Family Twist: A Podcast Exploring DNA Surprises and Family Secrets

In this episode of Family Twist, Corey and Kendall sit down with Mary, adoptive mom to previous guest Chris Martin. If you haven’t already, we recommend listening to Chris’ two episodes first — his story as an adoptee lays the groundwork for the conversation you’re about to hear with his mom.

Mary opens up about the unexpected beginnings of Chris’ adoption and how what started as a plan for a closed adoption blossomed into a fully open one. She shares candidly about the joys, challenges, and deep connections that grew as two families came together out of love for one child.

Together, Corey, Kendall, and Mary explore:

• The surprising way Mary and her husband learned they’d become parents
• How their adoption plan evolved into an open adoption — and why that mattered for Chris
• The importance of seeing adoption through both parent and child perspectives
• The blend of nature and nurture in Chris’ growth and personality
• The role of extended families, birth parents’ spouses, and even grandparents in sustaining openness
• Why Mary encourages others not to fear open adoption, but to center every decision on what’s best for the child

Mary’s voice adds a rich and heartfelt counterpoint to Chris’ earlier episodes, giving listeners a rare chance to hear both sides of an adoption story in depth.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In this episode of Family Twist, Corey and Kendall sit down with storyteller and comedian Becca Rothman to talk about her remarkable DNA discovery and her upcoming live solo show, Gifted: Nature, Nurture, and an Unexpected Present.

Becca shares the journey from long-held suspicions about her conception, to finally taking a DNA test, to discovering her biological father—a pediatrician—and two half-sisters she instantly connected with. She walks us through the clues, the moment of opening that life-changing email, the careful way she reached out, and the joy of meeting her new family for the first time.

She also opens up about the creative process of turning her story into art: how she stumbled into comedy and storytelling in her late forties, became a Moth producer, and is now preparing to premiere her first one-person show in New York City. Becca talks about the balance of humor and vulnerability in sharing family secrets, the importance of breaking cycles of shame, and how Taylor Swift (yes, really!) has influenced her courage to be fully authentic.

This conversation touches on family secrets, resilience, ADHD revelations, parenting, and the healing power of storytelling and the arts.

• Secrets & Shame: Growing up with hidden truths about her conception—and why sharing them publicly now feels like liberation.
• DNA Discovery: How a long-delayed 23andMe kit led to finding her biological father and two half-sisters.
• Nature Meets Nurture: Spotting uncanny similarities with her new family—from writing style to leaving kitchen cabinets open.
• Creative Bravery: From a rough first comedy gig to becoming a storyteller and creating Gifted, her solo show premiering in NYC.
• Family Reactions: How her parents, husband, and kids responded to the discovery.
• Identity & ADHD: Understanding herself more deeply after her bio dad mentioned his own diagnosis.
• Music & Healing: Why Taylor Swift and Talking Heads’ “Once in a Lifetime” have been soundtracks for this chapter of her life.

🎭 Gifted: Nature, Nurture, and an Unexpected Present

• Part of the Frigid NYC Festival at Under St. Marks in New York City
• Dates: September 6–7, 2025
• Sunday performance already sold out, but Saturday night and livestream tickets available
• More info: Frigid NYC or via Becca’s website/Instagram (@beccarothman)

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In this episode of Family Twist, Corey and Kendall get raw, real, and a little ranty. It’s part group therapy, part comedy roast, and all about the phrases adoptees hear over and over again that range from paper-cut stings to sledgehammer blows. From “You’re so lucky your parents chose you” to “Do you know your real parents?”—they unpack why these comments miss the mark, how they flatten adoptee stories, and what people could say instead.

With equal parts humor and honesty, Corey and Kendall explain how these clichés can turn gratitude into a prison, erase adoptive parents, or script feelings adoptees never asked for. They don’t just rant, though. They share practical, respectful alternatives and invite listeners—adoptees and non-adoptees alike—to reflect on the power of words.

If you’ve ever felt like screaming when someone told you “everything happens for a reason,” this episode gives you permission. Consider it adoptee group therapy with a laugh track.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode

• Why “You’re so lucky your parents chose you” erases loss behind adoption.
• The problem with asking “Do you know your real parents?” and how to reframe.
• The myth of “at least you were wanted” and how it silences nuance.
• Why “your birth mom must have loved you so much to give you up” oversimplifies complicated truths.
• Why adoptees bristle at “blood is thicker than water.”
• Alternatives to clichés: what to actually say when adoption comes up.
• The reminder that adoptees are not “special” props—they’re layered people with layered stories.

