The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch

By Klaudia Amenábar, Ollie PhreshComedy TV & Film TV Reviews After Shows

The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch episodes

February 24Schnapple Tree Yard: Ep. 69 (nice)
Join Klaudia and Ollie for a prolonged discussion about the state of television and coverage of Supernatural S6E14: “Mannequin 3: The Reckoning.”
Points of Interest: Our triumphant return, a very earnest conversation about Heated Rivalry and a less earnest conversation about Stranger Things, drawing parallels to Johnlock, Marxist Revolutionary League of Legends Show, what happened to home-grown queerbait?, an unsponsored mattress promotion, Sam and Dean in the Culling Game, Glee jumpscare, the Winchesters’ have CTE, asking which Sex and the City girl Dean is, Lisa supports her gay boyfriend, a Bloody Mary callback, and an examination of what makes a procedural.
---
IMMIGRANT PROTECTION RESOURCES
Make the Road NY’s Deportation Defense Manual
WITNESS’ guide to filming ICE
The National Immigration Law Center’s guide to immigration warrants
The National Immigration Law Center’s guide of how to find a loved one if they are kidnapped by ICE
Wired’s guide on what to do if ICE invades your neighborhood
Detention Watch Network’s guide on how to connect with local organizers trying to shut down detention centers
How to support Minnesota’s immigrant communities
---
Queer Media Recommendations

Isekai Office Worker: The Other World’s Books Depend on the Bean Counter anime and light novel.

When the Tides Held the Moon by Venessa Vida Kelley

Lavender House by Lev AC Rosen

The Unworthy by Agustina Bazterrica

Pole Position by Rebecca J. Caffery

Futbolista by Jonna Garza Villa
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
1 hr 50 min
November 18, 2025 Bobby's Sassy Man Apocalypse: Ep. 68
Join Ollie and Klaudia for a traipse through Supernatural S6E12: "Like A Virgin," and S6E13: "Unforgiven."
Points of Interest: The Panera Ad, an ode to midseason finales, turning bulbasaur around, sex ed with John Winchester, an embarrassingly emotional World of Warcraft rant, the sin of not giving Cas a hug, a dragon with a truck, plot relevant flashbacks, the Dean Gender Binary, on-again off-again Bufus, her web literally connects us all, and choosing not to talk about breeding.
---
Listen to Ollie talk about The ICJ vs. Magneto on Mutant Studies 101: Spotify / Apple Podcasts
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
1 hr 55 min
November 04, 2025 WATCH-ALONG BONUS: Lazarus Rising
In honor of the five year anniversary of November 5th, 2020, Klaudia and Ollie present their LIVE commentary on Supernatural S4E1: "Lazarus Rising."
LIVE COMMENTARY STARTS AT 4:46
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
51 min
October 21, 2025 Getting Sam and Dean in Fortnite: Ep. 67
Join Klaudia and Ollie for a totally not off the rails recap of Supernatural S6E10: "Caged Heat" and S6E11: "Appointment In Samarra."
Points of Interest: “A transcript, a wiki, and a dream”, good old fashioned queerbaiting, “speaking of Omegaverse-”, the official Dean Winchester period tracker, PRESIDENTIAL ALERT: The girls are captured, Castiel’s pornographic DVD, Dick Cheney has kissed Crowley, Sam’s piss kink, Crowley is tastefully slutty, and Supernatural’s astronomical abandon warehouse budget.
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
1 hr 57 min
August 19, 2025 Socialized Supernatural Season 16 (feat. Meghan Fitzmartin): Ep. 66
Join Ollie, Klaudia, and special guest Meghan Fitzmartin as they draw back the curtain on Supernatural, and happen to recap S6E9: "Clap Your Hands If You Believe."
Points of Interest: Setting the scene for November 5th, an Omegaverse bombshell, new writer’s room position: Weird Freak Who’s Too Online, the argument for filler episodes, inheriting Dean Winchester’s music taste, monks were the earliest form of stans, pitching a Lisa-centric episode, getting pizza rolled, Dean’s most cancellable moments, leprechaun improv, and Sam's fraudulent NPR donations.
---
Follow Meghan on Bluesky / Instagram and preorder her upcoming comic, Mary Sue!
--
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
2 hr 13 min
August 12, 2025 Undercover Boss Crowley: Ep. 65
Join Klaudia and Ollie as they struggle through Supernatural S6E7: "Family Matters" and S6E8: "All Dogs Go to Heaven."
Points of Interest: Escaping before the point of no return, Crowley’s TikTok Shop grift, pre-recorded crowdwork, Sam’s younger sibling behavior, Samuel Campbell’s thoughts on queer discourse, 1950s housewife Cas, losing against the urge to nitpick, a fast food aside, Crobby second chance romance, soulless Sam is just a little guy, not even the worst episode about dogs, Bible fanfiction (not in a fun way), “Where the mpreg at?”, the ghost of Supernatural future, and the Benny/Garth spinoff.
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
2 hr 13 min
July 01, 2025 The Destiel Cream Cheese/Pill Theory: Ep. 64
Join Ollie and Klaudia as they trudge through Supernatural S6E6: "Live Free or Twihard" and S6E6: "You Can't Handle The Truth."
Points of Interest: It’s actually over, baby’s first fujo moment, destroying Twilight to save the media landscape, a different Dean in every scene, atmospheric thunder sounds, the heirs to the Campbell’s Soup fortune, “If Castiel was here, he would have made Dean pregnant.”, a Rachel Maddow-themed disagreement, “Come here, fujo!”, gaslight gatekeep Samboss, and a call for The Mystery Spotcast fanfiction.
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
2 hr 4 min
June 17, 2025 Balthazar's Brat Summer: Ep. 63
Join Klaudia and Ollie as they get into Supernatural S6E3: "The Third Man" and S6E4: "Weekend at Bobby's."
Points of Interest: Jensen Ackles queerbaiting is a recession indicator, the post-NDA Supernatural production tell-all, bragging about being the first omega, Rowena waiting to give Sam estrogen, Can Sam munch?, the Men of Letters bunker is the Supernatural Avengers tower, Yahoo! Answers user Bobby, Why Garth the bus driver?, pitching the young Bobby/Rufus TV show, put-upon mother Bobby, Chekhov’s wood chipper, and a literal dick measuring contest.
---
Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.
Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protests
Wired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital age
Follow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
2 hr 46 min
May 27, 2025 Sam and Dean's Cheesecake Factory Orders: Ep. 62
Join Ollie and Klaudia as they break into a new season, starting with Supernatural S6E1: "Exile on Main Street" and S6E2: "Two and a Half Men."
Points of Interest: Torturing Jared by making him watch Ahsoka, a diagetic “previously on” segment, Supernatural’s obsession with dilapidated sets, the in universe transvestigation of Dean, “Is it gay to own a magazine?”, canonical Mayflower descendants Sam and Dean Winchester, Dean’s “Old Enough”-esque diaper run, the Campbells are lowkey shady AF, and #GetDeanWinchesterPregnant.
---
Check out Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list
---
Resources for Palestine:
BDS: Act Now Against These Companies Profiting From the Genocide of the Palestinian People
BDS: What you can do about Israel's escalated crimes across the occupied West Bank
Decolonize Palestine: A collection of resources for organizers and anyone who wants to learn more about Palestine.
Follow BDS: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
- Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
- Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
- Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
1 hr 58 min
May 13, 2025 Grant Us a Dean (Winchester) Who Doubts: Ep. 61
Join Klaudia and Ollie as they recap the final episodes of the season, Supernatural S5E21: "Two Minutes to Midnight" and S5E22: "Swan Song."
Points of Interest: Good ending ≠ good ending, this happened in The Magnus Archives, Real ID killed Supernatural, getting sued for calling Dean gay, an extended conversation on improv comedy, Pestilence is one of our biggest fans, asking important questions (has the pope seen Supernatural?), Crobby has canonically kissed, Until Dawn plagiarized Supernatural, “Is it just me, or is Crowley a little problematic?”, stud Rufus, the Devil’s fidget spinner, Bobby’s big naturals, demon blood keg stand, Lucifer had Netflix in the cage, Sam said “be straight”, and exploding Castiel style.
---
Check out Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list
---
Resources for Palestine:
BDS: Act Now Against These Companies Profiting From the Genocide of the Palestinian People
BDS: What you can do about Israel's escalated crimes across the occupied West Bank
Decolonize Palestine: A collection of resources for organizers and anyone who wants to learn more about Palestine.
Follow BDS: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok
---
Follow us @MysterySpotcast on Bluesky / TikTok / Instagram / Tumblr
---
- Send us a question to our Tumblr ask box or email us at [email protected]
- Submit your favorite Destiel fic for us to read
- Fill out this form to submit a song for the Mystery Spotcast Official Playlist
2 hr 18 min

About The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch

From the publisher's feed

It’s been years since the CW’s Supernatural ended. So why is it still such a phenomenon, and why are its fans stuck in a superhell love/hate relationship with it? What is Destiel, and why is its…