True Crime Recaps

By Amy Townsend, Chris NathanTrue Crime

Favorites
69
Followers
Typical duration
17 min
per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

True Crime Recaps episodes

June 23 He Randomly Chose a House, Killed a Mother and Lived a Normal Life for Nearly 30 Years
In November 1994, 37-year-old Robin Lawrence was found brutally murdered inside her Virginia home after being stabbed 49 times. Her two-year-old daughter was discovered alive but alone in the house, having spent nearly two days wandering the crime scene. Investigators believe the toddler tried to help her mother, leaving behind a heartbreaking scene that would stay with detectives for decades.
With no witnesses and no clear motive, the case quickly went cold. The only real clue was a small amount of DNA left behind on a hand towel, evidence that couldn’t be matched to anyone at the time. For nearly 30 years, Robin’s killer remained unidentified. Then, advances in genetic genealogy gave investigators a second chance. By building a family tree from distant DNA matches, a volunteer genealogist helped narrow the search down to one man: Stephan Smerk.
In 2023, detectives approached Smerk, a seemingly ordinary suburban father with no criminal record. After providing a DNA sample, he confessed to the murder. According to investigators, the attack was completely random, he didn’t know Robin and had no connection to her. He admitted he entered the home intending to kill someone, then carried out the attack before returning to his normal life. Nearly three decades later, the DNA Robin left behind led to justice in a case that once seemed impossible to solve.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
17 min
June 20 Investigators Tested the DNA in Her Cabin Against Two Different People
18-year-old Anna Kepner was on a family cruise in the Caribbean aboard the Carnival Horizon in November 2025 when she was later found dead under circumstances that triggered a federal investigation. Prosecutors allege the person responsible is her 16-year-old stepbrother, Timothy Hudson, who has pleaded not guilty. The case remains pre-trial, and all claims are allegations that have not been proven in court.
According to newly unsealed court records, Anna was sharing Cabin 8343 with her stepbrother and younger half-brother during the trip. Prosecutors say surveillance footage shows Anna entering the cabin and never being seen alive again, while a detailed timeline tracks activity in and around the room over several hours. Investigators also point to Snapchat activity, ship security footage, WiFi and device tracking data, and a damaged cell phone later recovered from a trash can on the ship as key pieces of evidence in the case.
Prosecutors allege Anna died from mechanical asphyxiation inside the cabin and was later found hidden under a bed. They also say DNA evidence plays a central role in their case, while the defense disputes those conclusions and argues the evidence does not definitively prove responsibility. Timothy Hudson has been released under strict electronic monitoring while awaiting trial, which is currently scheduled for September 2026.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 min
June 18 Jurors Took Less Than 3 Hours to Reach a Verdict
On April 2, 2025, what should have been an ordinary high school track meet in Frisco, Texas, turned into a tragedy. Seventeen-year-old Austin Metcalf was fatally stabbed during a brief confrontation under a team tent. Within moments, Austin was fighting for his life, and another teenager, Karmelo Anthony, was in police custody admitting he had used the knife.
At trial, there was little dispute about who delivered the fatal stab wound. The central question was whether Karmelo acted in lawful self-defense or whether he provoked the confrontation and escalated it into deadly violence. Jurors heard witness testimony, reviewed surveillance footage, examined statements made immediately after the stabbing, and listened to competing interpretations of what happened during those critical seconds.
After less than three hours of deliberation, the jury rejected the self-defense claim and found Karmelo Anthony guilty of murder. They later declined to find that he acted under ""sudden passion"" and sentenced him to 35 years in prison. In this video, we break down the evidence, the legal arguments, and the key moments that led jurors to their decision in one of the most closely watched criminal cases in Texas.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 min
June 16 They Found Her Wrecked Jeep With $2,500 Cash and No Sign of He
In March 2000, 23-year-old Leah Roberts packed her white Jeep Cherokee, withdrew thousands of dollars, and left North Carolina on a cross-country road trip inspired by Jack Kerouac. Five days after she was last seen in Bellingham, Washington, a couple jogging along a remote logging road near Mount Baker found her Jeep wrecked at the bottom of an embankment. Leah wasn't inside.
There was no blood and no sign of injury. Her belongings were still in the car, including $2,500 in cash and a family heirloom. Blankets had been stuffed into the broken windows, as if someone had used the Jeep for shelter after the crash. Years later, a forensic examination revealed the starter motor had been tampered with, raising the possibility the crash was staged. Witnesses recalled seeing Leah at a Bellingham restaurant shortly before she vanished, possibly speaking with a man whose identity has never been confirmed.
More than two decades later, no arrests have been made and Leah has never been found. Was it foul play in the Washington wilderness, or did Leah walk away from her old life? What really happened to Leah Roberts remains unanswered.
Do you have a theory? Let us know in the comments.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #LeahRoberts #MissingPerson #UnsolvedMystery #ColdCase #MountBaker #Bellingham #RoadTripMystery #Disappearance