Takeaway Message

Adoption isn’t about being lucky or broken. It’s both love and loss, gratitude and grief, connection and disconnection. Adoptees deserve space to tell their own stories without scripts handed down in clichés.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In this candid conversation, Corey and Kendall tackle one of the most painful realities in the adoptee and DNA surprise world — reaching out to a biological parent and getting… nothing in return.

Kendall opens up about his own experience with his birth mother: the initial reply that offered hope, the “I need time to process” that turned into months of silence, and the slow realization that this wasn’t a pause — it was a soft no. Together, Corey and Kendall unpack what that kind of rejection feels like, why parents sometimes choose silence, and the emotional work it takes to keep living fully without the answers you want.

This is not a story about closure. It’s a story about reclaiming your voice when someone else chooses not to be part of your story.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

• Kendall’s personal account of being shut out by his birth mother
• The difference between ghosting in dating and ghosting in family relationships
• The mental spiral of “filling in the blanks” when a parent won’t engage
• Possible reasons behind a parent’s refusal that don’t make the hurt any less
• Why waiting can cost you more than it gives you
• How Kendall found support and started to heal
• A direct message from Kendall to his birth mother — and to anyone living with parental silence

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In this heartfelt follow-up to one of our earliest episodes ("The Man Weekend"), Kendall shares stories from a recent rustic getaway with members of his birth family at their long-held property in northern New Hampshire. It’s a full-circle moment—spending time around the campfire with his brother, uncle, cousins, and nephews, deepening bonds with people he didn’t grow up with but now can’t imagine life without. From installing a water system to laughing until they lost their voices, this trip was more than just a weekend—it was a memory-in-the-making.

Corey joins the conversation to reflect on how far Kendall’s found-family journey has come, and how these connections—old and new—continue to shape their lives. They also touch on the emotional reality of balancing adoptive and biological family histories, the joy of watching young relatives grow up, and even a cautionary tale involving sesame meatballs.

Toward the end, Corey and Kendall introduce plans for future solo episodes addressing current issues in the adoptee, NPE, and donor-conceived communities—and share the powerful message behind a recent email from a listener whose life was changed by discovering Family Twist.

📌 Topics Covered:

• The return to Kendall’s birth family’s New Hampshire property
• What’s changed since “The Man Weekend” (including plumbing!)
• Reconnecting with cousins, uncle, and brother Chris
• The joy of bonding with nephews as they enter adulthood
• Humor, shenanigans, and nearly killing Pete with sesame
• Reflecting on the emotions of what was missed—and what’s now gained
• Future plans for solo episodes focused on NPE/adoptee/DC community issues
• The impact of Family Twist on a listener’s decision to search for their truth

🔗 Related Episodes:

• The Man Weekend (link to original episode)
• Chris Finds a Brother: Kendall’s First Birth Family Connection

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In Part 2 of our conversation with author and advocate J. Steven Osborne, we explore what happens after the shock of a DNA discovery, when the dust starts to settle, and you're left piecing together not just your origin story, but your identity.

Steven opens up about the emotional toll of learning that Jack Osborne, the man who raised him and loved him unconditionally, wasn’t his biological father. It felt like losing him all over again—except this time, it was to a lie, not to death. What follows is a deeply moving tribute to the man Steven still calls "Dad" and a powerful reminder that family is not about genetics—it’s about showing up, staying present, and choosing love every single day.

We also discuss:

• The surreal moment his sister’s DNA test confirmed the truth
• How his wife Becky became both researcher and rock in his journey
• The painful confrontation with his mother—and the unexpected truth hidden in her memoir
• How his siblings embraced him with fierce, unconditional love
• And why Steven now defines family by just two things: love and commitment

💥 Steven’s memoir, DNA – Did Not Anticipate, is a must-read for anyone navigating a DNA surprise, NPE discovery, or complex family secret. It’s raw, darkly funny, and filled with grace.

