We are live in Love County, Oklahoma with Toby Thomas the owner of Battlesprings Ranch. During our excavation of Moxley Pond, Toby found something that looked like a human tongue and he gave it to the Medical Examiner's office for further analysis. This week we are going to speak to Toby and find out if that really was a human tongue. Toby also has some exciting breaking news about a big development in the case.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Live from Love County, Oklahoma this is day 2 of the shocking and emotional excavation of Moxley Pond. After digging for hours we finally make some headway and find some items that could be clues in the case of Molly and Colt. A few months before Molly went missing, she went to a family reunion and met up with Paula's son Heath. While talking to her, Heath had a feeling that something was wrong and warned his mother that they should do something before something bad happened to Molly. For the first time we are speaking to Heath who has joined us on the excavation and he gives his insight into the case and the search for Molly and Colt. We were so lucky to put together this incredible team to join us on the excavation. Former FBI agent aka rockstar Maureen O'Connell joins us to explain what happened on day 2 and her insight into this journey.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

We are live in Love County, Oklahoma this week documenting an excavation of Moxley Pond one of the hotspots in the Molly Miller and Colt Haynes case. Joining us is retired FBI agent Maureen O'Connell and CSI Tech and Director of the Cold Case Foundation Sheryl "Mac" McCollum. Eight months after Molly and Colt went missing, there was a 911 butt dial from Colby Barrick who was located at Moxley Pond. In the call, the dispatcher overhears Barrick, and two other males discussing Molly Miller and she alerts Joe Russell who immediately says "at Moxley Pond?" Moxley Pond is located on BattleSprings Ranch just across the road from where the car chase ended. We went to Moxley Pond in 2019 and immediately felt that this area needed to be throughly searched. The new owner of Battle Springs Ranch did a private search with cadaver dogs who hit on the pond in 2021. Now, after 9 long years, we are now conducting the first excavation of the pond...will we finally get answers?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Attorney Jason May joins us to discuss the recent events around the Carter County Sheriff Department and what this means for Molly and Colt's case. As Thanksgiving draws near, Paula Fielder joins us with her thoughts on the possible corruption in Carter County and how it feels to celebrate a holiday without knowing what happened to your loved one.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Molly and Colt's families are not alone in their struggle to find answers about their missing loved ones. In 2006, Jennifer Kesse disappeared from her apartment in Orlando, Florida and for the past 16 years her parents have been struggling to find answers. We produced a documentary about Jennifer's story for the Oxygen network around the same time we did Molly and Colt's story and we were shocked at the similarities faced by both families. Today, we are thrilled to have Jennifer Kesse's father Drew Kesse as our guest. Through Mr. Kesse's heartbreaking experience, he offers support to the families of Molly and Colt. Drew also illustrates different strategies for maneuvering the politics and media when a loved one goes missing.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

For the past nine years there have been thousands of tips, leads, theories and witnesses who have come forward to give information about what happened to Molly and Colt. There has been a lot of speculation about the validity of some of these witnesses so today we are excited to have private investigator and licensed polygraph examiner, Lisa Ribacoff join us. Lisa is going to help us sort through a testimony that has caused some speculation.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Molly Miller and Colt Haynes case still has so many questions surrounding it. What happened on that night of July 8, 2013? Who killed them? Was it one person that killed them or was a group of people? Were the killers friends of Molly and Colt or strangers? Where are their bodies? Who knows what happened to them? Who helped dispose of their remains? Are they any remains? We asked Pat Portela a retired NY Homicide Detective to come on the podcast to give us some insight into what goes on during a murder investigation like this. Pat has experience working difficult unsolved murder cases as he was on the team that investigated the infamous Gilgo Beach Serial killer case in Long Island, NY.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

For almost a decade, the family and friends of Molly Miller and Colt Haynes have lived with the tragedy of not knowing what happened to them. The traumatic effects of losing a loved are magnified by the unknowns in this case. We have always wondered how a tragedy like this affects a community and what happens when it's over and the case is solved? How will Paula and the other family members, law enforcement members and all the wonderful people who have helped over the years handle knowing the truth? How does a family and a community heal? This week we have consulted with forensic psychologist and traumatologist Dr. John Delatorre.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

After spending almost a decade of hunting for answers to Molly Miller and Colt Hayne's disappearance and deaths, Paula Fielder continues to fight the good fight. Paula's tenacity has helped keep this case alive and she credits releasing information on the podcast as her new tool to find answers. Paula goes over old tips and as well as a few new tips that can hopefully move this mystery to its conclusion.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A tipster comes forward with new shocking information about the days following Molly and Colt's disappearance and reveals a new location. Jodi Barth, former Detective and Commander with the Illinois Department of Law Enforcement does a deep dive into Molly and Colt's case and finds some revealing information about another victim who was left in the woods by Conn Nipp shortly before Molly and Colt.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices