I Think Not!

By Obsessed Network

Society & Culture

What's I Think Not! about?

From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.

4.8

5,606 ratings

Download our free app to listen on your phone

LAST EPISODE

150: Acid Lady (Deadly Wives)

05.24.2023

Tim and Larissa Schuster are a successful couple in Clovis, California. Larissa owns a thriving biochemistry lab, while Tim works at a hospital and manages their home and two kids. The Schuster marriage appears to be a perfect example of ...

I Think Not! episodes:

05.24.2023 150: Acid Lady (Deadly Wives) Tim and Larissa Schuster are a successful couple in Clovis, California. Larissa owns a thriving biochemistry lab, while Tim works at a hospital and manages their home and two kids. The Schuster marriage appears to be a perfect example of ...
05.17.2023 149: Marlboro Man Murder (Deadly Wives) Elisa McNabney was living the high life in Sacramento, CA. Her husband Larry was a successful personal injury attorney, and since Larry's many TV commercials featured him in western gear, he was known as "The Marlboro Man. COME SEE US ...
05.10.2023 148: Things Aren't Always What They Seem (Deadly Wives) This episode feature two stories of wives who weren't who they appeared to be. First, 30-year-old Ann Miller of Raleigh, NC seemed to have it all: a great job, a handsome husband and a beautiful baby. COME SEE US ON ...
05.03.2023 147: Beth's Last Party (See No Evil) w/ Christopher Walker!! Hey, DB's!! We have a VERY special guest this episode - our favorite narrator Christopher! He absolutely LOVED being in the studio with us... [narrator voice] he did not love being in the studio with them...JK!! ENJOY! On December 23rd ...
04.26.2023 146: Dead Man Walking (See No Evil) On September 17th 2015, Edward Lowry is found savagely beaten and stabbed to death in a parking lot in South Dakota. With little evidence left behind at the scene, the police attempt to piece together Ed's last moments from CCTV. ...
04.19.2023 145: At Michelle's Door (See No Evil) A woman's New Year's disappearance leads to a gruesome discovery; with no witnesses, only the four security cameras from her apartment building can help decipher what happened. This Week's Sponsors: Rocket Money - Cancel unwanted subscriptions and manage your expenses ...
04.12.2023 144: Stalking Cynthia (See No Evil) Cynthia Langrall is shot dead during her morning jog through the normally peaceful Hillcrest Ranch neighborhood in Glendale, Arizona. Home surveillance footage enables detectives to identify the shooter's vehicle but will it be enough to catch the killer? This Week's ...
04.05.2023 142: Seen At Susan's (See No Evil) On April 12th 2008, Susan Casey vanishes after a night out. The only clues left behind are suspicious drag marks outside her home. CCTV footage reveals three different suspects on the scene. Which one is lying and who can tell ...
04.04.2023 143: The Zodiac Killer (Potentially) Identified: A New Project from Obsessed Network Earlier this year, author Jaret Kobec named a new suspect to be the Zodiac Killer. This was based on years of research which uncovered never before seen evidence and answered many of the open questions in the case. Kobec's evidence ...
03.29.2023 141: All Eyes on Jordie (See No Evil) In 2016, Jordie Hudson vanishes after a night out with friends. The only clue police have is her glasses, which are discovered in a pool of blood. Surveillance footage shows a horrific attack. Can police find her abductor before it's ...
03.22.2023 140: A Mystery in the Pines (The Wonderland Murders) Caught in a love triangle, young chef and mom Heather Mallory vanishes. Now Portland detectives and Heather's parents search for the truth in an investigation involving wiretaps, confidential informants, and a dramatic resolution deep in the forest. This Week's Sponsors: ...
03.15.2023 139: Fatal Vows (The Other Side of the Tracks) When Ed Postma, a Florida truck driver with a bad boy reputation, meets single mom Jackie Rosser, sparks fly. But when Ed straightens out to become a family man, new bad boys are waiting, and the spark dies, taking another ...
03.13.2023 "Crimes of the Centuries" Returns for Season 3! Hey, DBs!! We're so thrilled that Crimes of the Centuries from the Obsessed Network is back for Season 3! Join host Amber Hunt each week as she dives deep into a case that was huge when it happened but somehow ...
03.08.2023 138: He Seems Perfect (Your Worst Nightmare) Budding New York fashion designer Jenae Aragosa falls hard for bartender Trevor Frederick; a dark side of her new man comes to light and she realizes she'll be lucky if she makes it out of the relationship alive. This Week's ...
03.01.2023 137: Dangerous Game (Who the Bleep Did I Marry?) Seventeen-year-old Mandy Boardman is courted by a man twice her age, David Wise, who played on her softball team. It seemed she had met her perfect match. After the pair wed, it wasn't long before Mandy realized David was playing ...
02.15.2023 136: The Virgin & the Bachelorette (Scorned: Love Kills) Rebecca has hooked quite a catch with shy, wealthy software engineer Bruce. But when she begins a tawdry affair with a sultry stripper named Steve, Rebecca's deadly dance will bend this love triangle out of shape and lead to cold-blooded ...
