Top Comment

Top Comment

Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    49

    Followers

  • Typical duration

    30 min

    per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

Top Comment episodes

  • Disaster Trolls: 3. The Insider

    What sort of person spreads false claims about survivors of terror attacks? An unexpected source gives Marianna Spring the inside track on conspiracy show host Richard D Hall.

    Neil Sanders has moved in the same sort of conspiracy-minded circles as Hall for years. He’s been a regular guest on Hall’s show. Neil even says he probably wouldn’t have written his book without Hall’s encouragement. In this episode, he helps Marianna chart Hall’s evolution from a UFO enthusiast obsessed with alien abductions to someone who promotes toxic conspiracy theories.

    Neil rejects Hall’s theories about so-called “crisis actors” and faked terror attacks, and he recognises the distress those false claims cause to survivors.

    In this BBC Radio 4 podcast, the BBC’s disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring, investigates how survivors of UK terror attacks and tragedies are targeted with horrific conspiracy theories, online abuse and threats. Some are even tracked down offline too. Now they want answers and justice.

    This episode contains audio from Richard D Hall’s website.

    Presenter: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Ant Adeane
    Editor: Ed Main

    16 min
  • Disaster Trolls: 2. Sharpening the Spike

    Martin and his daughter suffered life-changing injuries in the Manchester Arena bombing, but one conspiracy theorist claims to have gone to great lengths to try to prove otherwise.

    Eve, then 14, and her father were the closest people to the blast to survive the 2017 terror attack, in which 22 people and the bomber were killed.

    During the months that followed, Martin was shocked to be told about false claims, promoted by conspiracy show host Richard D Hall, that the bombing was faked. Hall accused him and other survivors of lying about their injuries. But then to Martin’s even greater horror, he discovered Hall had shared a video with his followers online where he demonstrated how he would set up a camera to film Eve - now profoundly disabled and in a wheelchair - to see whether she could in fact walk.

    In this BBC Radio 4 podcast series, the BBC’s disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring, investigates how survivors of UK terror attacks and tragedies are targeted with horrific conspiracy theories, online abuse and threats.

    Across this series - and in this episode - there are graphic descriptions of violence. This episode contains audio from Richard D Hall’s website.

    Presenter: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Ant Adeane
    Editor: Ed Main

    14 min
  • Disaster Trolls: 1. Darkness in the Glade of Light

    Daren is haunted by his experience of the Manchester Arena bombing. So why do people taunt him with conspiracy theories which falsely claim the attack didn’t happen?

    On 22 May 2017, a terrorist bomb was detonated in the foyer of the arena at the end of an Ariana Grande concert, killing 22 people and the bomber. Daren, who had been in the audience with his son, rushed to help the injured. He has lived with the trauma of that night ever since.

    But to Daren’s disbelief, it wasn’t long before sinister claims began circulating online, wild allegations that the attack was faked. He and other survivors were accused of being “crisis actors” paid to play a part in a massive deception by evil forces in the government.

    So who is propagating these baseless claims?

    In this BBC Radio 4 podcast, the BBC’s disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring, investigates how survivors of UK terror attacks and tragedies are targeted with horrific conspiracy theories, online abuse and threats. Some are even tracked down offline too. Now they want answers and justice.

    Across this series - and in this episode - there are graphic descriptions of violence. This episode contains audio from Richard D Hall’s website.

    Presenter: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Ant Adeane
    Editor: Ed Main

    16 min
  • Disaster Trolls: Introducing... Disaster Trolls

    What happens when tragedy makes you a target? Why would anybody accuse terrorism survivors of being liars and “crisis actors”?

    The BBC’s disinformation and social media correspondent Marianna Spring investigates how people caught up in the Manchester Arena bombing and other UK terror attacks, are targeted with extreme conspiracy theories, online abuse and threats. Some are even hunted down offline. It’s a phenomenon we might usually associate with the US, and the billion dollar damages ruling against Alex Jones for claiming the Sandy Hook school shootings were faked. But Marianna uncovers shocking evidence that British trolls are also blighting the lives of people right here in the UK, people who now want answers and justice.

    Presenter: Marianna Spring

    Producer: Ant Adeane

    Editor: Ed Main

    3 min
  • War on Truth: 9. Roddy: 'We don’t trust the media, so we became it'

    Citizen journalism – reporting by self-taught people, often on the ground - can play a vital role in the coverage of conflict. However, not everyone who contributes to this coverage is as 'independent'’ as they’d like their followers to believe.

