The most played episodes among Podcast App listeners.

1. 1
   Number 1: [Kentucky] Double Jeopardy & The Polaroid Confession of Mel Ignatow

   Grab your mason jar and pull up a rocking chair—this week on Bless This Mess, Cara and Stew are heading to Louisville, Kentucky!On a September morning in 1988, 36-year-old Brenda Sue Schaefer’s car was found abandoned on the shoulder of Interstate 64 with a flat tire. What initially looked like a random roadside breakdown soon unraveled into a calculated plot orchestrated by her wealthy ex-fiancé, Mel Ignatow, and an accomplice. But after a high-profile trial ended in a shocking “Not Guilty” verdict, a routine home renovation ten months later uncovered hidden evidence beneath the floorboards that left prosecutors and the nation grappling with the strict constitutional limits of the Double Jeopardy Clause.Support the showListen to our Monday minisode A Little Less Mess right here on the main feed. Hang out with us on Patreon for The Weekly Pour on the Porch and Sittin’, Sippin’, & Bullshittin’.Please rate and review, subscribe, and follow us on social media for case updates, what's in our mason jars, true crime documentary recommendations, and Southern suppers. Search @blessthismesspodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.Sources for this episodeThe Courier-Journal (Louisville, KY): Archival investigative reporting, trial transcripts, and case coverage (1988–2008).CBS News (48 Hours): Double Jeopardy: Can A Murderer Avoid Prison?Kenton County & Jefferson County Circuit Court Records: Commonwealth of Kentucky v. Melvin Henry Ignatow (1991–1992).U.S. District Court for the Western District of Kentucky: United States of America v. Melvin H. Ignatow (Federal Perjury Indictment, Confession & Sentencing, 1992).WAVE 3 News (NBC Louisville): Retrospective coverage, police archival interviews, and final death investigation records .True Crime Archives & Forensics Case Files: The Murder of Brenda Sue Schaefer and the Double Jeopardy Precedent.

   August 27, 2026·44min
   Play
2. 2
   Number 2: A Little Less Mess: Stalked to Death or Staged - The Cindy James Mystery [Canada]

   In this week's Monday minisode of A Little Less Mess, Cara travels outside the South to the coastal city of Richmond, British Columbia, Canada.Over a seven-year span in the 1980s, 44 year old pediatric nurse Cindy James reported nearly 100 separate incidents of terror: sinister phone calls, slashed tires, dead cats hanging in her yard, arson, and violent physical assaults. But as months turned into years with no physical evidence left behind, police began to suspect Cindy was staging the entire nightmare herself. When Cindy vanished in May 1989 and was found dead in the yard of an abandoned house—hog-tied with a nylon stocking around her neck and a massive lethal overdose of drugs in her system—it sparked the longest coroner’s inquest in Canadian history, culminating in one of the most chilling legal rulings on record: death by an "unknown event."Support the showListen to our Monday minisode A Little Less Mess right here on the main feed. Hang out with us on Patreon for The Weekly Pour on the Porch and Sittin’, Sippin’, & Bullshittin’.Please rate and review, subscribe, and follow us on social media for case updates, what's in our mason jars, true crime documentary recommendations, and Southern suppers. Search @blessthismesspodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.Sources for this episodeBritish Columbia Coroners Service: Inquest into the Death of Cynthia Elizabeth James (May–June 1990 Inquest Transcripts & Findings).Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP): Richmond Detachment Investigative Summary & Public Case Files (1982–1989).The Vancouver Sun & The Province: Contemporary investigative reporting and archival coverage (Neal Hall, 1989–1990).CBC / The Fifth Estate & Unsolved Mysteries: The Haunting and Unsolved Death of Cindy James (Forensic & Investigative Retrospectives).

   September 01, 2026·17min
   Play
3. 3
   Number 3: [Texas] The All-American Family — The Murder of Belinda Temple

   Grab your mason jar and pull up a rocking chair—this week on Bless This Mess, Cara and Stew are heading down to Katy, Texas. On a January evening in 1999, thirty-year-old special education teacher Belinda Temple—eight months pregnant with her second child—was found shot execution-style inside her master bedroom closet. Her husband, David Temple, a prominent local high school football coach and hometown gridiron star, claimed he was running errands with their young son during a staged home invasion. But when famed prosecutor Kelly Siegler took over the case, a secret affair and a grocery store alibi timed down to the exact second unraveled a facade of suburban perfection into one of the most contentious legal battles in Texas history.Support the showListen to our Monday minisode A Little Less Mess right here on the main feed. Hang out with us on Patreon for The Weekly Pour on the Porch and Sittin’, Sippin’, & Bullshittin’.Please rate and review, subscribe, and follow us on social media for case updates, what's in our mason jars, true crime documentary recommendations, and Southern suppers. Search @blessthismesspodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.Sources for this episodeCBS News (48 Hours): The Guessing Game: The Murder of Belinda Temple (2010).ABC News (20/20): Shattered Love: The Trials of David Temple (2019).Oxygen / NBC Universal: Prosecuting Evil with Kelly Siegler: The Belinda Temple Case.Harris County District Court Records: The State of Texas v. David Temple (2007, 2019, 2023).Texas Court of Criminal Appeals: David Temple Appeals & Overturned Proceedings (2016, 2025).The Houston Chronicle & Katy Magazine: Archival investigative reporting and trial transcripts (1999–2025).

   September 04, 2026·43min
   Play
4. 4
   Number 4: A Little Less Mess: The Watcher of 657 Boulevard [New Jersey]

   In this week's Monday minisode of A Little Less Mess, Cara travels outside the South to the picturesque suburb of Westfield, New Jersey. In June 2014, Derek and Maria Broaddus purchased their dream 1.3-million-dollar historic home at 657 Boulevard. But just days after closing—before they even finished moving their three young children in—they found a chilling letter in the mailbox from an anonymous writer calling themselves "The Watcher." Demanding to know when the house would be filled with "young blood" and detailing their renovations in real time, the letters sparked a nightmare of neighbor paranoia, private investigators, a shocking female DNA clue, and an unsolved mystery that left a family with nowhere to run.Support the showListen to our Monday minisode A Little Less Mess right here on the main feed. Hang out with us on Patreon for The Weekly Pour on the Porch and Sittin’, Sippin’, & Bullshittin’.Please rate and review, subscribe, and follow us on social media for case updates, what's in our mason jars, true crime documentary recommendations, and Southern suppers. Search @blessthismesspodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.Sources for this episode New York Magazine / The Cut: The Haunting of a Dream House (Reeves Wiedeman, 2018). Westfield Police Department & Union County Prosecutor’s Office: Public investigative case files and DNA forensic records (657 Boulevard Investigation).Today Show / NBC News: New Jersey Couple Tormented by 'The Watcher' Speaks Out (Archival Coverage & Interviews).Vanity Fair / Time: The Real-Life Unsolved Mystery of The Watcher at 657 Boulevard.

   August 25, 2026·17min
   Play
5. 5
   Number 5: A Little Less Mess: The Unsolved Murder of Lisa Pruett [Ohio]

   In this week's Monday minisode of A Little Less Mess, Cara travels outside the South to the upscale community of Shaker Heights, Ohio.In September 1990, sixteen-year-old Lisa Pruett left home to meet her boyfriend in Shaker Heights, Ohio. Minutes later, she was attacked and killed in a yard just steps from his house. A classmate, Kevin Young, was charged after two people said he confessed while in psychiatric treatment, but no physical evidence tied him to the crime. He was acquitted in 1993, and Lisa’s murder remains unsolved.Support the showListen to our Monday minisode A Little Less Mess right here on the main feed. Hang out with us on Patreon for The Weekly Pour on the Porch and Sittin’, Sippin’, & Bullshittin’.Please rate and review, subscribe, and follow us on social media for case updates, what's in our mason jars, true crime documentary recommendations, and Southern suppers. Search @blessthismesspodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.Sources for this episodeCleveland.com, “Kevin Young, accused in 1990 fatal stabbing of Shaker Heights teen, dies at 44”Cleveland Scene, “I See the Truth,” a long-form review of the Lisa Pruett investigation and Kevin Young trialShaker Heights Police / Cuyahoga County court reporting and contemporaneous local coverage

   September 08, 2026·13min
   Play