Originally released as a bonus episode and now brought to you from the Super SUS archives.  Life has been a little chaotic lately for your co-hosts, but we’re doing our best to keep fresh-ish content coming your way each week.

When 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart agreed to house-sit for her aunt and uncle in Pocatello, Idaho, it seemed like an easy, quiet weekend. Instead, it became one of the most disturbing and calculated teen-perpetrated murders in recent memory.

In this episode, we walk through who Cassie was, the events leading up to that night, and how investigators uncovered a shocking plot hiding in plain sight. As the truth emerged, the case revealed disturbing motivations, recorded evidence, and a level of premeditation that left her community and loved ones reeling.

We discuss the investigation, the evidence that ultimately led to arrests, and the lasting impact Cassie’s loss has had on her family and the wider community.

Support the show

In October 2019, 26-year-old Kristen Trickle was found with a fatal gunshot wound in her Kansas home. Her husband, Colby Trickle, told police she had taken her own life.

At first, the case appeared straightforward. But investigators soon began noticing details that didn’t add up. As questions mounted, what was initially ruled a suicide became far more complicated.

This episode examines the circumstances surrounding Kristen’s death and the troubling inconsistencies that followed.

Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussion of suicide, which may be distressing for some listeners.

If you or someone you know is struggling:
In the U.S., you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. If you are outside the U.S., local crisis resources are available in most countries.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we examine the disturbing case of Wade Wilson, the man known in the media as the Deadpool Killer.

In October 2019, Wade murdered Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz in Cape Coral, Florida, killing both women within hours of each other in a brutal and seemingly random crime spree. The violence of the attacks, combined with Wade’s behavior before and after his arrest, left investigators and the community shaken.

We explore Wade’s background, the details of the murders, and the disturbing patterns that emerged as the investigation unfolded. The episode also examines the profound impact these crimes had on the victims’ families, as well as the unsettling attention and fan following Wade later attracted while incarcerated.

We break down the trial proceedings that led to Wade’s conviction on two counts of first-degree murder, his sentencing to death, and the status of his ongoing appeals.

This is a case that forces us to confront not only extreme violence, but the culture that can grow around it — and the innocent lives forever changed in its wake.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we examine the shocking and deeply disturbing death of Michelle Jones, whose life ended in violence inside her own Orlando home.

Michelle had invited her aunt Teri Brandt and Teri’s husband to stay with her while they evacuated ahead of a hurricane. When Michelle stopped answering her phone, friends became alarmed and went to check on her — only to find a scene of terrifying violence.

Inside Michelle’s house, two lives had been taken, and one lost by suicide. The brutality of the crime, the locked-from-the-inside scene, and the questions it raised sent investigators down a path that ultimately uncovered a much larger, darker story than anyone expected.

What starts as an investigation into a tragic double death inside a family home unfolds into a far more unsettling tale — forcing us all to confront how danger can hide even in places we trust most.

Support the show

On this episode of Super SUS, we take a closer look at the mysterious and tragic death of Melissa James, whose life came to a shocking end amidst the chaotic world of Las Vegas bodybuilding.

Join us as we uncover the puzzling circumstances surrounding Melissa's death, the hidden secrets of those around her, and the stunning twists that left investigators searching for answers. What really happened to Melissa, and what lies beneath the surface of this sensational case?

Tune in to hear us explore the layers of mystery, ambition, and scandal in a story that will leave you questioning everything.

Support the show

In our latest episode of Super SUS, we examine the tragic and still-unsolved Lane Bryant store shooting that occurred in Tinley Park, Illinois, on February 2, 2008. We dive into the chilling details of the case, describing how a gunman, posing as a delivery driver, held six women hostage, resulting in the execution-style murders of five. We discuss the survivor's account, the evidence collected, and the various theories that have emerged over the years. Despite extensive investigations and advancements in DNA technology, the killer remains at large, leaving both the community and the victims' families with unanswered questions.

Join us as we honor the memory of the victims and explore the complexities of one of the Chicago area’s most haunting cold cases.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we examine the disturbing case of Zach Bowen and Addie Hall, a couple whose relationship began in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans. What started as a connection forged through shared interests and intense circumstances slowly unraveled under the weight of substance abuse, emotional volatility, and unresolved trauma. 

