True Crime Recaps

By Amy Townsend, Chris NathanTrue Crime

Favorites
69
Followers
Typical duration
17 min
per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

True Crime Recaps episodes

July 16 20 Years After Her Fall They Arrested Her Husband Mid Yoga Class
For nearly twenty years, David Vander Meer insisted his wife Bernadette's death was nothing more than a tragic accident. During what was supposed to be a romantic tenth anniversary trip to Zion National Park, Bernadette plunged from the cliffs of Angels Landing while the two were hiking before sunrise. With little evidence to contradict his account, investigators closed the case, and David collected hundreds of thousands of dollars in life insurance proceeds.
Everything changed when former members of David's youth ministry began speaking to investigators years later. Their allegations painted a disturbing picture of grooming, secret relationships with teenage girls, hidden cell phones, suspicious financial activity, and a marriage that was already falling apart before the fatal hike. As detectives reopened the investigation, witnesses described statements and events that prosecutors believed pointed to a carefully concealed homicide rather than a tragic fall.
In June 2026, U.S. Marshals arrested David during a yoga class in Las Vegas, charging him with first-degree murder and insurance fraud connected to Bernadette's death. Before he could be extradited to Utah to stand trial, he died by suicide in his jail cell just three days after his arrest, ending the criminal case and leaving Bernadette's family without the courtroom answers they had waited nearly two decades to hear.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
19 min
July 14 The Chilling Six-Minute Phone Call That Convicted Former NFL Scout Blaise Taylor
Former NFL scout Blaise Taylor was living what looked like a dream career until prosecutors accused him of turning a glass of pink lemonade into a murder weapon. They alleged he secretly mixed a lethal dose of cocaine into a drink and served it to his pregnant girlfriend, Jade Benning, who was five months pregnant with their daughter, Ivy. As the poison took effect, Jade managed to call her best friend and left the line open, capturing a horrifying confrontation that would later become one of the most powerful pieces of evidence presented to a jury.
Investigators uncovered a troubling history showing Taylor had repeatedly expressed that he did not want to become a father. Witnesses testified he had pressured Jade to have an abortion and even asked a former girlfriend years earlier to secretly slip abortion pills into another pregnant woman's drink. Combined with forensic evidence, toxicology results revealing extraordinarily high cocaine levels, and testimony from medical experts, prosecutors argued the poisoning was carefully planned rather than an accident or overdose.
After listening to just over a week of testimony, the jury deliberated for less than two hours before finding Blaise Taylor guilty of the murders of Jade Benning and their unborn daughter, Ivy. The verdict brought an end to a years-long investigation built on forensic science, witness testimony, and Jade's final recorded words. Taylor was sentenced to life in prison and, under Tennessee law, will not be eligible for parole for more than five decades while his attorneys pursue an appeal.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #BlaiseTaylor #JadeBenning #BabyIvy #TennesseeTitans

