Send us a text

What happens when your friends start talking about demons, portals, and zombies? On October 2, 2020, key insider Zulema Pastenes sat down with police and described the chilling, bizarre reality of her life inside Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell's inner circle.

In this special dramatized episode, Afterglow takes you inside the interrogation room to hear Zulema's own story. Listen as she details the "web of lies and deceit" woven by the "master manipulators," the doctrine of "multiple creations" that placed them above the law, and the terrifying belief that Charles Vallow was no longer human, but a zombie named "Hiplos." This is the firsthand account of how a group of seemingly normal people were convinced that murder was a divine mission, culminating in the shocking justification from killer Alex Cox: "It was a zombie that I killed."

AI voices are the actors in the dramatization. 

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

"Whispers from the Cell" takes you inside the chilling conversation between Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell, recorded just one day before the bodies of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan were found. What secrets lay hidden in their coded language and religious fervor? We break down the June 8th jail call, a key piece of evidence in the Idaho cult murder trial, revealing their belief in a "millennial day within Zion" and their claims of contact with the deceased Alex Cox. Hear the unsettling details of their "project" and understand the implications of this pivotal recording. Join us on Afterglow: The Unveiling of the Idaho Cult as we explore the darkest corners of this shocking case. #LoriVallowTrial #ChadDaybellTrial #IdahoMurders #CultPodcast #TrueCrimeCommunity #MissingChildren #EvidenceAnalysis #JailCall #ReligiousCult #TrueCrimeStory #Afterglow #PodcastEpisode

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Summer Shiflet found herself at the center of a storm in the Daybell case. This episode explores her emotional journey, beginning with a deeply moving jailhouse call from her sister, Lori Vallow Daybell, just eleven days after the children's bodies were found. We then analyze the explosive recording of her conversation with prosecutor Rob Wood, which ignited claims of prosecutorial misconduct. "Eleven Days After: Sisters in Conflict" reveals the complex and conflicting loyalties Summer faced, and the pivotal role she played in the unfolding investigation.

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Join us as we explore the circumstances surrounding Joe Ryan's death, the third husband of Lori Vallow. We present police interviews from 2020, where detectives attempt to verify claims that Tylee Ryan had a key to Joe's apartment and entered it after his passing. Listen as we analyze the detective's questioning, the initial autopsy findings, and the questions that remain unanswered. How does this connect to the larger narrative of Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell, and the series of suspicious deaths surrounding them? Discover the complexities of this investigation in 'The Key to Joe Ryan's Apartment.'"

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Who was Alex, really?  In this gripping episode of Afterglow, we hear from two women who loved him: his ex-wife and his fiancée.  Their recollections of Alex are strikingly different, raising questions about the nature of truth and memory.  As their stories unfold, a complex portrait of Alex emerges, one filled with love, loss, and unanswered questions.  Join us as we try to unravel the mystery surrounding Alex in this emotional and thought-provoking episode.

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

This episode continues our deep dive into the Charles Vallow case, focusing on Melanie Gibb's second interview with Chandler PD on August 19, 2020. Melanie's testimony sheds light on the events leading up to Charles' death, including the disturbing claims of his "possession" and the alleged "prayer circles." We analyze the inconsistencies in Melanie's account and explore the potential influence of Chad Daybell's extreme beliefs. The episode also examines the controversial "patriarchal blessing" Chad gave to Alex Cox. This is just the beginning – more police interviews, including Serena Sharp, Nicole, Christina, Jason Mow, and Zulema, are on the horizon, promising further revelations in this complex and tragic case.

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Delve into the complexities of Melanie Gibb in this episode of Afterglow: Unveiling the Idaho Cult, Season 4, Episode 2: The Many Faces of Melanie Gibb. We analyze the pivotal police interview conducted at the Chandler Police Station, where Gibb discusses her knowledge of Charles Vallow's death. As a close friend of Lori Vallow Daybell and an active member of the "Preparing a People" movement, Gibb's testimony is crucial. Yet, inconsistencies and her insistence that she never truly believed the teachings of Chad Daybell raise questions.

This episode dissects the interview, highlighting the moments that cast doubt on her claims. Was she a naive follower, or did she play a more significant role in the events surrounding the deaths of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan? We explore her relationship with David Warwick, her deep involvement in the fringe religious group, and the now-infamous recorded phone call between her, Lori, and Chad. Discover the many faces of Melanie Gibb and decide for yourself what to believe.

Keywords: Afterglow Unveiling the Idaho Cult, Melanie Gibb, Lori Vallow Daybell, Chad Daybell, Charles Vallow, JJ Vallow, Tylee Ryan, David Warwick, Chandler Police Station, police interview, Preparing a People, doomsday cult, true crime, Idaho, Rexburg, investigation, testimony, lies, deception, recorded phone call, missing children, murder, Arizona

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Afterglow: Unveiling the Idaho Cult returns for Season 4 with a pivotal episode: Red Pajamas, Raccoons, and a Jailhouse Call - The Beginning of the End for Chad Daybell. This episode dives deep into the crucial preliminary hearing of Chad Daybell held in August 2020, before the murder charges were filed. We hear from three key witnesses whose testimonies began to unravel the web of deceit surrounding the disappearances of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan, the children of Lori Vallow Daybell.First, David Warwick recounts the chilling night he last saw JJ Vallow, wearing red pajamas, with Alex Cox. Then, listen to the damning jailhouse phone call between Lori and Chad Daybell the day the children's bodies were discovered on Chad's property. Finally, an FBI agent reveals the now-infamous text messages between Chad and Tammy Daybell about shooting a raccoon and burying it in the pet cemetery - the same location where JJ and Tylee were later found. The date of the text exchange most likely corresponds with the day that Tylee was murdered.This episode exposes the early cracks in Chad Daybell's carefully constructed facade. Join us as we analyze the evidence that marked the beginning of the end for Chad Daybell and the doomsday cult that led to these horrific crimes.

Keywords: Afterglow Unveiling the Idaho Cult, Chad Daybell, Lori Vallow Daybell, JJ Vallow, Tylee Ryan, Tammy Daybell, Alex Cox, David Warwick, preliminary hearing, red pajamas, jailhouse call, pet cemetery, raccoon, FBI, text messages, murder, doomsday cult, true crime, Idaho, Rexburg, investigation, justice for JJ and Tylee

Buzzsprout - Let's get your podcast launched!
Start for FREE

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

 Season 3, Episode 4 of "Afterglow: Unveiling the Idaho Cult," we dive deep into the gripping testimony of Melanie Gibb during Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing. Join us as we dissect her chilling account of the events surrounding the mysterious deaths of JJ, Tylee, and Tammy, shedding light on the dark secrets hidden within the Idaho cult.

From shocking revelations to eerie insights into Chad and Lori Daybell's twisted belief system, Melanie's testimony unveils the sinister truth lurking beneath the surface. As we explore the implications of her words, we'll uncover the tangled web of deception and manipulation that led to this tragic saga.

Tune in as we unravel the mysteries of the Idaho cult and delve into the heart of darkness that threatens to consume all who dare to seek the truth. It's an episode you won't want to miss.

This is a one-woman show dedicated to unraveling this chilling saga, your support has been invaluable. If you find value in the content and wish to contribute, you can show your support via PayPal, Cash App, or buy me a coffee. Your generosity fuels the research, production, and dedication poured into every episode.

Stay tuned as we dissect the gripping testimony and dive deeper into the revelations emerging from Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing. The narrative promises to reshape our understanding of this haunting case, revealing unseen facets and exposing the intricate web of information.

Thank you for being a part of this journey through history and tragedy. Your support, whether through donations, kind words, or simply tuning in, drives this endeavor forward. Join us as we navigate through the unfolding events within the courtroom walls, seeking truth amidst the tumultuous currents of an extraordinary time.

Thank you for tuning in to "Afterglow: The Unveiling of the Idaho Cult." Your commitment to understanding these deeply troubling events drives our journey deeper into the heart of this chilling tale. Thanks for listening. Check out my YouTube channel; Left Undone Incomplete Investigation.

