walk into the mountains
        •    Conflicting eyewitness accounts
        •    The massive search effort that reshaped Vermont policing
        •    The unsettling pattern of disappearances that followed
        •    Why so many believe Glastenbury Mountain is cursed
    A holiday mystery that became a legend—and a legend that refuses logical explanation.
    🕯️ THIS WEEK ON THE IDES OF APRIL
    The Dagger & The Crown: The Assassination of Francisco Pizarro — Conclusion
    The final installment of our two-part historical miniseries arrives this week as we follow Francisco Pizarro into the last days of his life.
    Inside this cinematic finale.
    History ends not with thunder, but with footsteps—and these footsteps lead directly to his chamber door.
    ⚰️ THIS WEEK ON TABOO TREASURES
    The Most Dangerous Jobs in the World
    Bruce and Jeff dive into the stories of workers whose jobs were so perilous they bordered on self-destruction.
      A grim, jaw-dropping look at the human cost of corporate negligence—and the bravery of the people who fought back.
    🔎 THIS WEEK ON CRIMINAL MISCHIEF
    The Vanishing: The Unsolved Murder of Lindsey Baum
    Carolyn Ossorio revisits one of the most heartbreaking disappearances in the Pacific Northwest: the Lindsey Baum case.
    Carolyn is hoping renewed attention can help move the case forward.
    👉 If you have any information related to this case, email: ⁠[email protected]⁠
    🛒 SPONSOR SHOUT-OUTS
    Supporting our sponsors helps support all Evio Creative productions:
    Quince — luxury without the markup
    👉 ⁠quince.com/DEVILWITHIN for free shipping & 365-day returns
    Mint Mobile — premium wireless for $15/month
    👉 ⁠mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠
    ExpressVPN — privacy everywhere
    👉 ⁠expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠ for up to 4 months free
    MOOD — legal THC & CBD shipped nationwide
    👉 ⁠mood.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠ for 20% off
    Ollie — fresh, human-grade dog food
    👉 ⁠ollie.com/IDES⁠ for 60% off
    Monarch — the modern personal finance hub
    👉 ⁠monarch.com/IDES⁠ for 50% off your first year
    If you enjoy these worlds of true crime, dark history, paranormal legend, and cinematic storytelling, help us grow:
        •    Follow, rate, and review The Devil’s Ledger
        •    Visit ⁠eviocreative.com⁠
        •    Follow us on Instagram:
    @thedevilwithinpod • @eviocreative • @idesofaprilpod • @taboo_treasures
    Your support keeps the stories alive.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    15 min
  • The Hollywood Ending:The Matthew Tinling Case - Part Two


    🎧 THE DEVIL WITHIN: The Matthew Tinling Case — Part Two

    Chapters 4–6: The Trial of a Horror Fan · The Violence Doesn’t End Here · The Devil in the Mirror

    🔥 Description:

    After his arrest, Matthew Tinling faced the Old Bailey — calm, smiling, and proud.

    The prosecution called him “a man who mistook fiction for faith.”

    The jury called him guilty.

    And yet, inside the walls of HMP Belmarsh, the violence didn’t end.

    From his obsession with Jigsaw’s “rules” to a string of brutal attacks on fellow inmates, Tinling kept the game alive long after the cameras stopped rolling.

    But what if he wasn’t just a monster?

    What if he was a mirror — reflecting our own hunger for punishment disguised as justice?

    In this concluding episode, we follow Tinling from the courtroom to the cellblock, and finally into the cultural darkness that made him possible.

    ⚖️ Chapter 4 — The Trial of a Horror Fan

    🔪 Chapter 5 — The Violence Doesn’t End Here

    🪞 Chapter 6 — The Devil in the Mirror

    🎙️ Written & Hosted by: Branden Morgan

    🎚️ Produced by: Evio Creative / Bellaire Studios

    🎵 Sound Design & Score: The Evio Collective


    💬 Call to Action:

    If you finished this story and felt something staring back — that’s the point.

