
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity by David Graeber and David Wengrow does a great job at debunking the big histories of figures like Noah Yuval Harari and Stephen Pinker, but at a cost that ultimately undermines their argument.
In this discussion and critique of a wonderfully disruptive book, I outline their case and some of the evidence, argue that they are implicitly advocating a state of nature myth, based on reason not Eden or violence, and suggest that this, unwittingly, recolonises the past with modern secular reason.
But it’s a book very much worth engaging with!
0:44 Why they are right about retelling our back story.
4:50 Why they are right about emerging evidence for its endless complexity.
10:44 Tasters of the alternative Homo sapiens prehistory they tell.
18:20 And yet, what is crucially missing in their retelling.
28:22 How it recolonises the past with notions of secular reason, freedom and will.
33:19 The first cities as ritual sites and what that says about consciousness.
37:33 Why a demythologised past isn’t enough for our future.
By Mark Vernon4.9
1515 ratings
The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity by David Graeber and David Wengrow does a great job at debunking the big histories of figures like Noah Yuval Harari and Stephen Pinker, but at a cost that ultimately undermines their argument.
In this discussion and critique of a wonderfully disruptive book, I outline their case and some of the evidence, argue that they are implicitly advocating a state of nature myth, based on reason not Eden or violence, and suggest that this, unwittingly, recolonises the past with modern secular reason.
But it’s a book very much worth engaging with!
0:44 Why they are right about retelling our back story.
4:50 Why they are right about emerging evidence for its endless complexity.
10:44 Tasters of the alternative Homo sapiens prehistory they tell.
18:20 And yet, what is crucially missing in their retelling.
28:22 How it recolonises the past with notions of secular reason, freedom and will.
33:19 The first cities as ritual sites and what that says about consciousness.
37:33 Why a demythologised past isn’t enough for our future.

324 Listeners

367 Listeners

1,009 Listeners

602 Listeners

503 Listeners

1,644 Listeners

861 Listeners

88 Listeners

263 Listeners

354 Listeners

149 Listeners

1,838 Listeners

24 Listeners

791 Listeners

219 Listeners