Quotes to remember:

📘 Order Steven’s book → https://dnadidnotanticipate.com/

🔗 Learn more about Right to Know → righttoknow.us

If you’ve ever felt like an outsider in your own story, this episode is for you.

#FamilyTwistPodcast #JStevenOsborne #DNADidNotAnticipate #FoundFamily #NPE #DNARevelation #FamilyIsLove #RightToKnow #MPE #DNAHealing #ChosenFamily

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

J. Steven Osborne believed he knew where he came from until an ancestry DNA test turned his world upside down. What started in 2021 as a casual curiosity for Native American heritage ended with a jaw-dropping response: a first cousin in Prince Edward Island. And his father? Not who he thought. Join Corey as Steven recounts the powerful, painful, and sometimes absurd journey that unraveled in real time.

In this Part One of the conversation, Steven takes us back to a childhood in Tory Hill, Kentucky—full of blended houses, foster kids, Pentecostal rituals, and 14 siblings. A loving but turbulent family life set the stage, and his father Jack became his emotional anchor. But on a flight home from Hilton Head, his sister’s DNA match confirmed what shattered everything: his biological father was someone else entirely.

This episode ends at that gut-punch moment—leaving listeners hanging, hearts racing, and fingers gripping the armrest. Part Two dives deeper into grief, identity, forgiveness… and yes, more revelations that defy fiction.

📘 Teaser for DNA – Did Not Anticipate

Steven co-wrote the memoir with his wife, forensic genealogist Becky Brower Osborne. Originally meant as healing journaling, the story morphed into an 80,000-word rollercoaster of intrigue, humor, heartbreak, and redemption—from disbelief to forgiveness, and finding belonging in unexpected places DNA Did Not Anticipate+9DNA Did Not Anticipate+9Buzzsprout+9.

Praise for the book:

• “Life‑is‑stranger‑than‑fiction”—a true shocker of a memoir Amazon+3DNA Did Not Anticipate+3RightToKnow+3
• “Gut‑wrenching grief woven with laugh‑out‑loud moments”—a compelling read for anyone who's faced a DNA surprise Buzzsprout+5BookLife+5DNA Did Not Anticipate+5

🗣️ This Episode Is For You If You’ve Ever…

• Wondered who you are when DNA contradicts family lore
• Experienced the emotional wreckage of a mistaken identity
• Found healing in humor, resilience, and forgivenes
• Crave a raw, deeply personal story told with both sharp wit and open heart

📌 What You’ll Hear in Part One

• 🧬 The “Aha!” moment on a plane when everything changed
• Emotional flashbacks to Pentecostal upbringing and chaotic blended family life
• The love story of Steven and Becky and how writing became his therapy
• Hints of the darker revelations waiting in Part Two

🔗 Links & Resources

❤️ Why We Love This Episode

Steven’s story is a testament to resilience: finding humor in heartbreak, courage in chaos, and family in truth. It’s a must-listen for anyone redefining their past—especially when that journey begins at 30,000 feet.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Author, adoptee, and fierce truth-teller Jean Widner returns to Family Twist—and this time, she’s holding a finished book in her hands. In this emotionally raw and intellectually rich conversation, Corey sits down with Jean to talk about the release of her long-anticipated book, The Adoption Paradox, and the deeply personal story behind it.

What began as a community-driven exploration of adoption evolved into something far more intimate—a reflection on grief, rejection, and what it means when your birth mother says “no.” Jean unpacks the anger, longing, and love that poured into her writing, including the moment a friend called her book “a love letter to your mother”—a revelation she hadn’t seen coming.

We also dive into the darker side of the adoption industry: predatory marketing tactics, the for-profit machinery behind child placement, and why “rescue” language is so harmful. Plus, Jean and Corey share a few behind-the-scenes truths about being marketers themselves, and what it means to use those skills for good.

This episode covers:

• Jean’s reflections one year after her birth mother’s painful rejection
• The real story behind The Adoption Paradox
• Why sealed birth certificates and loyalty tests still hurt
• Marketing ethics in adoption and who’s profiting from secrecy
• How community and storytelling create space for healing
• Why Fast Car by Tracy Chapman is the perfect song for her adoption journey

If you’ve ever felt like you couldn’t tell the whole truth about your story, this conversation is for you. Jean reminds us that sometimes the most radical act is just naming what happened, without the bow.