    Rate, review, and share The Devil Within to help new listeners find the darkness.

    🔗 Explore more at eviocreative.com and follow @thedevilwithinpod.

    🩸 Discover Criminal Mischief, Taboo Treasures, The Devil’s Ledger, and The Ides of April.


    💰 Sponsored By:

    👕 Quince — quince.com/DEVILWITHIN for free shipping + 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN.

    🧠 ExpressVPN — expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to 4 months free.


    🎙️ The Devil Within: The Matthew Tinling Case was written and hosted by Branden Morgan, produced by Evio Creative, mixed at Bellaire Studios, with original score and sound design by The Evio Collective.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    21 min
  • The Hollywood Ending: The Matthew Tinling Case - Part One

    🎧 THE DEVIL WITHIN: The Matthew Tinling Case — Part One

    Chapters 1–3: The Film in His Head · The Game Begins · Lessons in Fire and Blood

    💀 Description:

    In the spring of 2012, two men shared a small flat in a Maida Vale housing complex meant for people starting over.

    One of them — Richard Hamilton — was trying to rebuild after years of addiction.

    The other — Matthew Tinling — was watching Saw VI on repeat.

    When an argument over £240 in rent spiraled into obsession, Tinling turned the movie’s grotesque morality into real life.

    He stabbed Hamilton 17 times, tried to sever his spinal cord to recreate a trap from the film, and set the body on fire to “cleanse the scene.”

    Then he calmly withdrew money with Hamilton’s bank card… and bought crack.

    In this first episode, follow investigators as they untangle a killing staged like a screenplay — and meet the man who believed he was Jigsaw’s student.

    🩸  Chapter 1 — The Film in His Head

    🩸  Chapter 2 — The Game Begins

    🩸  Chapter 3 — Lessons in Fire and Blood

    🎙️ Written & Hosted by: Branden Morgan

    🎚️ Produced by: Evio Creative / Bellaire Studios

    🎵 Sound Design & Score: The Evio Collective


    💬 Call to Action:

    If this story left you uneasy — good.

    That means you were listening.

    Tap ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, leave a review, and share The Devil Within with someone who loves the dark corners of truth.

    🔗 Explore the Evio Slate: Criminal Mischief, Taboo Treasures, The Devil’s Ledger, and The Ides of April.

    🌐 Visit eviocreative.com and follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram for behind-the-scenes photos and archival materials.


    💰 Sponsors That Keep the Lights Low:

    👕 Quince — Luxury essentials at honest prices.

    👉 quince.com/DEVILWITHIN for free shipping + 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — Premium wireless for $15/month.

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN.

    🧠 ExpressVPN — Protect your data everywhere.

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to 4 months free.


    👁️‍🗨️ The Devil Within is a production of Evio Creative.

    All events are drawn from verified court transcripts and witness testimony.

    Some names and sounds have been altered for safety.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    23 min
  • The Devil's Ledger - Week of Nov. 10th.

    🎙️ The Devil’s Ledger – Week of November 10th

    👻 The Creepiest Thing I Heard This Week: The Plymouth Ghost Light

    Thanksgiving in Plymouth, Massachusetts has always been a blend of myth and memory — pilgrims, parades, and history lessons. But when night falls and fog rolls off Cape Cod Bay, a different tradition stirs.

    Witnesses report blue lanterns gliding through the mist each Thanksgiving night, moving silently from the harbor toward Burial Hill — the resting place of the earliest settlers. No footsteps. No voices. Just light drifting across stone and sea.

    First reported in 1983, and traced to 19th-century candlelit memorial walks for those who died the first winter, the phenomenon continues — always midnight to one. And the night Harold Baxter passed away, one of the ghostly lights flickered and vanished mid-procession.

    History says remembrance.

    Folklore says pilgrimage.

    Witnesses say they saw the dead go home.

    And tonight, they walk with us.


