The Premed Years

611: From Toronto to a US Med School After Three Cycles


Listen Later

(00:00) — Welcome and setup: Ryan tees up Bayley’s many cycles and lessons learned.

(00:45) — Early spark and Canada: Bayley shares deciding on medicine in grade 6/7.

(01:52) — Family in healthcare: Great‑grandfather physician; dad a dentist.

(02:20) — Undergrad choices in Canada: Picking science, not chasing a perfect premed program.

(03:49) — College admissions contrast: Canada’s stats focus vs US extracurricular emphasis.

(05:22) — Redefining premed: Framing premed as exploration to reduce guilt and pressure.

(06:26) — Comparison trap: Managing competitive vibes and putting on blinders.

(07:47) — Study style and self‑care: Solo studying, later groups, and protecting wellness.

(09:21) — Reduced course load: Owning a lighter load, taking five years without shame.

(10:02) — Outcome perspective: Different timelines still lead to medical school.

(12:39) — Time to apply: Transitioning from university to medical school applications.

(12:57) — Canada vs US apps: Fewer essays in Canada; US holistic review felt better.

(15:09) — Why clinical matters: Exposure is for students’ clarity, not just checkboxes.

(16:00) — Shadowing isn’t TV: A surgery shadow shows reality vs Grey’s Anatomy.

(16:38) — MCAT in Canada: One notable exception and English‑centric testing.

(17:20) — Planning for US prereqs: Adding physics and English with MSAR research.

(18:26) — Tough courses and pivots: Dropping physics, later returning, switching to psych science.

(19:20) — Ontario activity limits: 150 characters vs robust US activity narratives.

(21:02) — Targeting schools: Using MSAR and class lists for Canadian‑friendly programs.

(22:15) — First cycle post‑mortem: Average stats, few experiences, and gap‑year growth.

(23:54) — Shadowing hurdles: Connections, policies, and making it happen in Toronto.

(25:27) — Asking creates access: Hospital work chit‑chat leads to a cath lab invite.

(26:48) — Fear of no: Shoot your shot and let go of rejection anxiety.

(27:43) — Cycle one results: 25 applications, zero interviews, recalibrating hope.

(28:46) — Masters for GPA: Course‑based program to show academic growth.

(30:20) — Two MCAT attempts: Modest improvement and knowing when to stop.

(31:25) — Getting guidance: A Canadian advisor educated in the US helps refine essays.

(32:36) — Second cycle strain: Secondary fatigue and financial triage.

(33:19) — Not quitting: No plan B and deepening motivation.

(34:39) — Feedback famine: Few adcom replies; rewriting with a clearer purpose.

(36:32) — Third cycle strategy: No new MCAT, full‑time research, sharper narrative.

(37:16) — First interview at last: An October invite that didn’t feel real.

(38:18) — MMI and Casper prep: Practice, rationale, and recording answers.

(40:53) — Waitlisted: Reading patterns and managing the long limbo.

(42:16) — Stay visible: Zoom events, questions, and an on‑campus introduction.

(43:56) — May 1 acceptance: The work‑day email, camera rolling, parents on speed dial.

(46:02) — Crossing the border: Visas, timelines, and being the only Canadian in class.

(47:35) — Family faith: The sticky note and sweatshirt that predicted MD 2028.

(48:36) — Closing advice: Believe in yourself, keep learning, and keep asking.

Bayley joins Dr. Gray to unpack three application cycles that ended with a single US interview, a waitlist, and a May 1 acceptance. Bayley shares how she managed comparison culture, chose a reduced course load without shame, and why the US’s essay‑driven, holistic review resonated more than Canada’s stats‑heavy process. She breaks down the real shadowing barriers in Canada and how working in a hospital, talking to people, and simply asking created opportunities. Bayley explains how gap years—hospital roles, retail, and pediatric research—built maturity and clarity, not just checkboxes. She walks through building a smarter school list using MSAR and class data, the value of clear narratives in essays, and practical MMI/Casper prep that focused on articulating rationale, not rehearsed lines. From zero interviews to one that mattered, Bayley stayed visible during the waitlist limbo—showing up to Zoom events, asking questions, and even driving to introduce herself to admissions. If you’re navigating setbacks, you’ll find tangible strategies, candid reflection, and a reminder to protect your wellness, believe in your strengths, and keep shooting your shot.


What You'll Learn:

- Key differences between Canadian and US admissions—and why essays and experiences matter

- How to identify Canadian‑friendly US schools using MSAR and class data

- Ways to build meaningful experiences during gap years without box‑checking

- Practical MMI/Casper prep that highlights your decision‑making rationale

- How to handle waitlists, stay visible, and advocate for yourself

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Premed YearsBy Ryan Gray

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

1,262 ratings


More shows like The Premed Years

View all
TED Radio Hour by NPR

TED Radio Hour

21,934 Listeners

Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

Hidden Brain

43,547 Listeners

The Short Coat: An Inside Look at Getting Into and Getting Through Medical School by The Students of the University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine

The Short Coat: An Inside Look at Getting Into and Getting Through Medical School

307 Listeners

Jocko Podcast by Jocko DEFCOR Network

Jocko Podcast

30,856 Listeners

OldPreMeds Podcast by Ryan Gray

OldPreMeds Podcast

149 Listeners

The MCAT Podcast by Ryan Gray

The MCAT Podcast

533 Listeners

Specialty Stories by Ryan Gray

Specialty Stories

210 Listeners

White Coat Investor Podcast by Dr. Jim Dahle of the White Coat Investor

White Coat Investor Podcast

2,462 Listeners

Dr. Matt and Dr. Mike's Medical Podcast by Dr Mike Todorovic

Dr. Matt and Dr. Mike's Medical Podcast

561 Listeners

Ologies with Alie Ward by Alie Ward

Ologies with Alie Ward

24,550 Listeners

This Podcast Will Kill You by Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

This Podcast Will Kill You

17,004 Listeners

Ask Dr. Gray: Premed Q&A by Ryan Gray

Ask Dr. Gray: Premed Q&A

77 Listeners

The Peter Attia Drive by Peter Attia, MD

The Peter Attia Drive

8,601 Listeners

MCAT Basics (from MedSchoolCoach) by MedSchoolCoach

MCAT Basics (from MedSchoolCoach)

631 Listeners

Life Kit by NPR

Life Kit

4,855 Listeners

All Access: Med School Admissions by Christian Essman

All Access: Med School Admissions

224 Listeners

Short Wave by NPR

Short Wave

6,574 Listeners

Huberman Lab by Scicomm Media

Huberman Lab

29,338 Listeners

Jack Westin MCAT Podcast by Jack Westin

Jack Westin MCAT Podcast

75 Listeners