Mineral Rights: Who Should Own What’s Under the Ground? Australia Case Study | Yaron Brook Show
(Season 12, Episode 168)
Watch now: https://youtube.com/live/9f2XBrckRO8
Who owns the gas under Australia? Is it 28 million Australians? The Crown? Or the people who spent A$234 billion turning 100 million years of worthless pressure in a rock into cargo bound for Japan?Australia is one of the world's biggest exporters of natural gas, and Melbourne is still heading for a gas shortage. Yaron Brook argues that the East Coast never ran out of gas. It ran out of permission slips.
In this episode, Yaron Brook takes on one of the oldest assumptions in politics: that what's under the ground belongs to "the nation." Australia's gas fight is the case study. The unions and Greens want a 25% tax on gas exports. The Labor government is passing a rule that forces producers to offer 20% of their exports to Australian buyers. Both proposals start from the same premise, "it's our gas." Yaron argues that premise is wrong.
Ownership requires the ability to use, sell and exclude, and no Australian can do any of those things with "his share" of a gas field. A resource is a thing in the ground plus a mind that knows what to do with it. The people who supplied that mind, and the money and the risk, were Shell, Chevron, Woodside and the Japanese utilities whose 20-year contracts paid for the plants. The state's claim is a leftover from British kings.
Don't miss the live Q&A with Ayn Rand vs. Phil Donahue on Middle Eastern oil and more!
This is a sponsored episode. Want to pick a topic for the show? Sponsor an episode.
👉 Subscribe for weekly shows on freedom, rational self-interest and individual rights.
Main topics
00:50 Who should own what's under the ground?
03:53 Australia is the #3 LNG exporter in the world, yet faces a gas shortage by 2028
06:45 Two proposals: a 25% export tax vs. a 20% domestic reservation
08:30 The hidden premise: "It's Australia's gas"
14:46 How Japanese contracts & foreign capital built Western Australia's gas industry
19:46 WA's 15% rule, and why setting terms in advance matters
27:26 The gas under their feet: Victoria's constitutional fracking ban
29:37 "They didn't run out of gas. They ran out of permission slips."
29:58 Europe made the same mistake
34:32 Windfall profits and "economic rent": the case for the tax
36:33 A resource tax that raises less than beer tax
42:28 Who owns the gas? There's no such thing as collective ownership
43:05 Mineral rights came from kings. Why the US is the exception
46:02 A resource = a rock + a mind (Rand, Julian Simon, Alex Epstein)
48:11 A "fair return"?
49:16 12 million Americans get royalty checks, and that's why the US drills
53:40 Why Norway's 78% tax "works," and Australia's plan is its opposite
55:13 Why a revenue tax is especially destructive
57:25 Britain's windfall tax: investment went from $14B to $2B a year
1:00:26 Why the gas industry keeps losing
1:06:00 The strongest case for the 20% reservation
1:09:21 The "three companies control 90%" argument, answered
1:11:31 Twenty years of Western Australia's reservation: what it actually did
1:17:09 The Abundance Program: privatize the minerals
1:20:53 Abolish the rent tax, set a 12-month approval clock, go nuclear, build pipelines
1:25:23 Tax supporters: do you want the money or the gas?
1:27:14 This is coming to America
Live Q&A
1:31:26 Is Trump buying stakes in companies the Australian model?
1:33:19 Is Australia a lost cause for liberty?
1:37:43 Mad Max: Australia's warning about oil shortages
1:43:12 Elon's flying car: real or hype?
1:46:13 Ayn Rand vs. Phil Donahue: whose oil was it?
1:48:53 Why do monarchies still exist?
1:50:14 Is immigration to blame for Australia's housing shortage?
1:52:18 Does Israel prove a country doesn't need immigrants?
1:54:43 Would a capitalist country allow a voluntary kibbutz?
#MineralRights #PropertyRights #Australia #NaturalGas #LNG #oilreserve #naturalresource #Libertarian #Affordability #Capitalism #AynRand #EnergyPolicy #DrillBabyDrill
the overview above is written by YaronAi Like this episode
Subscribe, share it with friends, and become a Patreon supporter to access monthly AMAs, exclusive content, and commercial-free audio.
The Yaron Brook Show is Sponsored by
[The Ayn Rand Institute](https://www.aynrand.org/starthere)
[Energy Talking Points, featuring AlexAI, by Alex Epstein](https://alexepstein.substack.com/)
[Express VPN](https://www.expressvpn.com/yaron)
[Hendershott Wealth Management](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4lfC...) &
(https://hendershottwealth.com/ybs/)
[Michael Williams & The Defenders of Capitalism Project](https://www.DefendersOfCapitalism.com)
[Support the Show]( / yaronbrookshow )
[Sponsor the Show](
[email protected]/)
[One-time donation](https://bit.ly/2RZOyJJ)
Join the [Yaron Brook Show YouTube channel]( / @yaronbrook )
Like what you hear? Like, share, and subscribe to stay updated on new videos and help promote the [Yaron Brook Show](https://bit.ly/3ztPxTx)
Continue the discussion by following Yaron on [Twitter](https://bit.ly/3iMGl6z) and [Facebook](https://bit.ly/3vvWDDC )
Want to learn more about Ayn Rand and Objectivism? 🎓 Learn more about [Ayn Rand University](https://bit.ly/35qoEC3)
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/yaron-brook-show--3276901/support.
Yaron is the executive chairman of the Ayn Rand Institute and a world class speaker. He is the coauthor of the national best-seller
Free Market Revolution: How Ayn Rand’s Ideas Can End Big Government,
Equal is Unfair: America's Misguided Fight Against Income Inequality and
In Pursuit of Wealth: The Moral Case for Finance. He speaks around the world on a variety of topics including the morality of capitalism, Ayn Rand and her philosophy, finance and economics, and the value of inequality.