    📡 Evio Creative Network Spotlight

    🜏 The Devil Within

    A chilling new two-part series on Sean Sellers, the Oklahoma teen who claimed demonic possession led him to murder — and who became the last juvenile executed in modern U.S. history.

    ⛪ The Ides of April

    Part one of The Dagger and the Crown — the assassination of Francisco Pizarro.

    An empire washed in gold. Brothers bound by ambition and betrayal.

    History doesn’t crash — it bleeds.

    💎 Taboo Treasures

    Bruce & Jeff return with a sharp, no-limits dive into cultural forbidden zones.

    Topic TBD — but you know what they do with taboo.

    🔪 Criminal Mischief

    Carolyn Ossorio brings another case where truth outpaces fear.

    A story waiting in the vault — and it’s going to rattle you.


    🎬 This Week in Horror

    🌲 Keeper

    A cabin-in-the-woods nightmare — an anniversary trip turns into an ambush of paranoia, isolation, and dread that seeps into the walls.

    👹 Predator: Badlands

    A new entry in the Predator universe.

    Plot? Irrelevant.

    Expect blood, fear, and a hunt you won’t walk away from.


    🛠️ Sponsor Support

    Support the partners who fuel the shadows:

        •    Quince — luxury essentials without luxury markups

    👉 quince.com/DEVILWITHIN — Free shipping & 365-day returns

        •    Mint Mobile — wireless for $15/month

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    ExpressVPN — protect your privacy

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN — Up to 4 months FREE

        •    MOOD — legal THC & CBD shipped nationwide

    👉 mood.com/DEVILWITHIN — 20% off first order

        •    Ollie Dog Food — human-grade meals for dogs

    👉 ollie.com/IDES — 60% off your first box

        •    Monarch — transform your financial life

    👉 monarch.com/IDES — 50% off your first year


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    Subscribe on: Spotify • Apple Podcasts • YouTube

    Follow: @eviocreative • @thedevilwithinpod • @idesofaprilpod • @taboo_treasures

    And remember:

    History haunts.

    Folklore whispers.

    Sometimes the past walks at night.

    Keep your lantern lit.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    12 min
  • The Sean Sellers Story - Part Two

    🜏 THE DEVIL WITHIN

    The Sean Sellers Story — Part Two

    Chapters IV–VI: A Killer Reborn? Or a Script Well-Read?

    A prison cell can become a tomb—or a pulpit.

    In Part Two, we return to Sellers not as the eyeliner-clad teen who chanted to shadows, but as

    the soft-voiced inmate who prayed to Christ and mailed cassette-sermons across America. Sean

    Sellers reinvented himself. He claimed salvation. And in doing so, forced a country to ask

    whether redemption has limits—or if we only pretend to believe in change until the incarcerated

    actually change.

    Advocates saw a conversion story. Critics saw a performance. Psychologists saw untreated

    trauma. The state saw only the law.

    We follow his prison years, his religious awakening, the movement to spare his life, and the

    midnight hour in February 1999 when Oklahoma drew the curtain and pushed the chemicals. The

    only juvenile killer executed in modern American history — and the case that helped end

    juvenile death sentences forever.

    Did Sean Sellers find grace? Escape responsibility? Fool the world?

    Or did we witness something even harder to accept:

    A monster made at sixteen, a man made by solitude, and a soul no court could truly sentence?

    📜 Chapters

    • Chapter IV — The Confession Tapes

    A demon becomes a preacher; redemption meets skepticism.

    • Chapter V — The Executioner's Prayer

    A quiet last meal, a scripture-laden farewell, and a death chamber lit in fluorescent truth.

    • Chapter VI — A Shadow Over Innocence

    Legacy, law, and the ghost of a boy standing between morality and policy.

    🎧 Follow & ReviewSubscribe and leave a review — your voice brings others into the chapel and the courtroom.

