John Lennon believed "I'm in Love" could be a hit—but not for the Beatles. Instead, the 1963 track was handed off to the Fourmost, offering a glimpse into the Lennon-McCartney machine’s remarkable output during their peak years. Peter and Kenyon explore the song’s bittersweet lyrics, unusual rhythmic phrasing, and its distinctive descending chord sequence, which hints at the Beatles’ early flirtation with complexity. The hosts discuss the differences between Lennon’s original piano demo—raw and emotional—and the Fourmost’s polished cabaret interpretation, revealing how the song’s essence shifted across versions. Along the way, they uncover anecdotes about the Beatles’ generosity toward other artists and the strategic decisions behind giving away songs. Tune in to hear how “I’m in Love” exemplifies Lennon’s gift for blending pop sensibility with emotional resonance, even in a track the Beatles never claimed for themselves.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.