Horns of a Dilemma

Tripped Up About Tripwires


Listen Later

American security policy has made use of tripwire forces for many years.  One of the most prominent examples cited is the case of Berlin: As Thomas Schelling famously described the logic, the small garrison of US soldiers stationed there during the Cold War weren’t militarily capable of defeating the far-larger East German or Soviet forces nearby but, the East Germans or Soviets would be deterred from attacking because any attack would result in the deaths of that small US force, drawing America into a conflict. Our guests today, Professor Dan Reiter of Emery University and Professor Paul Poast of the University of Chicago, argue that Schelling was wrong. Their article, “The Truth About Tripwires: Why Small Force Deployments Do Not Deter Aggression,” in Vol 4, Iss 3 of TNSR, argues that deterrence relies almost exclusively on the military value of force deployment, so small token deployments are unlikely to deter a determined attacker.  They illustrate their argument with two cases from the Korean peninsula, and a counterfactual example from World War I.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Horns of a DilemmaBy Texas National Security Review

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

133 ratings


More shows like Horns of a Dilemma

View all
The Truth of the Matter by CSIS | Center for Strategic and International Studies

The Truth of the Matter

256 Listeners

War on the Rocks by Ryan Evans

War on the Rocks

1,077 Listeners

Angry Planet by Matthew Gault and Jason Fields

Angry Planet

799 Listeners

Modern War Institute by Modern War Institute at West Point

Modern War Institute

767 Listeners

Russian Roulette by Center for Strategic and International Studies

Russian Roulette

146 Listeners

ChinaPower by CSIS | Center for Strategic and International Studies

ChinaPower

206 Listeners

The President’s Inbox by Council on Foreign Relations

The President’s Inbox

697 Listeners

Defense One Radio by Defense One staff

Defense One Radio

139 Listeners

The Proceedings Podcast by U.S. Naval Institute

The Proceedings Podcast

211 Listeners

Net Assessment by War on the Rocks

Net Assessment

402 Listeners

The Asia Chessboard by Center for Strategic and International Studies

The Asia Chessboard

104 Listeners

Urban Warfare Project by John Spencer

Urban Warfare Project

210 Listeners

Irregular Warfare Podcast by Irregular Warfare Initiative

Irregular Warfare Podcast

394 Listeners

School of War by Nebulous Media

School of War

411 Listeners

NatSec Matters by Beacon Global Strategies LLC

NatSec Matters

256 Listeners