    🕯 Evio Creative Network

    • The Devil’s Ledger

    • The Ides of April

    • Criminal Mischief

    • Taboo Treasures

    Follow: @thedevilwithinpod • @eviocreative

    🛠 Sponsor Shout-Outs

    • Quince → quince.com/DEVILWITHIN

    • Mint Mobile → mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

    • ExpressVPN → expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN

    • MOOD → mood.com/DEVILWITHIN

    • Ollie → ollie.com/IDES

    • Monarch → monarch.com/IDES

    Support the storytellers that keep the lights low and the truth sharp.

    🔮 Next Week on The Devil Within

    A new case begins — whispered prayers in a borrowed room, obsession disguised as prophecy,

    and a community that learns fear can bloom anywhere faith does.

    If God speaks in silence…

    what else might?

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    26 min
  • The Sean Sellers Story - Part One

    🜏 THE DEVIL WITHIN

    The Sean Sellers Story — Part One

    Chapters I–III: The Boy Who Called Himself Ezurate

    Before the headlines, before the courtroom sermons, before the televised tears, there was only a

    boy—born in California, raised across the plains of Oklahoma, and restless inside a world too

    small to hold the storm gathering in his head.

    In Part One, we walk into the dark heart of the 1980s, when Satanic Panic crackled across

    America like static, and fear of the occult seeped into living rooms as fast as MTV and

    microwave dinners. But this wasn’t a case of suburban hysteria clashing with teenage rebellion.

    This was a child who drifted—from fascination, to obsession, to ritual, and finally into violence.

    We follow Sean Sellers from lonely adolescence to Black Mass role-play that stopped being play.

    His journals filled with sigils, his world narrowed to demonology and control, until fantasy

    crossed the threshold into murder. A convenience-store clerk shot without a word. Parents killed

    as they slept. A teenager insisting he was possessed. A justice system unprepared for a killer still

    in high school.

    This is the first half of a tragedy where belief—real or claimed—becomes blood.

    🔪 Chapters

    • Chapter I — The Making of a Killer

    A childhood marked by drift, a mind marked by fracture, and a boy who began speaking

    the language of the occult.

    • Chapter II — A Pact in Blood

    The murders that shook Oklahoma — and a confession that blurred the line between

    belief and convenience.

    • Chapter III — The Trial of a Child

    Satanism meets jurisprudence in a courtroom that had no script for a teenage “demon

    prince.”

    🎧 Listen, Rate, Review

    Follow The Devil Within wherever you listen to podcasts.

    Your reviews help new listeners find the shadows.🕯 Evio Creative Network

    Explore more from the storytellers behind The Devil Within:

    • The Devil’s Ledger — weekly real-world hauntings, mysteries & folklore

    • The Ides of April — candle-lit historical storytelling

    • Criminal Mischief — true crime with Carolyn Ossorio

    • Taboo Treasures — forbidden history & cultural deep-dives

    Follow: @thedevilwithinpod • @eviocreative

    🛠 Sponsor Shout-Outs

    Support the brands who support this show:

    • Quince — timeless essentials, honest prices

    👉 quince.com/DEVILWITHIN — free shipping + 365-day returns

    • Mint Mobile — wireless for just $15/month

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

    • ExpressVPN — protect your privacy everywhere

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN — up to 4 months free

    • MOOD — legal THC & CBD shipped nationwide

    👉 mood.com/DEVILWITHIN — 20% off first order

    • Ollie Dog Food — fresh food for your best friend

    👉 ollie.com/IDES — 60% off your first box

    • Monarch — the platform for mastering your finances

    👉 monarch.com/IDES — 50% off your first year

    🕳 Next Week

    Part Two: A Broken Mind, A Saved Soul, and a Death Chamber in Oklahoma.

    A killer turned evangelist. A nation divided. And the last juvenile ever executed in America.The question shifts from “What did he do?”

    to “Can a soul be redeemed, even when the body cannot?”

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    26 min
  • 🎙️ The Devil’s Ledger - Week of Nov. 3rd.

    🎙️ The Devil’s Ledger - Week of Nov. 3rd.

    The Creepiest Thing I Heard This Week: The Vanishing Hitchhiker of Route 66

    On Thanksgiving night, 1971, a family driving the quiet stretch of Route 66 near Sapulpa, Oklahoma, encountered a barefoot girl in a torn white dress.

    She asked for a ride home.

    They wrapped her in a blanket.

    She vanished before they reached the house.

    What followed — a deserted foundation, a decades-old crash record, and sightings that recur every Thanksgiving — has made Mary Ellen one of the most haunting legends on America’s most famous road.

    Was she a desperate spirit looking for her family — or just a story truckers tell to stay awake on long night drives?

    Tonight, we ride along.


    🔎 This Week on the Evio Network

    🜏 The Devil Within

    A chilling new two-part series on Sean Sellers, the Oklahoma teen who claimed demonic possession drove him to murder — the last juvenile executed in modern U.S. history.

    ⛪ The Ides of April

    We conclude the epic saga of Pope John VIII, the first pope assassinated in office — a tale of power, betrayal, and a Vatican learning the limits of divine protection.

    💎 Taboo Treasures

    “Smart Phones, Dumb People” — Bruce Witkin & Jeff Levine trace our evolution from rotary phones to glowing rectangles and ask: Did our devices get smarter, or did we get dumber?

    🏚 Criminal Mischief

    “FEAR” — Carolyn Ossorio tells the chilling true story of Byron Smith, the Minnesota homeowner whose self-defense turned into a deadly ambush.


    🎬 This Week in Horror

    🧟 Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein

    Beautiful, grotesque, and haunting — a visionary retelling reminding us monsters aren’t born… they’re made.

    👵☠️ Dorothea: Portrait of a Killer Granny

    The unsettling true story of Dorothea Puente, who allegedly turned her boarding house into a graveyard and cashed the checks of the dead.


    🛠️ Sponsors

    Support the storytellers who keep the shadows close:

        •    Quince — timeless essentials without luxury markups

    👉 quince.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    Mint Mobile — premium wireless for $15/month

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    ExpressVPN — online privacy & security

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    MOOD — legal THC & CBD delivered nationwide

    👉 mood.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    Ollie Dog Food — human-grade meals for dogs

    👉 ollie.com/IDES

        •    Monarch — powerful personal finance platform

    👉 monarch.com/IDES


    📣 Follow & Subscribe

    Explore more from Evio Creative:

        •    The Devil Within

        •    The Devil’s Ledger

        •    Criminal Mischief

        •    Taboo Treasures

        •    The Ides of April

    Follow for drops & behind-the-scenes:

    @eviocreative · @thedevilwithinpod · @idesofaprilpod · @taboo_treasures

    Stay curious, stay skeptical…

    and stay out of the woods at night.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    13 min
  • A Prayer in Spring: REDUX - Part Two

    🕯️ The Devil Within — A Prayer in Spring: REDUX (Part Two)

    Presented by the Evio Creative Podcast Network

    In this second and final part of A Prayer in Spring: REDUX, Branden returns to Jefferson Township — not as an outsider, but as someone who can’t quite let go of the town that shaped his understanding of faith, tragedy, and the supernatural.

    It’s a homecoming of sorts: a drive down Berkshire Valley Road, through White Rock, and finally down the infamously haunted stretch of Clinton Road. What begins as a quiet spring morning soon becomes a meditation on evil, loss, and the ways grief can echo through a place long after the headlines fade.

    Branden recalls his first visit to Clinton Road in daylight — the peaceful forests and winding asphalt that hide centuries of whispered legends. But when he returns to the Sullivan home, intending to introduce himself to the new owners, he learns the unthinkable: another tragedy has unfolded in the same house where Betty Ann Sullivan was murdered in 1988.

    Within a single generation, two families have suffered unspeakable loss under the same roof. Whether coincidence or curse, Jefferson Township seems to exist on a knife’s edge between beauty and darkness.