📖 Grab Jean’s book: adoptionparadox.com

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

In Part 2 of our powerful conversation with Chris, the emotional stakes deepen. Chris takes us through the winding road of reconnection with his birth father—once lost to addiction and incarceration—and how a long-awaited letter cracked the door open to forgiveness and healing.

We also explore the life-changing moment Chris met his half-brother from his birth father’s side, a child who didn’t just resemble him physically—but emotionally, energetically, and spiritually. It’s a reflection that brought up joy, grief, and a surprising sense of full-circle peace.

Chris also recounts a vulnerable and honest phone call with his birth mother where, for the first time, they both acknowledged the loss—and the love—that came from their separation.

And as Chris reconnects with the final missing pieces of his extended family, he shares what it feels like to finally, fully, know where you come from—and where you belong.

This is a conversation about truth, timing, and the power of second chances.

In This Episode:

– Meeting his half-brother and seeing his mirror image

– Rebuilding a relationship with his birth father after addiction

– The emotional weight of a long-overdue apology letter

– A healing phone call with his birth mother about separation and regret

– Family secrets on his birth father’s side—and how they ripple through generations

– Understanding identity through the lens of nature and nurture

– Belonging to multiple families, and claiming all of them

– Finding a home in the adoption community

Why It Matters:

Chris’s story challenges the assumption that “knowing everything” means you escape the pain. Even in the most open adoptions, healing takes time and sometimes, it takes meeting a sibling who looks like you to see yourself more clearly.

#FamilyTwistPodcast #AdopteeVoices #DNAReunion #BirthFatherHealing #HalfSiblings #PrimalWound #OpenAdoption #AdoptionTruth #FamilyHealing #IdentityJourney #MisattributedParentage #AdoptionPodcast

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Want more Corey and Kendall? Join us on Patreon for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus show with personal stories, behind-the-scenes conversations, family chaos, and plenty we wouldn't normally share on Family Twist.

Join us: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours

Chris’ story may not begin with a shocking discovery but it’s no less extraordinary. In this episode, Kendall and Corey sit down with Chris to explore a rare but deeply moving example of an open adoption that worked exactly as intended. Chris has known his birth parents for his entire life, and his adoptive parents invited his birth family in from day one.

But as we quickly learn, openness doesn’t mean immunity from pain. Chris reflects on how—even in a home full of love and acceptance—he still struggled with feelings of not being “enough,” of needing to prove his worth. He shares his journey through anxiety, early childhood trauma, and the therapeutic breakthroughs that helped him recognize the impact of the primal wound, even when adoption was never a secret.

Chris also speaks candidly about his experience surviving E. coli and kidney failure as a young child, and how that trauma shaped his early years. Through it all, his story is one of deep introspection, hard-earned insight, and powerful reminders that no two adoptee experiences are exactly alike—but the emotional threads often run in parallel.

💬 Topics Covered:

• 
  
• 
  
• How a high school teacher’s lesson on IVF led to an adoption offer
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• The emotional complexity of open adoption
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• Navigating anxiety and the need to “earn” belonging
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• The impact of childhood trauma and medical emergencies
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• How therapy, self-reflection, and community help shape healing
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• The primal wound, even when you're never kept in the dark
• 
  
• 
  
• 
  
• Nature vs. nurture through the lens of two families
• 
  
• 
  

💡 Why It Matters:

Chris’s story challenges the myth that adoptees raised in open, loving homes don’t struggle with identity or belonging. His willingness to speak about the nuance in his journey adds to the growing conversation around how all adoption stories—twisty or not—carry emotional weight.

🔜 Stay Tuned:

Part 2 continues Chris’s journey, with deeper reflections on how he navigates dual family connections, personality traits passed through biology, and the ongoing evolution of self-understanding.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Want more Corey and Kendall?

Join us for Family Twist After Hours, our weekly unfiltered bonus podcast featuring personal stories, family secrets, behind-the-scenes conversations and plenty we don't share on the regular show.

Your Patreon membership also helps cover the costs of keeping Family Twist going. Plus, subscribers get new Family Twist episodes a day early!

Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/FamilyTwistPodcastAfterHours