02.08.2023 135: New Orleans: Betrayal in the Big Easy (City Confidential) In 1994, Kim Groves was gunned down in her front yard after Len Davis, a police officer who did side-work in dealing cocaine, ordered her death because she knew too much. A sting operation caught Davis ordering Groves' death, but ...
02.01.2023 134: Alabama Love Triangle (I Killed My BFF) I Killed My BFF is a pretty straightforward show title, but the story in this episode is messy as can be: Alabama party boys and best friends Butch Hampel and Richard Terry meet while working at the local paper mill. ...
01.25.2023 133: A Date with Hate (Dates From Hell) Welcome to Dates From Hell, a show about a topic we can all relate to... brought to the extreme. This episode is certainly a doozy so buckle up, babes: Loved-up duo Richard and Luis spend a night at a glitzy ...
01.18.2023 132: A Beautiful Mind (Unraveled) We're exploring the show Unraveled in this episode. Season 2 episode 3 "A Beautiful Mind" tells a complex story that was hard not to get emotional about, but we're in this together team: Brilliant mathematician Chris Krumm gets some shocking ...
01.11.2023 131: Idol Worship (Stalked: Someone's Watching) We're tackling the "Idol Worship" episode from Stalked: Someone's Watching so get ready for lots of outlandish singing: A talent show contestant gains a new fan who starts calling her non-stop, turning the thrill of fame into sheer terror. How ...
01.04.2023 130: Mary Kay Beckman & Steven Lane (I Dated a Psycho) Welcome listeners, first-time and long-time, to our inaugural episode of I Think Not! We're kicking things off with the harrowing stories of Mary Kay Beckman, Steven Lane, and the toxic people they dated from I Dated A Psycho: A man's ...
12.21.2022 129: Disappeared Pilot REDUX: The End of Innocence (Ft. Patrick!) Surprise folks! We're bidding farewell to Disappeared with a return to where this podcast started. Enjoy a newly redone version of our pilot with current AND former hosts Ellyn, Joey and Patrick! In Tyler, Texas, 23-year-old Brandi Wells disappears after ...
12.14.2022 128: Disappeared Special: Lauryn Is Lost When 23-year old Lauryn Garrett vanishes after calling her father for a ride home, the family embark on a journey to find her and uncover startling clues linked to her past. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get ...
12.14.2022 Introducing... I Think Not! (A New True Crime Comedy Podcast) The big news has finally arrived people! We're rebranding! Welcome to I Think Not! Give the trailer a listen, and enjoy a description of the new show below: From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world ...
12.07.2022 127: A Date With Danger: The Disappearance of Nancy Moyer Nancy Moyer disappears while her children are visiting their father. Police look into Moyer's background, finding a surprisingly complicated life. Then, a murder occurs nearby, prompting authorities to ask if the cases could be connected. OBSESSED FEST YEAR 2 IS ...
12.02.2022 Obsessed Fest '23 Tickets Are On Sale NOW!!!!! CALLLING ALLL DDDDDDDDBBBBBBBSSSS!!! TICKETS FOR OBSESSED FEST '23 ARE NOW LIVE! Join us in Dallas from October 20 - 22! Come mix and mingle with your favorite true crime podcast hosts (seriously, we're just walking around or drinking at the ...
11.30.2022 126: Moment of Truth: The Disappearance of Michael Chambers When a retired firefighter goes missing, a bloody crime scene in his garage quickly indicates foul play. However, after a close look, authorities begin to consider the idea of the crime scene being staged. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 ...
11.23.2022 125: Bonus! An Interview with Mama Jo Ann Lowitzer We have a special Thanksgiving treat for you all. Jo Ann Lowitzer is the mother of Ali Lowitzer, who went missing in 2010 and is the subject of "So Close To Home" (S9 E9 of Disappeared). We had the honor ...
11.16.2022 124: Breaking Away: The Disappearance of James Martin Roberts Nineteen-year-old college sophomore Martin Roberts is a popular fraternity brother. Then, he goes missing, leaving behind a cryptic note. Two years later, Roberts' family remains desperate to know what happened to him. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you ...
11.09.2022 123: Last Stop: The Disappearance of Tabitha Tuders Thirteen-year-old Tabitha Tuders vanishes while walking to her bus stop in Nashville, Tennessee. Police think she's a runaway, but there are disturbing circumstances surrounding her disappearance, leaving her family desperate to find the truth. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 ...
11.02.2022 122: So Close to Home: The Disappearance of Ali Lowitzer Ali Lowitzer, 16, vanishes after getting off her school bus. The investigation stalls for two years until a tip comes in claiming Lowitzer could have been trafficked, leading to a SWAT team raid on a house of prostitution. LOOKING FOR ...
10.26.2022 121: Just Out of Sight: The Disappearance of Michael VanZandt Military veteran Michael VanZandt disappears one night in Hermosa Beach, California. Police suspect a group of strangers may be involved, while VanZandt's loved ones are haunted by suspicions about his thrill seeking make-up. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level ...
10.19.2022 120: In Broad Daylight: The Disappearance of Holly Cantrell Holly Cantrell is seen on security video leaving the hospital where she works, but she never arrives home. While investigating Cantrell's disappearance, police learn she has been keeping secrets. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL ...