    “It’s the people that leave. The house remains. The town remains. The forest remains. But something in the air here — something unseen — never lets go.”

    As the episode closes, Branden reflects on his connection to Jefferson: its resilience, its silence, and the way the town has learned to carry its ghosts quietly.

    “Despite the sorrow and horror that fueled my reasons for visiting, I’m reminded that this small town has weathered terrible tragedy — and endured. Maybe that’s the true nature of grace.”


    🌲 In This Episode

        •    Branden’s first visit to Clinton Road in daylight

        •    The disturbing discovery of a second tragedy inside the Sullivan home

        •    Reflections on evil, grief, and the possibility of something supernatural

        •    A meditation on Jefferson Township’s strength, faith, and quiet beauty


    💀 Credits

    Written and hosted by Branden Morgan

    Produced by Evio Creative in association with Bellaire Studios

    Original score and sound design by [Engineer Name]

    For press or partnerships, visit eviocreative.com (https://www.eviocreative.com/)


    🕯️ Sponsor Shoutouts

    Support The Devil Within and all Evio Creative shows by visiting our partners:

    🧥 Quince — timeless essentials at honest prices. Visit https://www.quince.com/DEVILWITHIN for free shipping and 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — premium wireless for just $15 a month. Visit https://www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text.

    🕵️ ExpressVPN — protect your data everywhere. Visit https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to four months free.

    🌿 MOOD — legal THC and CBD gummies shipped nationwide. Visit https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order.

    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — fresh, human-grade meals for your dog. Visit https://www.ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your welcome kit.

    💰 Monarch — take control of your finances at https://www.monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year.


    🎙️ Network CTA

    Listen to more from the Evio Creative Podcast Network, including The Ides of April, Criminal Mischief, The Devil’s Ledger, and Taboo Treasures.

    Follow @thedevilwithinpod, @idesofaprilpod, and @eviocreative for upcoming series announcements, behind-the-scenes content, and bonus episodes.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    25 min
  • A Prayer in Spring: REDUX - Part One

    🕯️ The Devil Within — A Prayer in Spring: REDUX (Part One)

    Presented by the Evio Creative Podcast Network

    This week, The Devil Within reaches the closing chapter of its season one re-release in support of the upcoming MGM+ docuseries Let the Devil In.

    In A Prayer in Spring: REDUX (Part One), Branden reflects on the final full episode of the original series — an episode that blends poetry, tragedy, and geography into a meditation on grief and faith in Jefferson Township.


    🎙️ Poetry Corner with Branden: “A Prayer in Spring” by Robert Frost

    The episode begins where it all began — with a poem.

    Robert Frost’s “A Prayer in Spring” becomes the anchor for a discussion of gratitude, impermanence, and surrender — how Frost’s plea to “keep us here, all simply, in the springing of the year” mirrors the Sullivans’ own brief, fragile peace before tragedy struck.

    Branden unpacks Frost’s lesser-known work and its place within the poet’s canon, contrasting its gentle acceptance with the melancholy of “Stopping by Woods,” “The Road Not Taken,” and “Nothing Gold Can Stay.”

    “It’s not joy Frost struggles with — it’s permission. Permission to enjoy something beautiful without waiting for it to end.”

    109 Redux


    🌲 The Newark Watershed

    The episode then turns to the land itself.

    Branden explores the Newark Watershed, a vast system of reservoirs and protected forest that spans 35,000 acres across Sussex, Morris, and Passaic counties — explaining how the isolation of this region helped shape the haunting stillness that defines northern New Jersey.

    “When people think of New Jersey and the only images conjured are Newark or Atlantic City… get up north and you’ll see why it’s called The Garden State.”

    109 Redux


    🕯️ The Sullivan Family’s Unfinished Story

    Finally, the episode revisits the Sullivan family’s grim aftermath.

    Years after Tommy Sullivan’s death, tragedy continued to follow.

        •    His brother Brian died by suicide just over a decade later.

