In this episode, we climb to the top of one of Key West’s most iconic landmarks—the Key West Lighthouse. But it’s not just the view that’ll give you chills. Visitors and staff have reported shadowy figures, disembodied footsteps, and a mysterious woman in white, believed to be the spirit of the first female lighthouse keeper. From unexplained lights to eerie sensations in the tower, this haunted lighthouse has plenty of ghost stories to keep you up at night.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. Or you can email us a [email protected]. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

At the heart of Old Town Key West stands a historic hotel with a dark reputation. This week, we’re checking into the La Concha — a beautiful, iconic building that hides a chilling past. From phantom footsteps in empty hallways to whispers from long-gone guests, the hotel has been the site of countless ghostly encounters. Some say spirits of those who jumped — or were pushed — from the rooftop bar still linger. Others speak of a restless elevator that moves on its own, carrying something unseen. Whether it’s the hotel’s tragic history or something darker, La Concha has earned its title as one of the most haunted spots in the Keys. Sleep tight… if you can.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. Or you can email us a [email protected]. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

Deep in the mangroves of the Florida Keys, something ancient might be watching. This week, we uncover the eerie legend of the Skunk Ape — a towering, hairy creature said to haunt the backwoods and backwaters of South Florida. While most sightings come from the Everglades, locals in the Upper Keys whisper of strange howls in the night, rustling in the buttonwood groves, and a stench so strong it chills you to the bone. Could the Skunk Ape have made its way down the Keys? Or has it always been here, hiding in plain sight? Tune in as we explore the dark corners of the Keys where the road ends — and the legends begin.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. Or you can email us a [email protected]. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

Banshee Show Notes

In this episode, we head across the Atlantic to dive into one of Ireland’s most chilling legends—the Banshee. Said to be a ghostly woman with a bone-chilling wail, the Banshee is believed to appear before a death in the family. Sometimes she’s seen brushing her long hair, other times she’s just heard crying in the distance. Is she a harbinger of doom, or just misunderstood? Either way, her scream will haunt your dreams.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. Or you can email us a [email protected]. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

In this episode, we take a stroll through one of Key West’s most iconic spots—the Hemingway Home. But it’s not just famous for its history and six-toed cats. Visitors say the ghost of Ernest Hemingway still lingers, with reports of shadowy figures, phantom footsteps, and even the sound of an old typewriter clicking away. Some even claim his wife Pauline makes the occasional ghostly appearance too. Literary legend... or lingering spirit? You decide.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

In this episode, we head to Key West to check out one of the most haunted bars in America—Captain Tony’s Saloon. Once a morgue and the site of public hangings, this bar has no shortage of ghost stories. From the Lady in Blue who’s said to haunt the women’s restroom, to eerie encounters around gravestones inside the bar, Captain Tony’s is dripping with spooky history. Grab a drink, and toast the ghost as we dive the wild side of Captain Tony’s.

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

Visit our socials!

Instagram:  @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook:  You Two Scare Me Podcast

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

In 1930, in Key West, Florida, a man named Carl Tanzler met, and became captivated by a 22 year old, dark haired beauty named Elena Hoyos. The problem? They both were married, she was completely uninterested, and…she was dying of tuberculosis. That didn’t stop Carl from trying to woo her! This is the twisted tale of a man so fixated on a woman that his obsession with her continued even after her death. 

Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? 

Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!

Visit our socials!

Instagram:  @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook:  You Two Scare Me Podcast

The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast

Meet Robert the Doll — Key West’s creepiest resident. This century-old toy has a haunted history and a reputation for cursing anyone who disrespects him. Now housed at the Fort East Martello Museum, Robert draws thrill-seekers and skeptics alike. Snap a pic without asking… and you might regret it.

Visit our Socials!

Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast

Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast

TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast