Counselor Chat Podcast

137. Reframing Behavior: From Punishment to Problem-Solving


Listen Later

In this week's podcast we look at pre-holiday behavior spikes through a problem-solving lens. Instead of “How do we punish this?” we ask, “What skill is missing?” She models restorative conversations, shares reflection tools that build self-awareness, and walks through calm-down strategies that help students regulate before you problem-solve.

Key takeaways

  • Behavior = communication. Shift from “what’s wrong with the student?” to “what’s happening for the student?”
  • Use restorative approaches: understand harm, take responsibility, repair relationships, restore trust.
  • Reflection > reaction: guided behavior reflection sheets connect thoughts, feelings, needs, and next steps.
  • Regulation first: you can’t consequence a child into calm; teach calming tools, then problem-solve.
  • Mindset shift: connection before correction; growth over guilt.

Try-it-now tools

Restorative questions:

  • What happened? • What were you thinking/feeling? • Who was affected & how? • What makes it right? • What will you do next time?

Behavior Reflection prompts:

  • Trigger • Feeling • Need • Better choice next time • Who to repair with & how (what a real apology looks/sounds like).

Calm-down strategies:

  • Square/5-finger breathing, grounding (5–4–3–2–1), movement/water break, sensory tools (rings, stress balls), feelings check-ins/thermometers.

Scenario highlight

  • “Jayden in the line”: Instead of office + lecture, Carol uses a brief restorative chat/circle + reflection sheet to move from guilt to growth and repair.

Counselor moves to start this week

  1. Model restorative conversations (skip “Why did you do that?”).
  2. Teach emotion language (feeling wheels, visuals, daily check-ins).
  3. Build a Behavior Reflection Toolkit for you and teachers.


Quote to remember

“Punishment might stop the behavior, but it doesn’t heal what’s underneath. Problem-solving does.”

Connect

  • Follow Carol on IG: @counselingessentials
  • Share what’s in your calm-down kit and tag the show!


Think Sheets


Grab the Show Notes: Counselingessentials.org/podcast


Join Perks Counseling Club Membership and get the lessons, small group and individual counseling materials you need. Join now and get your first month free when you sign up for 3 months!


Connect with Carol:

  • TpT Store
  • Counseling Essentials Website
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Elementary School Counselor Exchange Facebook Group
  • Caught In The Middle School Counselors Facebook Group
  • High School Counselor Connection Facebook Group

Mentioned in this episode:

Perks Membership

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Counselor Chat PodcastBy Carol Miller, School Counselor

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

64 ratings


More shows like Counselor Chat Podcast

View all
Happier with Gretchen Rubin by Gretchen Rubin / The Onward Project

Happier with Gretchen Rubin

12,931 Listeners

The Lazy Genius Podcast by Kendra, The Lazy Genius

The Lazy Genius Podcast

6,674 Listeners

WHOA That's Good Podcast by Sadie Robertson Huff

WHOA That's Good Podcast

13,197 Listeners

On Purpose with Jay Shetty by iHeartPodcasts

On Purpose with Jay Shetty

27,676 Listeners

Flusterclux With Lynn Lyons: For Parents Who Worry by Lynn Lyons LICSW, Robin Hutson

Flusterclux With Lynn Lyons: For Parents Who Worry

461 Listeners

IMO with Michelle Obama and Craig Robinson by Higher Ground

IMO with Michelle Obama and Craig Robinson

12,770 Listeners

School Counseling Simplified Podcast by Rachel Davis

School Counseling Simplified Podcast

101 Listeners

Huberman Lab by Scicomm Media

Huberman Lab

29,266 Listeners

Mayim Bialik's Breakdown by Mayim Bialik

Mayim Bialik's Breakdown

5,332 Listeners

Good Inside with Dr. Becky by Dr. Becky Kennedy

Good Inside with Dr. Becky

4,523 Listeners

School for School Counselors Podcast by School for School Counselors

School for School Counselors Podcast

218 Listeners

The Mel Robbins Podcast by Mel Robbins

The Mel Robbins Podcast

20,139 Listeners

High School Counseling Conversations® by Lauren Tingle, School Counselor

High School Counseling Conversations®

54 Listeners

Candid Counselors by Brian Coleman and Olivia Carter

Candid Counselors

8 Listeners

The Oprah Podcast by Harpo

The Oprah Podcast

1,563 Listeners