Love Shack Live: Helping Couples Rescue Their Relationships

#259: The Truth About Avoidant Attachment... It’s Not What You Think (Part One)


Listen Later

Send a text

Have you ever walked away from a conversation thinking, “Why did I do that… again?”

You care. You love them. You want it to work. And yet when things get intense, you shut down, go quiet, and disappear emotionally.

In this episode of Love Shack Live, we unpack what avoidance really is (hint: it’s not a character flaw) and why shutting down is often a nervous system protection strategy that once worked really well… but now costs you connection.

You’ll learn what’s happening inside the avoidant partner, why the anxious partner panics when the conversation goes silent, and how this dynamic can trap both people in a loop of pressure, withdrawal, and resentment.

Most importantly, we’ll show you a different path: building emotional safety and emotional capacity in small, practical steps so you can come back to the table without spiraling or disappearing.

Because shutting down isn’t who you are. It’s what you learned.

And you can learn something new.

In This Episode, We Cover

  • Why emotional withdrawal is one of the strongest predictors of relationship breakdown
  • The real reason avoidance happens (and why it can feel like danger in the body)
  • What anxious partners often do in response, and why it accidentally makes things worse
  • How both partners end up in “shutdown” in different ways
  • The shift from courtroom energy (punishment + certainty) to classroom energy (curiosity + skill-building)
  • What emotional safety actually is (and why it’s not the same as comfort)
  • A simple “start here” practice: rebuilding safety in 5-minute rounds
  • A quick emotional temperature check (1–10) to know when you’re resourced enough to talk
  • How to get support if you’re stuck in the avoidant/anxious loop

Timestamps: 

03:08 Debunking the ‘They Don’t Care’ Story: Everyone Can Be Avoidant

04:13 What Shutdown Feels Like in the Body (A Real-Life Example)

07:42 Pressure Makes It Worse: The Partner’s Panic & the Stories We Make Up

08:40 Anxious vs. Avoidant: Opposite Coping Styles Collide

09:48 The CPR Metaphor: Why Reassurance Can Feel Suffocating

11:55 Shame, Self-Judgment, and the Spiral on Both Sides

21:52 The Real Goal: Regulate First, Then Come Back to the Table

25:54 ‘Understand Me First’: How Conversations Turn Into Fights

27:55 Be the First to Listen: How One Person Can De‑escalate the Fight

28:56 Understanding Isn’t Contagious: Compassion for Anxious vs. Avoidant Dynamics

30:57 Stop Making Up Stories: Get the ‘Intel’ From the Person, Not Your Head

33:12 The Consensus Trap: Why Friends & Social Media Can’t Explain Your Partner

35:45 “They Don’t Deserve It” vs. “You Do”: Regulate for Your Own Sake

38:18 Courtroom vs. Classroom: Trade Punishment for Curiosity (and the Lightbulb Moment)

41:32 Emotional Safety 101: It’s Uncomfortable, Triggering, and Still Necessary

42:28 The Safety ‘Cheat Sheet’: Slow, Skillful Back‑and‑Forth (5 Minutes at a Time)

50:09 Wrap-Up + Get Support: Key Takeaways, Next Episode, and Clarity Call

52:05 Emotional Capacity ‘Temperature Check’ + Closing Rituals

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Love Shack Live: Helping Couples Rescue Their RelationshipsBy Staci Bartley, Relationship Expert

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

49 ratings


More shows like Love Shack Live: Helping Couples Rescue Their Relationships

View all
Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

Hidden Brain

43,534 Listeners

Love Life With Matthew Hussey by Matthew Hussey

Love Life With Matthew Hussey

2,681 Listeners

Crime Junkie by Audiochuck

Crime Junkie

369,807 Listeners

Let’s Get Vulnerable: Relationship and Dating Advice by Dr. Morgan Anderson

Let’s Get Vulnerable: Relationship and Dating Advice

1,144 Listeners

Healing Honeys with Louise Rumball by Louise Rumball

Healing Honeys with Louise Rumball

128 Listeners

Pillow Talks by Vanessa & Xander Marin

Pillow Talks

2,502 Listeners

On Attachment by Stephanie Rigg

On Attachment

1,067 Listeners

The Mel Robbins Podcast by Mel Robbins

The Mel Robbins Podcast

20,816 Listeners