10.12.2022 119: The Vanishing Hour: The Disappearance of Tyarra Williams In Greensboro, N.C., 19-year-old Tyarra Williams vanishes from the parking lot of her apartment complex. After receiving tips that Williams may have fallen prey to human trafficking, her grandfather embarks on a cross-country search for answers. JOIN OUR PATREON! At ...
10.05.2022 118: Born This Way: The Disappearance of Sage Smith After transgender teenager Sage Smith goes missing In Charlottesville, VA, police identify a suspect, then evidence comes to light forcing them to take a closer look at Smith's inner circle. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 ...
09.28.2022 117: Into The Mist: The Disappearance of Stephanie Crane Stephanie Crane, aged nine, leaves a local bowling alley but never arrives home. Years later, authorities hope that advances in forensic evidence testing may finally solve the mystery. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL BONUS ...
09.21.2022 116: Troubled Waters: The Disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley While on a Caribbean cruise, 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley vanishes from her family's cabin and is never seen again; over a decades-long struggle, her family embarks on a grueling search, stopping at nothing to find their beloved Amy. JOIN OUR ...
09.14.2022 115: Last Words: The Disappearance of Logan Schiendelman Logan Schiendelman vanishes, and authorities find his car abandoned; multiple tips claim seeing Logan, but searches turn up nothing; with no evidence of foul play, questions surface and police are forced to examine his family's controversial past. JOIN OUR PATREON! ...
09.07.2022 114: From The Patreon Feed: I Almost Got Away With It: Got To Pretend To Be A Cop (S8 E1) We're taking a holiday break this week so here's the first episode of us recapping a show we're loving over on the Patreon feed: I Almost Got Away With It. If you want more, head to Patreon.com/obsessedwithdisappeared. Peter Gibbs is ...
08.31.2022 113: Edge of Fourteen: The Disappearance of Ashley Summers Fun-loving 14-year-old Ashley Summers vanishes in 2007; the mystery deepens when the FBI connects her case to two other young women missing from her neighborhood. LOOKING FOR MORE OWD? JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL ...
08.24.2022 112: The Long Way Home: The Disappearance of Deanne Hastings Thirty-five-year-old mother Deanne Hastings leaves a note saying she's running to the store, but she never returns; as detectives uncover more information about Hastings' actions leading up to her disappearance, a slew of troubling theories emerge. LOOKING FOR MORE OWD? ...
08.17.2022 111: Lost Angel: The Disappearance of Angel Garcia 19-year-old Angel Garcia disappears after riding his dirt bike around Hartford CT. Friends say Angel was chased by a mysterious SUV before he disappeared. Months Later, a possible sighting in a convenience store 15 miles from home. Could it be ...
08.10.2022 110: A Bridge Too Far: The Disappearance of Danielle Imbo And Richard Petrone A date night in Philadelphia becomes deeply disturbing when a couple disappears. Their families unite to find them, but as desperation grows, finger-pointing puts them at odds. Soon, the FBI takes over the investigation that is riddled with speculation. LOOKING ...
08.03.2022 109: Last Summer: The Disappearance of Kayla Berg When 15-yr-old Kayla Berg isn't home after a night out, her loved ones believe she's staying with friends. But when six days pass, and the aspiring gymnast is missing, the details of her last known whereabouts raise suspicion in a ...
07.27.2022 108: The One That Got Away: The Disappearance of Eric Franks A young man gets life-changing news and drops everything to start a new chapter. But when he never calls home again, his family knows something is wrong. Police begin to investigate but encounter a tangled web of contradictory stories. LOOKING ...
07.20.2022 107: About A Boy: The Disappearance of Zachary Bernhardt Eight-year-old Zachary Bernhardt disappears from his Florida home late at night. Suspicions swirl around his mom, but she denies any involvement and moves away. When another boy goes missing, new theories emerge. LOOKING FOR MORE OWD? JOIN OUR PATREON! At ...
07.13.2022 106: Flight Risk: The Disappearance of Katelin Akens On route to the airport, 19-year-old Katelin Akens makes an unexpected stop at a Virginia shopping mall ... and vanishes. Police investigate her loved ones at length and start to suspect that someone close to Katelin may know more than ...
07.06.2022 105: From The Patreon Feed: Pink Collar Crimes: The Queen Of Coupons Phoenix-based housewife Robin Ramirez took extreme couponing to a whole new level when she orchestrated the largest and most lucrative fake coupon scam in U.S. history. LOOKING FOR MORE OWD? JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 ...
06.29.2022 104: Into The Night: The Disappearance of Zoe Campos After a night at home watching movies, 18-year-old Zoe Campos cannot be found by her family the next morning. As investigators pore through the teen's Facebook account, they discover she did not turn in early as her loved ones originally ...

Older episodes

I Think Not!

What's I Think Not! about?

Download our free app to listen on your phone

I Think Not! episodes:

150: Acid Lady (Deadly Wives)

149: Marlboro Man Murder (Deadly Wives)

148: Things Aren't Always What They Seem (Deadly Wives)

147: Beth's Last Party (See No Evil) w/ Christopher Walker!!

146: Dead Man Walking (See No Evil)

145: At Michelle's Door (See No Evil)

144: Stalking Cynthia (See No Evil)

142: Seen At Susan's (See No Evil)

143: The Zodiac Killer (Potentially) Identified: A New Project from Obsessed Network

141: All Eyes on Jordie (See No Evil)

140: A Mystery in the Pines (The Wonderland Murders)

139: Fatal Vows (The Other Side of the Tracks)

"Crimes of the Centuries" Returns for Season 3!

138: He Seems Perfect (Your Worst Nightmare)

137: Dangerous Game (Who the Bleep Did I Marry?)

136: The Virgin & the Bachelorette (Scorned: Love Kills)

135: New Orleans: Betrayal in the Big Easy (City Confidential)

134: Alabama Love Triangle (I Killed My BFF)

133: A Date with Hate (Dates From Hell)

132: A Beautiful Mind (Unraveled)

131: Idol Worship (Stalked: Someone's Watching)

130: Mary Kay Beckman & Steven Lane (I Dated a Psycho)

129: Disappeared Pilot REDUX: The End of Innocence (Ft. Patrick!)

128: Disappeared Special: Lauryn Is Lost

Introducing... I Think Not! (A New True Crime Comedy Podcast)

127: A Date With Danger: The Disappearance of Nancy Moyer

Obsessed Fest '23 Tickets Are On Sale NOW!!!!!

126: Moment of Truth: The Disappearance of Michael Chambers

125: Bonus! An Interview with Mama Jo Ann Lowitzer

124: Breaking Away: The Disappearance of James Martin Roberts

123: Last Stop: The Disappearance of Tabitha Tuders

122: So Close to Home: The Disappearance of Ali Lowitzer

121: Just Out of Sight: The Disappearance of Michael VanZandt

120: In Broad Daylight: The Disappearance of Holly Cantrell

119: The Vanishing Hour: The Disappearance of Tyarra Williams

118: Born This Way: The Disappearance of Sage Smith

117: Into The Mist: The Disappearance of Stephanie Crane

116: Troubled Waters: The Disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley

115: Last Words: The Disappearance of Logan Schiendelman

114: From The Patreon Feed: I Almost Got Away With It: Got To Pretend To Be A Cop (S8 E1)

113: Edge of Fourteen: The Disappearance of Ashley Summers

112: The Long Way Home: The Disappearance of Deanne Hastings

111: Lost Angel: The Disappearance of Angel Garcia

110: A Bridge Too Far: The Disappearance of Danielle Imbo And Richard Petrone

109: Last Summer: The Disappearance of Kayla Berg

108: The One That Got Away: The Disappearance of Eric Franks

107: About A Boy: The Disappearance of Zachary Bernhardt

106: Flight Risk: The Disappearance of Katelin Akens

105: From The Patreon Feed: Pink Collar Crimes: The Queen Of Coupons

104: Into The Night: The Disappearance of Zoe Campos

Other shows like I Think Not!: