That Aged Well

By That Aged Well Podcast

Feel conflicted about the movies you loved as a kid? Let Paul and Erika guide you through all that beloved garbage we watched...after all, nostalgia is more fun when you aren't the only one embarrasse... more

4.9

634634 ratings

Download on the App Store

Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play

FAQs about That Aged Well:

How many episodes does That Aged Well have?

The podcast currently has 380 episodes available.

That Aged Well episodes:

December 08, 2025 200 Cigarettes (1999) - Crab Dip, Crotch Pits & a Cigarette Ash
Have you ever listened to this podcast, and thought “Man, I wish Erika and Paul would talk about New York City more. Like, they live there, and they NEVER bring that up.” Well, have we ever got an episode for you, because 1999’s 200 Cigarettes not only boasts a cast of thousands, it was shot in the New York of the hosts’ college-years and it is hitting their nostalgia buttons hard. Strap in for some very specific Elitist East Coast C*ntent (shirt now available in our Dashery store)!
You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 2min
December 01, 2025 A “Friends” Thanksgiving Extravaganza (1994) - Cooking Outfits, Lady Fingers & a 19-Pound Turkey
It’s a That Aged Well first, as Paul and Erika RETURN to a subject for the first time in the history of the show! After reviewing the first season of Friends in 2019, they now kick off Holiday December with a look at three of the iconic show’s famous Thanksgiving episodes. Here lies such classics as Chandler in a box, Rachel’s “trifle,” and a big swing on stunt casting that may or may not be successful…your hosts can’t agree!
We would so appreciate your help in filling out our Listener Survey!!
You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 18min
November 24, 2025 Double Indemnity (1944) - Dictaphones, Insurance Investigators & a Wig
We are rounding out Classics month with a real, undeniable classic: it’s Billy Wilder’s 1944 noir Double Indemnity! Did everyone else already know that this movie is about insurance? No, really, a lot of the plot revolves around insurance policies! Also, point of order, Erika and Paul would like to formally apologize to all Lolas for the slander on this episode. They will try (but probably fail) to do better in the future.
We would so appreciate your help in filling out our Listener Survey!!
You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 11min
November 17, 2025 Blazing Saddles (1974) - Horse Actors, Johnsons & a Wed Wose
Man, this month is gonna give listeners whiplash…after a sunny musical and a disturbing melodrama, we’re going with Mel Brooks’ 1974 Western spoof Blazing Saddles! Sure, Paul once claimed he would never even attempt to talk about this movie, but Erika got him drunk and before he knew it, they were recording.

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
1h 58min
November 10, 2025 Suddenly, Last Summer (1959) - Feeding Frenzies, Elevators & a 5 O’ Clock Daiquiri
Classic Film November rolls on with something just a little different…1959’s Suddenly, Last Summer which might just possibly be the darkest film ever done on That Aged Well. And we did A Nightmare On Elm Street two weeks ago! Erika and Paul take you through all of it, with time left to talk about what plastic surgery they’d get for $23 million, the provenance of winged skeletons, and foyer elevators!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 21min
November 03, 2025 Singin’ In The Rain (1952) - Round Tones, Rage Blackouts & a Triple Threat
We’ve made it through October, which means we’re kicking off another tradition here at That Aged Well…Classic Movie November! And we’re ringing in November with a true classic: Singin’ In The Rain, which comes with a cavalcade of dancing, singing, and stories of how Gene Kelly maybe wasn’t so nice on set. Come join Paul and Erika as they bask in what is widely considered to be one of the greatest movies ever made!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), and Threads (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 31min
October 27, 2025 A Nightmare On Elm Street (1984) - Parenting, Dream Logic & a Warm Bath
It’s the final Monday in October and y’all know what that means…Erika and Paul watched a slasher film! Well, Erika watched it and Paul “watched” it, but we can only hope for so much here. Particularly with this one, Wes Craven’s classic A Nightmare On Elm Street, which gives your hosts a chance to talk about DIY projects, bed TVs, and random bottles of vodka!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), and Threads (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 17min
October 20, 2025 Return To Oz (1985) - Hardware Stores, Electric Shock Therapy & an Adrenaline Junkie
After watching Rosemary’s Baby and The Faculty, Paul is sure that watching this movie for children will be a nice respite for him in Spooky October. Right? Right?!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), and Threads (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
1h 58min
October 13, 2025 The Faculty (1998) - Principal Velma Kelly, Coach Terminator & a Mousy Jean Grey
Spooky October is in full swing, and That Aged Well is moving from witches to aliens! Paul and Erika watched The Faculty and are in awe of the level of talent in the cast, the level of caffeine pills in the plotting, and the level of stupid in the haircuts. Come join them as they take a romp through the first film they’ve ever done that features Bebe Neuwirth!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), and Threads (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 12min
October 06, 2025 Rosemary’s Baby (1968) - Towels, Fake Phone Calls & a Thin Final Straw
It’s October, which means it’s Spooky Season, which means it’s scary movies all month! Erika and Paul are kicking it off with a true classic of the genre this time…Rosemary’s Baby! As anyone who has seen this movie could predict, the Elitist East Coast C*ntent starts early and goes late in this very New York film, but that doesn’t mean they also don’t take the time to celebrate Mia Farrow, John Cassavetes, and, most of all, Ruth Gordon!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), and Threads (@ThatAgedWell)!
SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!
VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!
Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!
Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba
Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
...more
2h 25min

FAQs about That Aged Well:

How many episodes does That Aged Well have?

The podcast currently has 380 episodes available.

More shows like That Aged Well

You Must Remember This by Karina Longworth

You Must Remember This

14,047 Listeners

...These Are Their Stories: The Law & Order Podcast by Partners in Crime Media

...These Are Their Stories: The Law & Order Podcast

1,095 Listeners

The Bechdel Cast by iHeartPodcasts

The Bechdel Cast

3,160 Listeners

I Hate It But I Love It by The From Superheroes Network

I Hate It But I Love It

1,017 Listeners

You're Wrong About by Sarah Marshall

You're Wrong About

21,862 Listeners

The Villain Was Right by The From Superheroes Network

The Villain Was Right

440 Listeners

American Hysteria by chelsey weber-smith

American Hysteria

3,321 Listeners

Too Scary; Didn't Watch by Headgum

Too Scary; Didn't Watch

2,124 Listeners

WHAT WENT WRONG by Sad Boom Media

WHAT WENT WRONG

3,317 Listeners

You Are Good by Sarah Marshall + Alex Steed

You Are Good

2,707 Listeners

Romancing the Pod by Romancing the Pod - Paige Wesley, Todd Schlosser

Romancing the Pod

660 Listeners

This Ends at Prom by Pod People Productions

This Ends at Prom

549 Listeners

Maintenance Phase by Aubrey Gordon & Michael Hobbes

Maintenance Phase

16,801 Listeners

Dear Movies, I Love You by Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

Dear Movies, I Love You

3,789 Listeners

If Books Could Kill by Michael Hobbes & Peter Shamshiri

If Books Could Kill

9,229 Listeners