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
17 min
July 11 The Grace Ryan Investigation and the Charges Against Her Mother
In March 2026, 16 year old Grace Ryan was found unresponsive inside her Colorado home after months of declining health. Investigators later alleged that her struggle with alcohol had continued for months and that those closest to her were aware of just how serious her condition had become.
As detectives examined text messages, medical records, and evidence collected from the home, prosecutors alleged that Grace’s mother, Gretchen Ryan, had regularly provided alcohol to her daughter despite repeated signs that she needed urgent medical care. Court documents also described conversations in which both mother and daughter acknowledged the severity of Grace’s condition.
The investigation ultimately led to a second degree murder charge against Gretchen Ryan. Prosecutors allege the evidence demonstrates an ongoing pattern of conduct that contributed to Grace’s death. As of this recording, the case remains active, and Gretchen Ryan has not been convicted of the charges against her.
The Grace Ryan case has sparked difficult conversations about parental responsibility, addiction, and when criminal liability may extend beyond a single decision.
Follow True Crime Recaps for weekly cases examining real investigations and the justice system.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
13 min
July 09 The Mercedes Vega Case
Twenty-two-year-old Mercedes Marianna Vega left her Tempe, Arizona apartment for work on the evening of April 16, 2023. Surveillance cameras captured her walking through her apartment parking garage just moments before she disappeared. Hours later, firefighters responding to a burning car along Interstate 10 made a horrifying discovery. According to investigators, Mercedes had been abducted, tortured, and her death became one of Arizona's most disturbing recent homicide investigations.
As detectives retraced Mercedes' final hours, they uncovered a connection to an armed robbery three years earlier. Mercedes had identified a suspect and was scheduled to testify in court the very next day. Prosecutors now allege her killing was part of a plan to prevent that testimony, leading investigators through fingerprints, surveillance footage, phone records, and evidence spanning multiple states.
The robbery case has since resulted in convictions, while the separate murder case remains ongoing. Prosecutors have charged multiple defendants, all of whom have pleaded not guilty, and the allegations have not yet been tested at trial. As the case continues to develop, investigators and Mercedes' family are still seeking justice for the 22-year-old whose life was cut tragically short.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
24 min
July 07 The Sondresha Koins Case
In March 2003, 23-year-old Sondresha Koins, a new mother on maternity leave, was found murdered inside her home in Germantown, Tennessee. She had given birth just two weeks earlier and was adjusting to life with her newborn daughter. When a co-worker went to check on her after several days of no contact, police discovered Sondresha’s body in the living room while her baby was found alive and crying nearby.
There were no signs of forced entry, no clear evidence of theft, and no obvious motive. Investigators initially considered whether the attack could be linked to a string of nearby home invasions, but they later ruled that theory out. From early on, detectives believed Sondresha may have known her killer, possibly letting them inside voluntarily. Despite interviewing over 100 people and working alongside state investigators, the case quickly went cold.
Years later, authorities would arrest a suspect tied to unrelated home invasions in the area, but no charges were ever filed in Sondresha’s case. More than 20 years later, her murder remains the only unsolved homicide in Germantown’s history, leaving investigators and her family still searching for answers.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
11 min
July 04 The Most Disturbing Unsolved Mystery at Sea
In 1900, a relief ship arrives at the remote Eilean Mòr lighthouse expecting to find three keepers waiting. Instead, the station is silent, the light is out, and there’s no sign of the men anywhere.
As the investigation unfolds, disturbing details emerge: damaged railings, missing equipment, and conflicting clues suggesting something sudden and violent may have happened on the island. But no bodies are ever found, and the official records don’t fully explain what occurred. It's almost like James Ducat, Thomas Marshall, and Donald McArthur had vanished into thin air.
For over a century, the world has wondered: Was it a freak "rogue wave" that swept them all away? Did one man snap and take the others with him? Or is there something even darker about the island the locals refused to share?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
20 min
July 02 Woman Tossed 130 Feet Off Bridge After Rope Was Never Attached
A 21-year-old university student traveled to a bridge-jumping event in Brazil looking for an adrenaline rush. Maria Eduarda Rodrigues was fitted with a harness, guided through the safety process, and carried to the edge of a bridge by trained staff. Everything appeared normal—until the moment she was launched. Witnesses suddenly realized the rope meant to stop her fall had never been attached.
Maria fell approximately 130 feet before emergency responders arrived. Despite efforts to save her, she died from catastrophic injuries. Investigators soon discovered an even more troubling mystery: multiple crew members allegedly could not explain who was responsible for attaching the rope or performing the final safety check. Reports claim several workers fled into nearby woods immediately after the incident before later being located by police.
As authorities continued investigating, another crucial piece of evidence reportedly disappeared. Maria had paid extra to wear a GoPro during the jump, but the camera was missing after the accident. Police are now working to determine exactly how such a basic safety failure occurred, who was responsible, and what happened to the missing footage that could potentially reveal the truth.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
10 min
June 30 She Was Jealous of Her 4-Year-Old Daughter
In July 2022, four-year-old Haley Weikle was supposed to be going to bed like any other child. Instead, prosecutors say her own mother, Rebakah Weikle, followed her into her bedroom and carried out a brutal, premeditated murder. Investigators later uncovered evidence that Rebakah had been researching ways to kill her daughter and had developed a deep resentment toward the little girl for a reason that shocked even seasoned detectives.
After Haley's death, Rebakah allegedly cleaned up the crime scene, hid evidence, and attempted to continue life as if nothing had happened. When authorities began investigating, she pointed the finger at her husband, Rusty Weikle, falsely accusing him of murdering their daughter. For years, conflicting stories and a lack of witnesses complicated the case until digital evidence from her phone revealed what prosecutors described as a calculated plan.
In 2026, Rebakah pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and child abuse resulting in death, receiving two life sentences. But the case didn't end there. As investigators examined conditions inside the family home, additional questions emerged about the warning signs that had been missed before tragedy struck. This is the heartbreaking case of Haley Weikle, a little girl whose life was stolen by the person who should have protected her most.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #HaleyWeikle #RebakahWeikle #RustyWeikle #FamilyTragedy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
10 min
June 27 She Texted Her Boyfriend At 4AM. That Was The Last Anyone Heard From Her
In January 2008, 19-year-old Brianna Denison was staying with friends in Reno, Nevada during winter break. After a night out at a concert and local hangout spots, she returned to a house near the University of Nevada and fell asleep on the couch while her friends went to bed. She was last seen around 4:23 a.m., texting her boyfriend, with no indication anything was wrong.
By morning, Brianna was gone. Her belongings were still inside the house, but signs quickly pointed to something violent: blood was found on the pillow she had been using, along with evidence suggesting she had been attacked while asleep. Investigators soon realized her disappearance was linked to a series of earlier assaults near the university involving a man who targeted women and took personal items from them.
DNA evidence became the key breakthrough, linking the same unknown male profile from Brianna’s case to multiple prior attacks. Months later, a tip led investigators to James Biela, whose DNA ultimately matched evidence from the crime scene. He was convicted of rape and murder and sentenced to death, and Brianna’s case later led to “Brianna’s Law,” changing how DNA is collected in Nevada.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #BriannaDenison #BriannasLaw #JamesBiela #DNAEvidence #CaitlinDenison

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
19 min
June 25 The Taylor Parker Case: Fake Pregnancies, Murder & a Stolen Baby
Taylor Parker spent years constructing a web of lies, convincing friends, family, and even those closest to her that she was living a life that never existed. What began as deception eventually spiraled into one of the most shocking true crime cases in recent Texas history.
In this episode, we examine the murder of Reagan Hancock, who was preparing to welcome her daughter, Braxlynn Sage Hancock, when prosecutors say Parker's elaborate fake pregnancy was on the verge of being exposed. Instead of admitting the truth, investigators believe Parker carried out a horrifying plan that ended in unimaginable violence.
We'll break down the timeline, the investigation, the evidence presented at trial, and how years of manipulation ultimately unraveled. This is the full story behind one of America's most disturbing capital murder cases.
If you enjoy in-depth true crime storytelling, be sure to follow True Crime Recaps for new episodes every week.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
41 min

About True Crime Recaps

From the publisher's feed

Hosts and storytellers Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend piece together the most gripping true crime cases the world can't stop talking about. From infamous serial killers to today's headline-making…