Thanks for listening. Please consider giving me a 5-star rating and leave a review.
#LoriVallow #ChadDaybell #ZulemaPastenes #TyleeRyan #JJVallow #CharlesVallow #TammyDaybell #alexcox, #MelaniBoudreaux #doomsdaymom #cultmom #missingchildrenidaho
#MelaniPawlowski

Theme music by Dan Lebowitz

TOP 10 Idaho True Crime Podcasts! Afterglow is named!

Considering donating to my show via any of these links:

Monthly supporter

via PayPal at  www.PayPal.me/katfshh 

Via cash app at 

Cash.app/$afterglowkathy

Or at

By me a coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/Afterglow

No donation is too small.
Sources for this episode
Nate Eaton, East Idaho News
Justin Lum, Fox 10 Phoenix
Annie Cushing Annielytics.com

The clips and media in this podcast are considered fair use.
Fair use refers to the right to reproduce, use, and share copyrighted works of cultural production without direct permission from or payment to the origi

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q

Send us a text

Join us in this gripping episode of "Afterglow: The Unveiling of the Idaho Cult" as we step into the intense and pivotal moments of Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing. The courtroom atmosphere crackles with tension as Detective Hermosillo takes the stand, poised to reveal a torrent of new information surrounding the tragic deaths of Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow.

Set against the backdrop of a world in the throes of the COVID-19 pandemic in August 2020, this extraordinary moment in history frames the unfolding events within the courtroom. As a one-woman show dedicated to unraveling this chilling saga, your support has been invaluable. If you find value in the content and wish to contribute, you can show your support via PayPal, Cash App, or buy me a coffee. Your generosity fuels the research, production, and dedication poured into every episode.

Stay tuned as we dissect the gripping testimony and dive deeper into the revelations emerging from Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing. The narrative promises to reshape our understanding of this haunting case, revealing unseen facets and exposing the intricate web of information.

Thank you for being a part of this journey through history and tragedy. Your support, whether through donations, kind words, or simply tuning in, drives this endeavor forward. Join us as we navigate through the unfolding events within the courtroom walls, seeking truth amidst the tumultuous currents of an extraordinary time.

Thank you for tuning in to "Afterglow: The Unveiling of the Idaho Cult." Your commitment to understanding these deeply troubling events drives our journey deeper into the heart of this chilling tale. Thanks for listening. Check out my YouTube channel; Left Undone Incomplete Investigation.

Thanks for listening. Please consider giving me a 5-star rating and leave a review.
#LoriVallow #ChadDaybell #ZulemaPastenes #TyleeRyan #JJVallow #CharlesVallow #TammyDaybell #alexcox, #MelaniBoudreaux #doomsdaymom #cultmom #missingchildrenidaho
#MelaniPawlowski

Theme music by Dan Lebowitz

Considering donating to my show via any of these links:

Monthly supporter
via PayPal at  www.PayPal.me/katfshh 

Via cash app at 

Cash.app/$afterglowkathy

Or at

By me a coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/Afterglow

No donation is too small.
Sources for this episode
Law and Crime
Nate Eaton, East Idaho News
Justin Lum, Fox 10 Phoenix
Annie Cushing Annielytics.com
KTVB News
The clips and media in this podcast are considered fair use.
Fair use refers to the right to reproduce, use, and share copyrighted works of cultural production without direct permission from or payment to the original copyright holders. It is a designation that is assigned to projects that use copyrighted materials for purposes that include research, criticism, news reporting, and teaching.
  The material is presented for entirely non-profit educational purposes. There is no reason to believe that the featured media clips will in any way negatively affect the market value of the copyrighted works. For these reasons, we believe that the podcast is cove

Support the show

Subscribe to Afterglow for new episodes every Monday!

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts!

© [2025] [Kathryn Brooks]. All rights reserved.

Follow on YouTube: Left Undone Incomplete Investigations for so many Videos of this case and more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcP74RUcUliZ5von9YOz-5Q