When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

Korean War #38: The Perfect Scapegoat


Listen Later

Truman serves up MacArthur, and contrary to popular imagination, it was not the General, but the President, who schemed in the background - at least at this stage...


Episode 38: The Perfect Scapegoat introduces one of the most infamous aspects of the Korean War narrative to you guys – that insufferable tension between President and General which would eventually lead to the dismissal of the latter and harsh criticism of the former. It was a difficult relationship long before this plug was pulled though, and while we’ve seen disagreements and MacArthur’s reaction to the Truman administration’s policies vary, we take some time here to properly root a portion of our narrative in this perspective. More specifically, here we return to that meeting on Wake Island on 15th October between Truman and MacArthur, and we examine what I believe is the real reason why the President began to increasingly present himself alongside everyone’s favourite triumphant General. It wasn’t because he was in search of some of the glory for himself, instead it was because Truman was already thinking of the post-war situation, and of his own legacy. 


While he would accept, as President, a portion of the blame for allowing the war in Korea to escalate into the massively expensive but still limited war with the Chinese, he was not willing to accept all of this blame. Indeed, he was determined now to leave behind the crumbs of evidence which would later enable critics to note that MacArthur’s considerable and well known hubris was just as much to blame for the intervention of the Chinese as was the official line from Washington which continued to underestimate the Chinese stance and capabilities. When MacArthur assured his President that the Chinese would not intervene, Truman likely already knew thanks to the codebreaking that Mao had announced his intention to intervene in a cable to Kim Il-sung. In this respect then, General Douglas MacArthur was the perfect scapegoat – he was as belligerent and vain as he was totally out of the loop of what Washington was aiming for, and he would help take much of the focus from the President once the Chinese did, contrary to MacArthur’s claims but in line with Truman’s information, invade.

********

Music used:

“My Sweetie Went Away” by Bessie Smith, released in Nov 1923. Bessie Smith was an American blues singer. Sometimes referred to as The Empress of the Blues, Smith was the most popular female blues singer of the 1920s and 1930s. Available:  http://freemusicarchive.org/music/Bessie_Smith/Antique_Phonograph_Music_Program_02172015/My_Sweetie_Went_Away_-_Bessie_Smith 

SPONSORS

1) Use the code WDF15 to get 15% off your stylish new pair of headphones/earphones/listening things

2) To access some fascinating books, nerd out with like minded enthusiasts, further your knowledge of some classical works, get 25% off your first three months AND help the show, head on over to onlinegreatbooks.com!

Remember to BEFIT!

B is for blog

E is for email [email protected]

F is for Facebook, the Page and the Group

I is for

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

When Diplomacy Fails PodcastBy Zack Twamley

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

652 ratings


More shows like When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

View all
History of Westeros (Game of Thrones) by History of Westeros

History of Westeros (Game of Thrones)

1,229 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,454 Listeners

The British History Podcast by Jamie Jeffers

The British History Podcast

5,388 Listeners

The History of Byzantium by thehistoryofbyzantium@gmail.com

The History of Byzantium

4,287 Listeners

In Our Time: History by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time: History

1,880 Listeners

The History of England by David Crowther

The History of England

4,379 Listeners

The History of China by Chris Stewart

The History of China

1,102 Listeners

Another Mother Runner by Another Mother Runner

Another Mother Runner

1,331 Listeners

Babbage from The Economist by The Economist

Babbage from The Economist

586 Listeners

The History of English Podcast by Kevin Stroud

The History of English Podcast

6,441 Listeners

The Square Ball: Leeds United Podcast by The Square Ball

The Square Ball: Leeds United Podcast

262 Listeners

The Anfield Index Podcast by AnfieldIndex.com

The Anfield Index Podcast

113 Listeners

THE ADAM BUXTON PODCAST by ADAM BUXTON

THE ADAM BUXTON PODCAST

1,211 Listeners

Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps by Josh Szeps

Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps

844 Listeners

Daily Politics from the New Statesman by The New Statesman

Daily Politics from the New Statesman

142 Listeners

The ArsenalVision Podcast - Arsenal FC by ArsenalVision Podcast LLC

The ArsenalVision Podcast - Arsenal FC

1,021 Listeners

The History of the Twentieth Century by Mark Painter

The History of the Twentieth Century

712 Listeners

Rule The Roost - A Tottenham Hotspur Podcast by Jack Hussey

Rule The Roost - A Tottenham Hotspur Podcast

107 Listeners

The Age of Napoleon Podcast by Everett Rummage

The Age of Napoleon Podcast

2,077 Listeners

Tides of History by Wondery /  Patrick Wyman

Tides of History

6,307 Listeners

The Hellenistic Age Podcast by The Hellenistic Age Podcast

The Hellenistic Age Podcast

461 Listeners

Pax Britannica: A History of the British Empire by Samuel Hume

Pax Britannica: A History of the British Empire

369 Listeners

French Revolution & Napoleon (Grey History) by Grey History (William Clark)

French Revolution & Napoleon (Grey History)

518 Listeners

The Ancients by History Hit

The Ancients

3,285 Listeners

History of the Germans by Dirk Hoffmann-Becking

History of the Germans

470 Listeners