Picture it: you’ve just made a dream come true by moving from the midwest to the beach. What could make it better? Oh right, the perfect guy. Joe Collier was seemingly the perfect man for Candy Williams. He was good looking, charming, smart, he seemed to have his act together. What’s not to like? Candy thought her search for the one was over. He spoiled her with gifts, he was always wanting to give her whatever she needed, he was so attentive to her.

But in April of 2006, she walked into her house to find what I would consider a horror scene. Every surface of the house was covered in thousands of post it notes, all of them saying something along the lines of I’m sorry, it’s too hard, I can’t do this. 

From here, Joe’s behavior became increasingly bizarre. Candy started to realize that he was not her perfect match. Just when she thought it couldn’t get any worse, she found out about…… the murders. 

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/creepers50 and and use code creepers50 for 50% off plus free shipping!

Better Help

Visit BetterHelp.com/CREEPERS today to get 10% off your first month

Brilliant Earth

Visit Brilliantearth.com to see all their beautiful jewelry!

Sources:

I Dated a Psycho (S1, E1) | Full Episode | LMN

A mother's pain, a dark secret

A teen killer's dark secret

Woman wants isle to know of killer's presence | Local News

Youth Convicted in Adoptive Parents' Murders Collects from Estate | AP News

Teen's Dark Secret: He Murdered His Family - ABC News

Peter Zimmer | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers

Ethan Allen School, Wisconsin Inmate Booking

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices