Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Rethink... winners and losers
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Rethink... winners and losers
Do you agree with either of these statements?
Illegal migrants come here and are a burden on services and the taxpayer.
OR
The only way to reduce inequality is to tax billionaires and giant companies who avoid tax.
They may seem on opposite poles of the political spectrum, but both anti-migrant campaigners and anti-capitalists share an identical mindset. Both are demonstrating zero-sum thinking; the belief that if one group wins, another has to lose.
In itself, zero-sum thinking isn't moral or immoral, right or wrong. But Economists claim it leads to poor economic policy, and they say evidence shows it is possible to create win-win situations for everyone.
But many of the main parties at Westminster also use zero-sum thinking in their political rhetoric - from Reform and the Greens, to the Conservatives and Labour. Also, the first past the post electoral system is literally a zero-sum process. So is this kind of thinking baked-into UK politics?
So are there particular groups of people that are more prone to zero-sum beliefs? Where did this mindset come from? What economic conditions encourage zero-sum thinking, and how deeply are these beliefs held?
Presenter: Ben Ansell
Producer: Ravi Naik
Editor: Richard Vadon
Contributors:
Stefanie Stantcheva, Nathaniel Ropes Professor of Political Economy at Harvard and founder and director of the Social Economics Lab.
Dr Patricia Andrews Fearon, behavioural science researcher at social impact accelerator The Agency Fund, and Stanford University. Her research on zero-sum mindsets began during her doctoral studies at Cambridge, where she was a Gates Scholar.
Dr Parth Patel, Associate director for democracy & politics at the Institute of Public Policy and Research
Iain Mansfield, Director of Research and Head of Education and Science at Policy Exchange
Cleo Watson, Former Downing Street strategist, adviser to Theresa May and Boris Johnson, author, and presenter of Radio 4's "How to win a campaign"
View all episodes
By BBC Sounds
4.8
99 ratings
Do you agree with either of these statements?
Illegal migrants come here and are a burden on services and the taxpayer.
OR
The only way to reduce inequality is to tax billionaires and giant companies who avoid tax.
They may seem on opposite poles of the political spectrum, but both anti-migrant campaigners and anti-capitalists share an identical mindset. Both are demonstrating zero-sum thinking; the belief that if one group wins, another has to lose.
In itself, zero-sum thinking isn't moral or immoral, right or wrong. But Economists claim it leads to poor economic policy, and they say evidence shows it is possible to create win-win situations for everyone.
But many of the main parties at Westminster also use zero-sum thinking in their political rhetoric - from Reform and the Greens, to the Conservatives and Labour. Also, the first past the post electoral system is literally a zero-sum process. So is this kind of thinking baked-into UK politics?
So are there particular groups of people that are more prone to zero-sum beliefs? Where did this mindset come from? What economic conditions encourage zero-sum thinking, and how deeply are these beliefs held?
Presenter: Ben Ansell
Producer: Ravi Naik
Editor: Richard Vadon
Contributors:
Stefanie Stantcheva, Nathaniel Ropes Professor of Political Economy at Harvard and founder and director of the Social Economics Lab.
Dr Patricia Andrews Fearon, behavioural science researcher at social impact accelerator The Agency Fund, and Stanford University. Her research on zero-sum mindsets began during her doctoral studies at Cambridge, where she was a Gates Scholar.
Dr Parth Patel, Associate director for democracy & politics at the Institute of Public Policy and Research
Iain Mansfield, Director of Research and Head of Education and Science at Policy Exchange
Cleo Watson, Former Downing Street strategist, adviser to Theresa May and Boris Johnson, author, and presenter of Radio 4's "How to win a campaign"
More shows like Rethink
View all
Global News Podcast
7,887 Listeners
From Our Own Correspondent
376 Listeners
More or Less
855 Listeners
Newshour
1,072 Listeners
In Our Time
5,579 Listeners
The Documentary Podcast
1,801 Listeners
6 Minute English
1,748 Listeners
Learning English Conversations
1,033 Listeners
The Infinite Monkey Cage
1,955 Listeners
The Bottom Line
40 Listeners
Thinking Allowed
306 Listeners
Moral Maze
69 Listeners
The Life Scientific
232 Listeners
Start the Week
159 Listeners
Westminster Hour
45 Listeners
The Briefing Room
78 Listeners
13 Minutes Presents: Artemis II
4,173 Listeners
You're Dead to Me
3,223 Listeners
Inside Briefing with the Institute for Government
24 Listeners
Americast
789 Listeners
The Rest Is Politics
3,900 Listeners
The Rest Is Politics: Leading
855 Listeners
When It Hits the Fan
49 Listeners
How To Win An Election
25 Listeners
Rory Stewart: The Long History of...
78 Listeners