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
22 min
June 13 A Mother Tried to Blame Her Daughter - The Stacey Castor Case
When Michael Wallace died unexpectedly at just 38 years old, his death was initially believed to be the result of natural causes. No autopsy was performed, and the case appeared closed. Years later, after Stacey Castor remarried, another sudden death within the family would draw the attention of investigators and raise new questions about the past.
As detectives examined the circumstances surrounding the death of Stacey’s second husband, David Castor, they uncovered evidence that suggested the two cases may have been connected. The investigation led authorities to revisit Michael Wallace’s death, revealing similarities that could no longer be ignored.
With investigators closing in, attention shifted to a shocking allegation involving Stacey’s own daughter, Ashley. Authorities believed an attempt had been made to place responsibility for the deaths on Ashley through a carefully constructed plan. When Ashley survived and investigators examined the evidence, the case took another dramatic turn.
Known to many as the "Black Widow" case, the story of Stacey Castor became one of the most unusual criminal investigations in New York history. It remains a case defined by deception, family betrayal, and an effort to avoid accountability at any cost.
Follow True Crime Recaps for weekly cases examining real investigations and the justice system.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
19 min
June 11 She Hid a Secret in Her Attic for Years - The Dolly Oesterreich Case
In 1922, Fred Oesterreich was found dead inside his Los Angeles home. His wife, Dolly Oesterreich, told police that an intruder had entered the house, taken Fred’s life, and locked her in a closet before fleeing. At first, the story seemed plausible. Investigators soon discovered there was far more to the case than anyone imagined.
As authorities dug deeper, they uncovered a secret that had allegedly remained hidden for years. Dolly had been involved in a long term relationship with Otto Sanhuber, a man who had secretly lived inside the attic of the family home. According to investigators, Otto remained concealed above the household for years, moving with the family and rarely being seen by anyone else.
The investigation revealed a complicated web of relationships, conflicting statements, and questions surrounding Fred’s death. As the case moved through the courts, prosecutors faced the unusual challenge of proving what had happened inside a home that concealed one of the most extraordinary secrets in criminal history.
The Oesterreich case remains one of the strangest and most talked about cases of the twentieth century, blending deception, hidden identities, and a mystery that continues to fascinate true crime audiences today.
Follow True Crime Recaps for weekly cases examining real investigations and the justice system.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
18 min
June 09 An Adoption Reunion That Ended in Tragedy
In 2016, Katie Pladl reconnected with her biological parents after being adopted as a baby. What began as an emotional reunion soon evolved into a highly unusual and deeply controversial family situation that drew concern from those around them.
As relationships within the family became increasingly complicated, authorities became involved. A criminal investigation, legal proceedings, and court ordered restrictions followed, while tensions continued to grow between multiple family members.
Despite efforts to intervene, the situation ultimately ended in tragedy. Several lives were lost across two states, leaving investigators to reconstruct a complex timeline of events and examine the decisions that led to the devastating outcome.
The Pladl case remains one of the most disturbing family cases in recent memory, raising difficult questions about boundaries, accountability, and the consequences of unchecked relationships.
Follow True Crime Recaps for weekly cases examining real investigations and the justice system.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
13 min
June 06 Oregon’s Most Haunting Missing Family Mystery Was Finally Solved
In December 1958, the Martin family left their home in Portland, Oregon to pick up Christmas decorations in the mountains. Ken and Barbara Martin packed their three daughters into the station wagon for what should have been a simple holiday outing.
They never came home.
For decades, the disappearance haunted Oregon. Investigators found strange tire tracks near the Columbia River, witnesses reported seeing unknown men around the family’s car, and theories ranging from kidnapping to murder spread across the country. But despite massive searches, the Martin family’s station wagon was never found.
Then, 66 years later, a diver searching the Columbia River made a discovery buried deep beneath the sediment. Hidden inside was the answer to one of America’s oldest missing family mysteries.
This is the chilling true story of the Martin family disappearance and the decades-long search that finally uncovered what happened that night.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
16 min
June 04 Japan’s Most Disturbing Child Killer
In 1997, the city of Kobe, Japan was shaken by one of the most horrifying crimes in modern history. A school caretaker arrived at a junior high school early in the morning and discovered the severed head of an 11-year-old boy placed at the front gate. Inside the child’s mouth was a handwritten letter taunting police and daring them to stop the killer. What investigators uncovered next shocked the entire country.
The murderer turned out to be just fourteen years old. Known publicly only as “Boy A,” Shinichiro Azuma had already attacked multiple children before killing Jun Hase. As police pieced together the disturbing letters, violent assaults, and escalating behavior, they uncovered a teenager obsessed with death, violence, and control. His crimes would spark nationwide fear and forever change Japan’s juvenile justice laws.
Years later, after his release from detention, the killer resurfaced again with a controversial memoir describing his crimes and thoughts in chilling detail. This is the terrifying true story of the Kobe child murders and the boy who became one of Japan’s most infamous killers.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
20 min
June 02 The Perfect Husband Hid a Dark Secret
A quiet retired couple living on a rural farm near Erie, Illinois becomes the target of a carefully orchestrated home invasion that quickly escalates into something far more disturbing than a typical robbery. A masked intruder breaks into their home, restrains them, and forces them into a vehicle before transporting them to a second property. There, they discover a hidden trapdoor leading into a fortified underground bunker stocked with supplies, surveillance equipment, and restraints, clearly built to hold people for an extended period of time.
As the investigation unfolds, authorities uncover that the attacker is Chad Schipper, a man deeply embedded in the victims’ own community. A former church elder and financial advisor, he had once shared social circles with the couple and even built trust within their church community. Behind this respectable image, however, he was struggling with severe financial instability and mounting debt, including money owed to family members and clients he had misled.
The kidnapping plan begins to unravel after one critical mistake: the use of a cashier’s check tied directly to his own business. This leads investigators to quickly identify him, track his movements, and ultimately locate the bunker where the couple is being held. After a police pursuit, crash, and confession, Chad Schipper is arrested and later sentenced to 60 years in prison. Despite the brutality and planning behind the crime, the victims survive and later dedicate themselves to advocacy, sharing their story of survival, faith, and recovery in a published memoir and public speaking efforts.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #Kidnapping #ChadSchipper #HiddenBasement #LarryVanOosten #ConnieVanOosten

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
20 min

About True Crime Recaps

From the publisher's feed

Hosts and storytellers Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend piece together the most gripping true crime cases the world can't stop talking about. From infamous serial killers to today's headline-making…