In Part 2 of the Amy St. Laurent story, we follow the police investigators as they continue their search to find Amy and build a case that will bring the perpetrator to justice. 

When 25-year-old Amy St. Laurent went missing in Portland, Maine, the police weren't lacking for suspects. In Part 1, we'll do a deep dive into the police investigation to find her... was it the ex-boyfriend, the rejected suitor or the last person to see her alive? 

Kenny Ray Reichhoff was 19 years old and had grown up in the small rural community of Brooks, Wisconsin. He’d dropped out of high school during his junior year and had been living on his own since he was 17. In December 1974, Kenny was arrested for a brutal double murder in which one of the men killed was someone he considered to be like a second father to him. Was it rage that drove him to kill or something else entirely? 

A new episode

Diana Kelley and Christy Kelley didn't know each other and had never met. But they did have three things in common that led to both of them being murdered. 

In 1998, Kathy Augustine was elected as Nevada’s first female State Controller, but her tenure was not without problems. In the early morning hours of July 8, 2006, Kathy was found unconscious in her Reno, Nevada home and died three days later. Was it natural causes or had she been sleeping with the enemy?

In 1998, Kathy Augustine was elected as Nevada’s first female State Controller, but her tenure was not without problems. In the early morning hours of July 8, 2006, Kathy was found unconscious in her Reno, Nevada home and died three days later. Was it natural causes or had she been sleeping with the enemy?

In 1983, Sidney Merrick was found stabbed to death after her car broke down on the side of Interstate 80 in Utah. Thanks to numerous witnesses coming forward with detailed information, just nine days after the horrific crime an arrest warrant was issued. In 2007, advances in DNA testing conclusively linked the killer to the shocking murder of a child that had been unsolved since 1982.

In 1983, Sidney Merrick was found stabbed to death after her car broke down on the side of Interstate 80 in Utah. Thanks to numerous witnesses coming forward with detailed information, just nine days after the horrific crime an arrest warrant was issued. In 2007, advances in DNA testing conclusively linked the killer to the shocking murder of a child that had been unsolved since 1982.