In which Michelle elaborates on what makes a "hearty, well-balanced Supernatural episode," we explore the menacing connotations of playground spinny things, and Bethany bids farewell to Sam's cast. Also featured: listener feedback and a lively debate on qualifications for Sam-saves! (Starting around the 1 hr 25 min mark and continuing on for WAY too long...so if you are pressed for time, or conflict-averse, you can skip it. ;) We can't seem to help ourselves.) Remember: this podcast is riddled with spoilers all the way through Season 11! #sorrynotsorry We would love to hear from you! You can email us at [email protected]. You can leave us an iTunes review. Or you can comment on our brand new Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/groups/theplaidcast/

In which we discuss Dean's secret love for Little House on the Prairie, come up with our own duress code, and revisit the critical debate of how to define a Sam-save.

In which we discuss the convergence of the show's themes, the Winchesters as a superior Romeo and Juliet, and the questionable chemistry of sulfuric blood.

In which we experience lots of technical difficulties. :( (So sorry!) Discussion includes Faustian tales, ambition vs. desperation, and why Michelle loves goofer dust.

In which we discuss prison movies we need to see, Supernatural's open-minded women, and good cop Diana as a foil to Jo. Also featured: our official stances on the Samgirl-Deangirl spectrum, and continued exultation over SAM'S CAST.

In which we discuss condescending nicknames and whether Dean is sexist, and Bethany tricks Michelle into almost ranking things.

In which we argue over Andy's moral fiber, discuss Dante's categorizations of evil, and consider the name-veto prerogative of any doctor who brings baby "Ansem Weems" into the world.

In which we discuss our zombie apocalypse teams, power dynamics between younger and older siblings, and Bethany’s least favorite Winchester shirt. Also featured: your feedback on the highs and lows of season 1!

In which we discuss the continuity of Dean's violent nature, Bethany's vampire racism, and the impossible command to "taint not thy mind" when hunting evil. (Also introduced: new segment "Sam Carries Women," and the unofficial Plaidcast drinking game.)

In which we discuss the "full desertness" of Dean's grief and the tragic loss of Sam's bangs, while painstakingly avoiding all discussion of clowns.