There are a lot of misconceptions about goats that set new owners up for frustration before they ever bring animals home. In this episode, I’m walking through five things I really wish I had understood before I got goats—lessons that would have saved me time, money, stress, and a lot of hard-earned mistakes.
We start by resetting expectations around goat behavior and management, including why goats are not sheep and why treating them like they are leads to fence failures, nutrition problems, and constant headaches. I break down the common myth that goats will eat anything, why that idea causes disappointment and even safety issues, and how understanding goat selectivity can actually make them a powerful management tool when used intentionally.
We also talk through the difference between poor management that forces goats to eat through hunger and strategic pressure that can be used carefully to influence forage selection. I explain why hunger-driven eating is often a sign that stocking rate, rotation, supplementation, or minerals are off—and when it can make sense to intentionally encourage goats to consume less-preferred plants without compromising health or welfare.
Finally, we cover why fence isn’t just one piece of goat ownership but the entire system, why minerals are not optional for goats, and why bottle babies—despite being cute—are not the best place for beginners to start. If you’re planning to get goats, or if you already have them and things feel harder than you expected, this episode will help you step back, reset expectations, and build systems that actually work.
In This Episode, I Cover:
Why goats are not sheep and how their behavior, grazing style, and nutrition differHow managing goats like sheep creates fence, feeding, and safety problemsThe myth that goats will eat anything—and why it sets people up for disappointmentHow goats actually browse, sample, and select forageWhy hunger-driven eating is usually a sign of management problemsWhen and how goats can be strategically encouragedto eat less-preferred plantsThe role of stocking rate, rotation, supplementation, and minerals in forage selectionSeasonal changes in plant palatability and how that affects grazing plansWhy fence is not a detail but the foundation of goat managementCommon ways electric fence fails and why you need a secure backup enclosureWhy goats have higher mineral demands than many people expectThe problems caused by feeding sheep mineral to goatsWhy mineral availability does not always equal mineral intakeWhy bottle babies are emotionally appealing but management-intensiveThe higher risks and behavioral challenges of bottle-raised goatsWhy bottle babies make the learning curve steeper for beginnersKey Takeaways:
Goats require different management than sheep or cattleExpectation mismatches are at the root of most goat problemsGoats are selective browsers, not garbage disposalsHunger-based eating is a warning sign, not a management strategyStrategic pressure can influence forage use when applied carefully and intentionallyFence is the system that everything else depends onA solid, goat-proof enclosure relieves pressure when electric fence failsMinerals are essential to long-term goat health and performanceFeeding sheep mineral to goats will cause deficiencies over timeBottle babies are not the easiest place to start learning goatsClear expectations and intentional systems make goats much easier to manageRelated Episodes:
03 | Ready for Goats! 4 Steps to Help You Confidently Shop for and Purchase Your First Goats10 | 5 Tips to Raise Bottle Goat Kids That Thrive17 | Do My Goats Need Mineral? How to Meet Their Micronutrient Needs and Keep the Herd Healthy07 | Should My Goats Have Horns or Not? Pros and Cons of Disbudding Goats02 | Overwhelmed? 4 Steps to Create a Practical Plan for adding Livestock to Your Homestead SuccessfullyResources & Links:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts + grab the free Kidding Due Date Chart:
https://www.getgoatwise.com/kidding-chart
Get Dry Creek meat:
https://drycreekheritagemeats.com
Join my insider email list:
https://www.getgoatwise.com/insider
Join the free community:
https://www.getgoatwise.com/community
Email me:
[email protected]
See ranch life on Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/drycreekpastures/
The information shared in this episode is for educational purposes only and should not be considered veterinary advice. Always consult a licensed veterinarian for animal health guidance.