    Roddy’s distrust of the media led him to start his own podcast. He also follows self-styled citizen journalists who are roaming around inside Ukraine.
    In this episode of War On Truth, the BBC’s specialist disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates some of their work. She speaks with an expert who has analysed some of their coverage, tries to understand how it gets made, what might be influencing it - and why it spreads to people like Roddy.
    Producer: Joseph Martin
    Editor: Ant Adeane

    17 min
  • War on Truth: 8. Tetyana: ‘My son is the Snake Island hero’

    On the first day of the war, Ukraine gained a new patriotic hero and Tetyana thought she had lost a son. But the story wasn't quite as it first seemed.

    Tetyana’s son, Roman became world famous for defiantly swearing at a Russian warship which had threatened to bomb him and his fellow border guards on Snake Island, if they didn’t surrender.

    A recording of the exchange went viral and the Ukrainian government declared that Roman and his comrades had died as national heroes.

    Tetyana was plunged into grief as her son was celebrated as a symbol of national resistance.

    But, as she recounts, events soon took an unexpected turn.

    The ramifications of what actually happened at Snake Island have become a battleground in the information war that is being fought over Ukraine, alongside the military battle. And like the conflict on the ground, this fight also has real consequences for the people whose lives it touches.

    In this podcast series, BBC disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates stories from Ukraine, Russia, and around the world, and hears from those caught up in the battle for the truth.

    Producers: Ant Adeane and Joseph Martin

    Editor: Ed Main

    16 min
  • War on Truth: 7. Sergei: ‘It’s my duty to keep telling Russians the truth’

    After Russia’s first independent radio station was taken off air by the Kremlin, the journalists who worked there are finding ways to get round censorship of the war in Ukraine.

    Sergei Buntman helped to found Echo of Moscow which for more than three decades provided an alternative to the news on Russian state media.

    In the days following the invasion of Ukraine, his radio station and several other news organisations were forced to shut down for challenging the official narrative about the war.

    Yet despite threats of violence and imprisonment, Sergei and some of his fellow Russian journalists are refusing to stay silent, and are finding new ways to make themselves heard.

    They find themselves on the frontline of the information war that is being fought over Ukraine, alongside the military battle. And like the conflict on the ground, this fight also has real consequences for the people whose lives it touches.

    Russia’s military assault has been accompanied by an onslaught of disinformation and propaganda from state media, trolls and influencers. With all sides seeking to capture and control the narrative, how do you tell what is fake and what is real?

    In this podcast series, BBC disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates stories from Ukraine, Russia, and around the world, and hears from those caught up in the battle for the truth.

    Producer: Ant Adeane

    Editor: Ed Main

    21 min
  • War on Truth: 6. The View from the Other Side

    Marianna Vishegirskaya is the pregnant woman who has unwittingly found herself at the centre of one of the most disputed events of the war.

    In a previous episode we looked at how Russia falsely accused her of helping fake photos of the aftermath of its attack on a maternity hospital, in which at least three people were killed.

    But now Marianna has told her side of the story, after escaping the besieged city of Mariupol with her husband and newborn baby.

    Her interview, given to a pro-Kremlin journalist, flatly contradicts much of what Russia has said up to now. But some of her comments have been cherry picked to promote a new version of events which also absolves Russia of any blame.

    Despite all the contradictions in the propaganda, Marianna’s Russian friend Yaroslava still believes Russian state media rather than the woman she knows personally.

    It’s a sign of the power of the information war being fought over Ukraine alongside the military battle. And like the conflict on the ground, this fight also has real consequences for the people whose lives it touches.

    Russia’s military assault has been accompanied by an onslaught of disinformation and propaganda from state media, trolls and influencers. With all sides seeking to capture and control the narrative, how do you tell what is fake and what is real?

    In this podcast series, BBC disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates stories from Ukraine, Russia, and around the world, and hears from those caught up in the battle for the truth.

    Producer: Joseph Martin

    Editor: Ed Main

    19 min
  • War on Truth: 5. Rob: ‘Covid was a hoax, and so is the war’

    What does the invasion of Ukraine have in common with the coronavirus pandemic?

