On June 29, 1994, Cynthia Epps, 29, was supposed to return home after her night walk. But according to her boyfriend, Carter, Cynthia never came home which was odd for the mother of two. An unexpected 911 call the following day would lead to a shocking discovery. But even with these known details, there are still so many questions. This left Cynthia’s family and neighborhood of East Buffalo, NY, desperate for answers.


For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/cynthia-epps

Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM

Parentology article

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links