Brain Inspired

BI 213 Representations in Minds and Brains


Listen Later

Support the show to get full episodes, full archive, and join the Discord community.

The Transmitter is an online publication that aims to deliver useful information, insights and tools to build bridges across neuroscience and advance research. Visit thetransmitter.org to explore the latest neuroscience news and perspectives, written by journalists and scientists.

Read more about our partnership.

Check out this series of essays about representations:

What are we talking about? Clarifying the fuzzy concept of representation in neuroscience and beyond

Sign up for Brain Inspired email alerts to be notified every time a new Brain Inspired episode is released.

To explore more neuroscience news and perspectives, visit thetransmitter.org.

What do neuroscientists mean when they use the term representation? That's part of what Luis Favela and Edouard Machery set out to answer a couple years ago by surveying lots of folks in the cognitive sciences, and they concluded that as a field the term is used in a confused and unclear way. Confused and unclear are technical terms here, and Luis and Edouard explain what they mean in the episode. More recently Luis and Edouard wrote a follow-up piece arguing that maybe it's okay for everyone to use the term in slightly different ways, maybe it helps communication across disciplines, perhaps. My three other guests today, Frances Egan, Rosa Cao, and John Krakauer wrote responses to that argument, and on today's episode all those folks are here to further discuss that issue and why it matters. Luis is a part philosopher, part cognitive scientists at Indiana University Bloomington, Edouard is a philosopher and Director of the Center for Philosophy of Science at the University of Pittsburgh, Frances is a philosopher from Rutgers University, Rosa is a neuroscientist-turned philosopher at Stanford University, and John is a neuroscientist among other things, and co-runs the Brain, Learning, Animation, and Movement Lab at Johns Hopkins.

  • Luis Favela.
    • Favela's book: The Ecological Brain: Unifying the Sciences of Brain, Body, and Environment
    • Edouard Machery.
      • Machery's book: Doing without Concepts
      • Frances Egan.
        • Egan's book: Deflating Mental Representation.
        • John Krakauer.
        • Rosa Cao.
          • Paper mentioned: Putting representations to use.
          • The exchange, in order, discussed on this episode:
            • Investigating the concept of representation in the neural and psychological sciences.
            • The concept of representation in the brain sciences: The current status and ways forward.
            • Commentaries:
              • Assessing the landscape of representational concepts: Commentary on Favela and Machery.
              • Comments on Favela and Machery's The concept of representation in the brain sciences: The current status and ways forward.
              • Where did real representations go? Commentary on: The concept of representation in the brain sciences: The current status and ways forward by Favela and Machery.
              • Reply to commentaries:
                • Contextualizing, eliminating, or glossing: What to do with unclear scientific concepts like representation.
                • 0:00 - Intro

                  3:55 - What is a representation to a neuroscientist?
                  14:44 - How to deal with the dilemma
                  21:20 - Opposing views
                  31:00 - What's at stake?
                  51:10 - Neural-only representation
                  1:01:11 - When "representation" is playing a useful role
                  1:12:56 - The role of a neuroscientist
                  1:39:35 - The purpose of "representational talk"
                  1:53:03 - Non-representational mental phenomenon
                  1:55:53 - Final thoughts

                  ...more
                  View all episodesView all episodes
                  Download on the App Store

                  Brain InspiredBy Paul Middlebrooks

                  • 4.9
                  • 4.9
                  • 4.9
                  • 4.9
                  • 4.9

                  4.9

                  133 ratings


                  More shows like Brain Inspired

                  View all
                  History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps by Peter Adamson

                  History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps

                  1,577 Listeners

                  Closer To Truth by Closer To Truth

                  Closer To Truth

                  241 Listeners

                  Philosophize This! by Stephen West

                  Philosophize This!

                  15,031 Listeners

                  The Quanta Podcast by Quanta Magazine

                  The Quanta Podcast

                  482 Listeners

                  Philosophy For Our Times by IAI

                  Philosophy For Our Times

                  306 Listeners

                  Into the Impossible With Brian Keating by Big Bang Productions Inc.

                  Into the Impossible With Brian Keating

                  1,044 Listeners

                  The Michael Shermer Show by Michael Shermer

                  The Michael Shermer Show

                  920 Listeners

                  Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas by Sean Carroll | Wondery

                  Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas

                  4,133 Listeners

                  The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss by Lawrence M. Krauss

                  The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss

                  484 Listeners

                  Machine Learning Street Talk (MLST) by Machine Learning Street Talk (MLST)

                  Machine Learning Street Talk (MLST)

                  88 Listeners

                  Dwarkesh Podcast by Dwarkesh Patel

                  Dwarkesh Podcast

                  379 Listeners

                  Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal by Theories of Everything

                  Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal

                  460 Listeners

                  Clearer Thinking with Spencer Greenberg by Spencer Greenberg

                  Clearer Thinking with Spencer Greenberg

                  128 Listeners

                  The Joy of Why by Steven Strogatz, Janna Levin and Quanta Magazine

                  The Joy of Why

                  499 Listeners

                  Robinson's Podcast by Robinson Erhardt

                  Robinson's Podcast

                  242 Listeners