        •    His aunt, Betty Ann’s sister, left behind her entire life after seeing the crime scene photos — and spent the next twenty years living as a cloistered nun.

    Branden recounts how investigators later tracked down members of the family and uncovered new, disturbing details about Tom Sullivan Sr., whose life and secrets take center stage in next week’s Part Two.

    “It seems the family just can’t escape tragedy — like it was written in blood in some cosmic contract that began that night.”

    109 Redux


    🔥 Next Time

    Part Two reveals what became of Tom Sullivan Sr. — the man at the heart of it all — and why his story changes everything you thought you knew about The Devil Within.


    💀 Credits

    Written and hosted by Branden Morgan

    Produced by Evio Creative in association with Bellaire Studios

    Original music and sound design by [Engineer Name]

    For press or partnerships, visit eviocreative.com (https://www.eviocreative.com/)


    🕯️ Sponsor Shoutouts

    Support The Devil Within and all Evio Creative shows by visiting our partners:

    🧥 Quince — timeless essentials at honest prices. Visit https://www.quince.com/DEVILWITHIN for free shipping and 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — premium wireless for just $15 a month. Visit https://www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text.

    🕵️ ExpressVPN — protect your data everywhere. Visit https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to four months free.

    🌿 MOOD — legal THC and CBD gummies shipped nationwide. Visit https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order.

    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — fresh, human-grade meals for your dog. Visit https://www.ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your welcome kit.

    💰 Monarch — take control of your finances at https://www.monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year.


    🎙️ Network CTA

    Listen to The Devil Within, The Ides of April, Criminal Mischief, Taboo Treasures, and The Devil’s Ledger — part of the Evio Creative Podcast Network.

    Follow @thedevilwithinpod, @idesofaprilpod, and @eviocreative for new episodes, bonus content, and production updates.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    30 min

About The Devil Within

From the publisher's feed

The Devil Within is a cinematic podcast about the stories that refuse to die — the legends, disappearances, curses, and supernatural encounters that linger long after the world moves on.

Best of The Devil Within

Ranked by our users in the last 21 days

More shows like The Devil Within

Generation Why: True Crime by Audible

Generation Why: True Crime

17,271 Listeners

The Vanished Podcast by Audible

The Vanished Podcast

15,168 Listeners

This Is Actually Happening by Audible

This Is Actually Happening

10,443 Listeners

Good Life Project by Jonathan Fields / Acast

Good Life Project

3,308 Listeners

Up and Vanished by Tenderfoot TV

Up and Vanished

62,797 Listeners

Already Gone Podcast by Nina Innsted

Already Gone Podcast

3,895 Listeners

True Crime All The Time by Emash Digital

True Crime All The Time

13,723 Listeners

The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories by Grip Tape

The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories

6,693 Listeners

American History Tellers by Audible

American History Tellers

19,146 Listeners

Business Wars by Audible

Business Wars

12,830 Listeners

Invisible Choir by Reach Freaks

Invisible Choir

5,399 Listeners

American Scandal by Audible

American Scandal

19,119 Listeners

Hell and Gone by iHeartPodcasts

Hell and Gone

7,439 Listeners

Culpable by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Culpable

22,192 Listeners

Park Predators by Audiochuck

Park Predators

18,043 Listeners

The Idaho Massacre by iHeartPodcasts

The Idaho Massacre

6,731 Listeners

Paper Ghosts: The Texas Teen Murders by iHeartPodcasts

Paper Ghosts: The Texas Teen Murders

6,233 Listeners

Unraveled by ID

Unraveled

10,535 Listeners

Against The Odds by Audible

Against The Odds

7,783 Listeners

Killer Psyche by Audible | Treefort Media

Killer Psyche

4,699 Listeners

The Binge Crimes: What Happened to the Harrisons? by Sony Music Entertainment

The Binge Crimes: What Happened to the Harrisons?

3,442 Listeners

Up and Vanished Weekly by Tenderfoot TV

Up and Vanished Weekly

464 Listeners