In 1847, two young sisters moved into a supposedly haunted farmhouse in Hydesville, New York. What began as Kate and Maggie Fox playing pranks on their superstitious mother—tying apples to strings to create mysterious knocking sounds—accidentally convinced their entire community they could communicate with the dead. Within months, their childhood game had spiraled into something far beyond their control.
By 1849, the Fox sisters were performing public séances at Rochester's Corinthian Hall before packed audiences of skeptics and believers alike. No one could detect their fraud. Their "spirit communications" launched the American Spiritualist Movement, a religious phenomenon that swept across continents and influenced millions. Mediums emerged everywhere, séances became parlor entertainment, and the line between belief and skepticism blurred entirely.
But the sisters kept a devastating secret for forty years. In 1888, Maggie Fox finally confessed publicly: it was all a hoax. Yet by then, spiritualism had taken root so deeply that even their confession couldn't kill the movement they'd accidentally created. The story of the Fox sisters reveals how a simple prank can reshape history—and how truth sometimes matters less than what people desperately want to believe.
Discover how two girls fooled a nation and opened the door to talking with the dead, only to watch their creation outlive their confession.
Episode Summary
In the winter of 1847, the Fox family moved into a farmhouse in Hydesville, New York with a reputation for being haunted. When mysterious knocking sounds began in March 1848, no one suspected the truth: twelve-year-old Kate and fourteen-year-old Maggie Fox were playing an elaborate prank on their superstitious mother. The girls tied apples to strings and bounced them on floors, creating "spirit rappings" that convinced their family they were communicating with ghosts.
What started as harmless mischief escalated beyond their control. When the girls pretended to have conversations with a spirit they called "Mr. Splitfoot" (a nickname for the devil), neighbors became convinced a murder had occurred in the house. An innocent man named Bell was accused and shunned by his community—demonstrating the dangerous power of superstition and rumor.
The sisters' older sister Leah recognized a business opportunity. She capitalized on the attention, taking the girls on tour and positioning them as genuine mediums. By November 1849, the Fox sisters were performing before packed audiences at Corinthian Hall in Rochester, withstanding scrutiny from skeptics and dignitaries who could not detect their fraud. Their act launched the American Spiritualist Movement, a religious phenomenon that spread across the United States and Europe, giving rise to thousands of mediums and making séances a mainstream practice.
The movement's founders, however, struggled with guilt and alcoholism. In 1888, forty years after their first "spirit communication," Maggie Fox publicly confessed the fraud at New York's Academy of Music, demonstrating how they had cracked their toe joints to create the knocking sounds. She denounced spiritualism and implicated her sister Leah in the deception.
But the confession barely dented the movement they'd created. Believers split into factions—some denying the confession, others accusing the sisters of lying to spite Leah. Spiritualism continued to thrive long after the Fox sisters died in poverty and obscurity. In 1904, bones discovered in the Hydesville farmhouse cellar briefly reignited speculation about the "murdered peddler," but examination revealed only a mixture of human and animal remains with no evidence of the murder the girls had claimed.
The Fox sisters' story reveals the complex interplay between belief, skepticism, and the human desire for connection beyond death. It demonstrates how a childhood prank can accidentally reshape religious history—and how truth sometimes matters less than what grieving people desperately want to believe.
Key Locations
Hydesville, New York Small hamlet approximately 20 miles from Rochester where the Fox family lived in the supposedly haunted farmhouse. The March 31, 1848 "spirit communications" occurred here, launching the spiritualist phenomenon. The original farmhouse no longer stands, but the location is commemorated by spiritualist organizations.
Rochester, New York Major city where the Fox sisters gained wider fame. Corinthian Hall (no longer standing) hosted their first major public demonstrations on November 14, 1849. Rochester in the 1840s-1850s was a center of progressive reform movements, including abolition, women's rights, and unconventional religious ideas, providing fertile ground for spiritualism.
New York Academy of Music Site of Maggie Fox's 1888 public confession where she exposed the mechanics of their "spirit rappings" and denounced spiritualism as fraud.
Key Dates & Timeline
December 11, 1847 John and Margaret Fox move into the Hydesville farmhouse with daughters Maggie and Kate. House already has reputation for being haunted.
March 1848 Mysterious knocking sounds begin. The Fox sisters are creating them by tying apples to strings and bouncing them on floors.
March 31, 1848 Kate Fox pretends to see a spirit and challenges it to copy her finger snaps. The "spirit" responds. Mother shares the incident with neighbors, and the prank escalates beyond the girls' control.
1848-1849 Sisters develop system of "yes/no" questions answered by knocks. Claim to communicate with spirit of murdered peddler "Charles B. Rosna." Innocent neighbor named Bell is accused and shunned. Church distances itself from the family. Girls sent to live with older siblings.
November 14, 1849 First major public demonstration at Corinthian Hall in Rochester. Skeptical audience and local dignitaries cannot detect fraud. Event ends in near-riot but launches sisters to fame.
1849-1850s Fox sisters tour New York and beyond. Media coverage spreads nationally. American Spiritualist Movement begins, with mediums emerging across the country. Sisters become celebrities among literary elite and attract both believers and skeptics.
1850s-1880s Sisters continue performing while spiritualism grows into major religious movement. Both Maggie and Kate struggle with alcohol addiction. Maggie forms relationship with Arctic explorer Elijah Kane, who suspects the fraud and urges her to quit.
1888 At New York Academy of Music, Maggie Fox publicly confesses fraud, demonstrates the toe-cracking technique, and denounces spiritualism. Confession causes fallout but fails to kill the movement.
1904 Bones discovered in cellar of Hydesville farmhouse, reigniting speculation about the "murdered peddler" story. Examination reveals mixture of human and animal remains with no conclusive evidence of murder.
Source Citations
- Weisberg, Barbara. "Talking to the Dead: Kate and Maggie Fox and the Rise of Spiritualism." HarperOne, 2004.
- Comprehensive historical biography of the Fox sisters with extensive primary source research.
- Braude, Ann. "Radical Spirits: Spiritualism and Women's Rights in Nineteenth-Century America."Indiana University Press, 2001.
- Academic examination of spiritualism's connection to women's rights and reform movements in Rochester and beyond.
- New York Herald, November 1849
- Contemporary newspaper coverage of the Corinthian Hall demonstrations and public reaction.
- "The Death-Blow to Spiritualism: Being the True Story of the Fox Sisters." Reuben Briggs Davenport, 1888.
- Account of Maggie Fox's public confession at the New York Academy of Music.
- Library of Congress - Chronicling America Collection
- Period newspaper archives documenting the rise of the spiritualist movement and Fox sisters' tours (1848-1888).
- Rochester History Journal, Vol. 71, 2009
- "The Fox Sisters and the Rappings That Started It All" by James Pauldino. Historical society documentation of Rochester's role in spiritualism.
- Podmore, Frank. "Modern Spiritualism: A History and a Criticism." Methuen & Co., 1902.
- Contemporary skeptical analysis of spiritualism including detailed Fox sisters investigation.
- "Hydesville in History" - Lily Dale Assembly Archives
- Spiritualist organization's preservation of Fox sisters historical materials and site documentation.
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/hometownhistory/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
