Top Comment

Top Comment

Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    49

    Followers

  • Typical duration

    30 min

    per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

Top Comment episodes

  • Marianna in Conspiracyland 2: 5. A collective immune system

    Can people fight back against medical misinformation? In the months after Paloma’s death, her brothers say they want to prevent other deaths, and they believe social media companies should take stronger action against medical misinformation. Meanwhile her Mum, Kate Shemirani, takes to social media to share a different account of her death. She has promoted a range of unproven theories on social media and podcasts about how Paloma was murdered by medical staff. The BBC has not seen evidence to support this. The BBC’s social media investigations correspondent Marianna Spring interrogates whether and how some politicians and social media companies are emboldening anti-medicine conspiracy theorists, and speaks to a former cancer surgeon and patient trying to bust cancer myths online.

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Anna Harris
    Sound Engineer: Tony Churnside
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning producer: Nathan Jones
    Commissioning editor: Rhian Roberts

    This was a BBC collaboration with Panorama.

    25 min
  • Marianna in Conspiracyland 2: 4. The Archaeologists

    Are we equipped to deal with a rising tide of misinformation? The BBC’s social media investigations correspondent Marianna Spring investigates how safeguarding procedures work and how social services and hospitals are trying to deal with the mainstreaming of medical misinformation. She speaks to a social worker who says it’s time for the law to be reviewed in England and finds out more about what happened to Paloma in the months after she left hospital. Were there missed opportunities to help her?

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Anna Harris
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Sound Engineer: Tony Churnside
    Production Coordinator: Maria Ogundele
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning producer: Nathan Jones
    Commissioning editor: Rhian Roberts
    This was a BBC collaboration with Panorama. Watch Cancer Conspiracy Theories on iPlayer now.

    23 min
  • Marianna in Conspiracyland 2: 3. Down the cancer conspiracy rabbit hole

    What are cancer patients seeing on social media? The BBC’s social media investigations correspondent Marianna Spring goes down the cancer conspiracy rabbit hole to find out. She returns to the days Paloma spent in hospital after her cancer diagnosis to analyse the advice Paloma was being given by medical staff versus the advice she was receiving from alternative practioners and her Mum, Kate Shemirani. Marianna investigates Paloma’s mum’s platform as a conspiracy theory influencer and looks at the wider role some social media sites are playing in turbocharging accounts that promote health misinformation. Plus, she speaks to the Vice President of Royal College of Radiologists to understand how harmful content on social media is affecting patients.

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Anna Harris
    Sound Engineer: Tony Churnside
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning producer: Nathan Jones
    Commissioning editor: Rhian Roberts

    This was a BBC collaboration with Panorama.

    31 min
  • Marianna in Conspiracyland 2: 2. Conspiracyland at home

    Could the answer lie in the past? The BBC’s social media investigations correspondent, Marianna Spring, continues investigating what happened to Paloma Shemirani. She speaks to Paloma’s brothers to see if the answers could lie in the house they grew up in. Who is Paloma’s mum - prominent British conspiracy theorist influencer Kate Shemirani - and how did her beliefs evolve and impact Paloma and her siblings? Could her mum’s conspiracy theory views have influenced Paloma’s decision to reject chemotherapy?

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Anna Harris
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Sound Designer: Tony Churnside
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning producer: Nathan Jones
    Commissioning editor: Rhian Roberts
    This was a BBC collaboration with Panorama. Watch Cancer Conspiracy Theories on iPlayer now.

    30 min
  • Marianna in Conspiracyland 2: 1. The Dove and the Pigeon

    What happened to Paloma? Aged 22, Paloma Shemirani has her whole life ahead of her. She’s recently graduated, moved into a flat and found a job. But just days before Christmas in 2023 she receives bad news, she has cancer - an aggressive but treatable form of Lymphoma. Despite a good prognosis, Paloma decides - at least initially - to reject chemotherapy. The BBC’s social media investigations correspondent Marianna Spring investigates what happened and what this tells us about the mainstreaming of anti-medicine ideas.

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Anna Harris
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Sound Designer: Tony Churnside
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning producer: Nathan Jones
    Commissioning editor: Rhian Roberts

    This was a BBC collaboration with Panorama.

    33 min
  • Why Do You Hate Me? USA: 5. Fandom Frenzies: Who’s afraid of little old us?

    In Why Do You Hate Me? USA, BBC disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring is investigating how what’s happening online can shape the 2024 presidential election.

    In this episode, Marianna goes deep inside the world of a particular kind of social media tribe: the fandom. These groups revolve around the love for celebrities from pop stars like Taylor Swift to billionaire Elon Musk. And now political activists are operating a bit like fandoms to boost the chances of their favourite candidate. So could the social media tactics used by mega fans change the minds of voters in the upcoming election?
    And can the dedication fandoms inspire exist without trolling and hate?
    Host: Marianna Spring
    Producer: Daniel Wittenberg
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts
    Sound Designer: Tony Churnside
    Production Co-ordiantor: Katie Morrison

    29 min
  • Why Do You Hate Me? USA: 4. Doxxed and Blocked: ‘We’re distressed about war in the Middle East and now trolls are after us.'

    Few topics have caused as much division online as the deepening war in the Middle East. In this episode, Marianna is in New York investigating the experiences of students targeted on social media. They have been affected by doxxing – where their personal information is shared online triggering racist and misogynistic hate – by people wanting to make a wider political argument. The abuse that they have received has impacted each of their views in different but significant ways and potentially influenced their vote in the US presidential election. Marianna tracks down some of their trolls and confronts one of them.

    Host: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Daniel Wittenberg
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts
    Sound Design: Tony Churnside
    Production Co-ordinator: Rosie Strawbridge

    29 min
  • Why Do You Hate Me? USA: 3. The Fable of the Pikesville Clip: ‘I’ve been burnt by the fire once, so I’ll think twice before posting’

    A headteacher at a school in small American suburb of Baltimore was a prominent member of the local community. But many in the neighbourhood turned on Principal Eric Eiswert, after an audio clip emerged of him appearing to make racist and antisemitic remarks.

    Except, what no one knew then was that another bombshell would transform what they thought of the headteacher – and of themselves.
    In this episode of Why Do You Hate Me? USA, Marianna investigates the network of posts and people that can make it so hard to know what’s really going on, even down the street. She explores a new tool at the disposal of conspiracy theorists, trolls, and bad actors at the 2024 presidential election, and interrogates the damage it can cause to tightly-knit communities.
    Host: Marianna Spring
    Producer: Daniel Wittenberg
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts
    Sound Design: Tony Churnside
    Production Co-ordinator: Rosie Strawbridge

    29 min
  • Why Do You Hate Me? USA: 2. Counting The Threats: 'I just work in IT – why am I getting threats from election deniers?'

    What are the real-world consequences of the belief that almost anything and everything can be staged or rigged – from assassination attempts to elections?

    In Why Do You Hate Me? USA, BBC disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring is investigating how what’s happening online can shape the 2024 presidential election.
    In this episode, Marianna continues her journey through Colorado to hear about what happens when some people no longer trust systems and institutions – and then send hate to the people they see complicit in unproven plots and conspiracies.
    She meets the election workers who feared for their safety after Donald Trump and some of his supporters falsely claimed the 2020 election was stolen and public officials were overwhelmed with abuse and threats online. Could it possibly get worse this time around?
    Host: Marianna Spring
    Producer: Daniel Wittenberg
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts
    Sound Designer: Tony Churnside
    Production Co-ordinator: Rosie Strawbridge

    29 min
  • Why Do You Hate Me? USA: 1. Wild Thoughts: 'I hate Trump, she likes him – we both think he staged assassination attempts'

    Meet Camille and ‘Wild Mother’. Both women love nature, animals, and the outdoors. Both women also believe the assassination attempts on Donald Trump were staged – but have very different political views. Why do people believe the things they do? And what role do social media sites – and their algorithms – play?

    In this series, BBC disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring travels to the United States to investigate the social media backdrop to the 2024 presidential election and explore the different ways in which what is happening online is influencing the campaign offline.
    Marianna starts her journey in Colorado, looking at how conspiracy theories have spread so far across the political spectrum in the US. She interrogates the consequences for Camille, ‘Wild Mother’, and the upcoming election.
    Host: Marianna Spring
    Producer: Daniel Wittenberg
    Story Editor: Matt Willis
    Editor: Sam Bonham
    Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts
    Sound Designer: Tony Churnside
    Production Co-ordinator: Rosie Strawbridge

    29 min

About Top Comment

From the publisher's feed

The story behind your social media feed, from BBC correspondent Marianna Spring and investigative journalist Matt Shea.

Top Comment investigates what's blowing up online. From global events…

More shows like Top Comment

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,574 Listeners

Business Daily by BBC World Service

Business Daily

524 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,041 Listeners

World Business Report by BBC World Service

World Business Report

285 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,499 Listeners

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4 by BBC Radio 4

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4

2,092 Listeners

File on 4 Investigates by BBC Radio 4

File on 4 Investigates

43 Listeners

The Life Scientific by BBC Radio 4

The Life Scientific

237 Listeners

Evil Genius with Russell Kane by BBC Radio 4

Evil Genius with Russell Kane

345 Listeners

Have You Heard George's Podcast? by BBC Sounds

Have You Heard George's Podcast?

233 Listeners

Elis James and John Robins by Significant Productions

Elis James and John Robins

311 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,212 Listeners

The Slow Newscast by The Observer

The Slow Newscast

162 Listeners

Americast by BBC News

Americast

720 Listeners

British Scandal by Audible

British Scandal

2,495 Listeners

Sport's Strangest Crimes by BBC Radio 5 Live

Sport's Strangest Crimes

77 Listeners

Spiral | Tortoise Investigates by The Observer

Spiral | Tortoise Investigates

3,449 Listeners

Uncanny by BBC Radio 4

Uncanny

795 Listeners

The Coming Storm by BBC Radio 4

The Coming Storm

517 Listeners

Dua Lipa: At Your Service by BBC Sounds

Dua Lipa: At Your Service

1,002 Listeners

Lady Killers with Lucy Worsley by BBC Radio 4

Lady Killers with Lucy Worsley

525 Listeners

Unmissables: Explosive Lies by Global

Unmissables: Explosive Lies

618 Listeners

Believe in Magic by BBC Studios

Believe in Magic

628 Listeners

The Global Story by BBC World Service

The Global Story

382 Listeners

The Louis Theroux Podcast by Spotify Studios

The Louis Theroux Podcast

457 Listeners

Black Box: The Chatbots by The Guardian

Black Box: The Chatbots

479 Listeners

Miss Me? by Persephonica

Miss Me?

237 Listeners

Intrigue by BBC Radio 4

Intrigue

176 Listeners

The History Podcast by BBC Radio 4

The History Podcast

59 Listeners

Crime Next Door by BBC Sounds

Crime Next Door

114 Listeners

Shadow World by BBC Radio 4

Shadow World

30 Listeners

Rory Stewart: The Long History of... by BBC Radio 4

Rory Stewart: The Long History of...

73 Listeners

The Crime Agents by Global

The Crime Agents

46 Listeners