We explore Zach’s deeply troubled background, including his military service and struggles with PTSD, alongside Addie’s history of abusive relationships and ongoing mental health challenges. As tensions escalate, their story takes an increasingly dark turn, raising troubling questions about accountability, mental illness, and the warning signs that were missed. This episode unpacks a case that is as complex as it is unsettling, highlighting how personal tragedy and untreated trauma can collide with devastating consequences.

Resources & Support

If this episode brings up difficult feelings or you or someone you know needs support, help is available:

• National Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (U.S.)
  Call or text 988 | 24/7 support for emotional distress and crisis situations
• Veterans Crisis Line
  Call 988, then press 1, or text 838255 | Confidential support for veterans and their families
• National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI)
  nami.org | Education, advocacy, and support for individuals and families affected by mental illness
• Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)
  findtreatment.gov | Resources for mental health and substance use treatment
• National Domestic Violence Hotline
  thehotline.org | Call 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or text START to 88788

Support the show

In Part 2 of our coverage on the disappearance of Jennifer Kesse, we pick up where the investigation deepens—and the questions become even more troubling.

We break down the leading theories that have emerged over the years, including the possibility of an abduction linked to construction workers at Jennifer’s condo complex, the role of opportunity and access, and whether her disappearance was a targeted crime or a tragic random act. We take a closer look at the most critical pieces of evidence, including the infamous surveillance footage, the mysterious carpet found near her car, and evolving DNA testing that has brought renewed attention to the case.

This episode also centers the tireless efforts of Jennifer’s family, who have spent nearly two decades pushing for answers, accountability, and continued investigation. We discuss recent developments, advances in forensic technology, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s renewed involvement as the case enters a new phase.

Nearly 20 years later, Jennifer Kesse’s disappearance remains unsolved—but not forgotten. Part 2 explores what we know, what still doesn’t add up, and why this case continues to haunt investigators, loved ones, and everyone searching for justice.

Resources:

Find Jennifer Kesse Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/FindJenniferKesse/
Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE): https://www.fdle.state.fl.us

If you have information related to Jennifer Kesse’s disappearance, contact your local law enforcement agency or submit a tip through FDLE. Even small details may matter.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we begin our deep dive into the disappearance of Jennifer Kesse, a 24-year-old professional who vanished from her Orlando, Florida condo in January 2006.

Jennifer was last heard from the night before she disappeared, after speaking with her boyfriend. The following morning, she failed to show up for work—a rare occurrence—and concern quickly escalated. When her family checked her condo, they found signs of a normal morning routine, but Jennifer was gone. Her car was missing as well.

Two days later, the vehicle was located at a nearby apartment complex, about a mile from her home. Surveillance footage captured an unidentified individual parking the car and walking away—one of the most haunting and frustrating pieces of evidence in the case.

Part 1 focuses on who Jennifer was, the early hours after she vanished, and the initial investigation as law enforcement worked to piece together what might have happened. We explore early theories, unanswered questions, and the unsettling clues that would come to define one of Florida’s most enduring missing-person cases.

Support the show

In this episode of Super SUS, we dig into the life and crimes of Aileen Wuornos, often called the “Damsel of Death” Wuornos was a serial killer who murdered seven men in Florida between 1989 and 1990, later being convicted of six of those killings.

We walk through Aileen’s deeply unstable childhood, marked by abandonment, abuse, and early exposure to violence, and how those experiences shaped her adult life, including her years surviving through sex work. Aileen claimed the murders were acts of self-defense against violent clients, a claim that remains heavily debated and complicated by evidence, witness accounts, and her own changing statements.

We examine the investigation, her highly publicized trial, and the role of Tyria Moore, her longtime partner, whose cooperation with law enforcement ultimately led to Aileen’s arrest and conviction. Along the way, we grapple with the bigger question at the heart of this case: was Aileen Wuornos a calculated predator, or the tragic product of years of trauma, neglect, and systemic failure?

Content Warning & Resources

This episode discusses violence, sexual assault, and domestic abuse. Listener discretion is advised.

If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence or abuse, help is available:

• National Domestic Violence Hotline (U.S.)
  Call 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or text START to 88788
  Available 24/7
• RAINN (Sexual Assault Support)
  Call 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or chat online
  Available 24/7
• 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (U.S.)
  Call or text 988 for immediate emotional support

If you’re outside the U.S., local resources can often be found through your country’s health services or domestic violence advocacy organizations.

You are not alone—and support is available.

Support the show