    On the face of it not much at all, but disinformation about the war is also fuelling existing conspiracy movements around the world.

    Covid denialists who claimed the pandemic was invented by a shadowy elite to impose a tyrannical global government, now believe that the conflict in Ukraine is part of the same evil plot.

    It’s a bizarre offshoot of the extraordinary information war that’s being fought over Ukraine, in parallel to the military campaign on the ground.

    So how and why are these baseless conspiracy theories taking root?

    In this podcast series, BBC disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates stories from Ukraine, Russia, and around the world, and hears from those caught up in the battle over the truth.

    Producer: Ant Adeane

    Editor: Ed Main

    18 min
  • War on Truth: 4. One Baby, Three Photos, and a Web of Lies

    When Russia bombed a maternity hospital in Mariupol, it claimed that a wounded pregnant woman was faking it. Her friends told us something different.

    Images of Marianna Vyshemirska fleeing the aftermath of the attack caused an outcry around the world. But they were also seized upon for a furious disinformation campaign, waged by people including Russian diplomats, that sought to justify the bombing.

    But we’ve found clear evidence that the Russian story is false, and that the pregnant woman who was bombed was targeted again online - by pro-Russian trolls.

    Marianna’s friends say she’s become a pawn in the information war over Ukraine that is raging alongside the military battle. And like the conflict on the ground, this fight also has real consequences for the people whose lives it touches.

    In this podcast series, BBC disinformation reporter Marianna Spring investigates stories from Ukraine, Russia, and around the world, and hears from those caught up in the battle for the truth.

    Producer: Marco Silva

    Editor: Ed Main

    20 min

About Top Comment

From the publisher's feed

The story behind your social media feed, from BBC correspondent Marianna Spring and investigative journalist Matt Shea.

Top Comment investigates what's blowing up online. From global events…

More shows like Top Comment

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,574 Listeners

Business Daily by BBC World Service

Business Daily

524 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,041 Listeners

World Business Report by BBC World Service

World Business Report

285 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,499 Listeners

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4 by BBC Radio 4

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4

2,092 Listeners

File on 4 Investigates by BBC Radio 4

File on 4 Investigates

43 Listeners

The Life Scientific by BBC Radio 4

The Life Scientific

237 Listeners

Evil Genius with Russell Kane by BBC Radio 4

Evil Genius with Russell Kane

345 Listeners

Have You Heard George's Podcast? by BBC Sounds

Have You Heard George's Podcast?

233 Listeners

Elis James and John Robins by Significant Productions

Elis James and John Robins

311 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,212 Listeners

The Slow Newscast by The Observer

The Slow Newscast

162 Listeners

Americast by BBC News

Americast

720 Listeners

British Scandal by Audible

British Scandal

2,495 Listeners

Sport's Strangest Crimes by BBC Radio 5 Live

Sport's Strangest Crimes

77 Listeners

Spiral | Tortoise Investigates by The Observer

Spiral | Tortoise Investigates

3,449 Listeners

Uncanny by BBC Radio 4

Uncanny

795 Listeners

The Coming Storm by BBC Radio 4

The Coming Storm

517 Listeners

Dua Lipa: At Your Service by BBC Sounds

Dua Lipa: At Your Service

1,002 Listeners

Lady Killers with Lucy Worsley by BBC Radio 4

Lady Killers with Lucy Worsley

525 Listeners

Unmissables: Explosive Lies by Global

Unmissables: Explosive Lies

618 Listeners

Believe in Magic by BBC Studios

Believe in Magic

628 Listeners

The Global Story by BBC World Service

The Global Story

382 Listeners

The Louis Theroux Podcast by Spotify Studios

The Louis Theroux Podcast

457 Listeners

Black Box: The Chatbots by The Guardian

Black Box: The Chatbots

479 Listeners

Miss Me? by Persephonica

Miss Me?

237 Listeners

Intrigue by BBC Radio 4

Intrigue

176 Listeners

The History Podcast by BBC Radio 4

The History Podcast

59 Listeners

Crime Next Door by BBC Sounds

Crime Next Door

114 Listeners

Shadow World by BBC Radio 4

Shadow World

30 Listeners

Rory Stewart: The Long History of... by BBC Radio 4

Rory Stewart: The Long History of...

73 Listeners

The Crime Agents by Global

The Crime Agents

46 Listeners