It’s 11:33 p.m. and Owen has brought Jimmy Tatro into bed with him. The real-life bros discuss childhood nostalgia and share their personal experiences with culture from the aughts (did you also watch Mean Girls sitting beside your crush?!). While Jimmy doesn’t actually explain to Owen what fantasy football is, he does talk about being last in both of his leagues and the punishments that await him (hint: it involves McDonald’s). Owen and Jimmy talk about the time they filmed a movie together, which happened to be the same period when Owen had an Outback Steakhouse addiction. Then, Jimmy shares his critique of the ending note riff in “Defying Gravity” and participates in a game of FMK featuring pancakes, French toast, and waffles. It’s Owen’s second episode with a straight man— kind of hot?

Follow and connect with all things @InYourDreams across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube.