True Crime Recaps

By Amy Townsend, Chris NathanTrue Crime

Favorites
69
Followers
Typical duration
17 min
per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

True Crime Recaps episodes

May 30 Kouri Richins Sentenced to Life Without Parole in the Black Widow Trial That Shocked America
The case of Kouri Richins has become one of the most disturbing and complex true crime stories to emerge in recent years. What began as the sudden death of Utah businessman Eric Richins quickly spiraled into a multi-layered investigation involving alleged poisoning attempts, financial pressure, and life insurance policies tied directly to the accused.
Prosecutors alleged that Kouri Richins poisoned her husband with fentanyl, pointing to prior suspicious incidents, financial motives, and communications suggesting a planned future without him. The defense, however, argued there was no definitive proof she administered the fatal dose and suggested alternative explanations, including questions about how the drug entered his system.
After a high-profile trial filled with testimony, digital evidence, and emotional family statements, Kouri Richins was convicted of aggravated murder and related charges in 2026 and sentenced to life without parole. The case continues to spark debate due to its mix of alleged financial motive, relationship history, and the shocking post-death revelations that followed.
#TrueCrimeRecaps #KouriRichins #EricRichins #BlackWidow

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
18 min
May 28 Alex Murdaugh’s Murder Conviction Has Been Overturned
For years, the murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh seemed like a closed case. Alex Murdaugh, once part of one of South Carolina’s most powerful legal families, was convicted of killing his wife and son after jurors heard evidence prosecutors said they could not ignore, including the now infamous kennel video placing him near the crime scene minutes before the murders.
But now, everything has changed. Alex Murdaugh’s murder conviction has officially been overturned after shocking allegations involving jury influence by former court clerk Becky Hill. The South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that comments allegedly made to jurors during the trial may have compromised the fairness of the proceedings, throwing one of the most high-profile murder convictions in recent history into chaos.
In today’s recap, we break down the original murders, the financial crimes, the kennel video that changed everything, the misconduct allegations that overturned the conviction, and whether Alex Murdaugh could actually win a retrial. Because despite years of headlines, documentaries, and courtroom drama… the Murdaugh story may be far from over.
#TrueCrimeRecaps AlexMurdaugh #MurdaughMurders #MurdaughTrial

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
13 min
May 26 Mackenzie Shirilla Case Explained: The Crash That Divided Public Opinion on Intent vs Accident
On July 31, 2022, a horrific crash in Strongsville, Ohio left two young men dead and a teenage driver as the sole survivor. What initially appeared to be a tragic high-speed accident soon became one of the most controversial true crime cases in recent years: the case of Mackenzie Shirilla.
Prosecutors argued that Shirilla deliberately drove her car off the main road and into a dead-end business park, accelerating to nearly 100 mph before slamming into a brick building. Key evidence presented at trial included cellphone location data, surveillance footage, and black box recordings that allegedly showed full throttle acceleration with no brake use. The defense, however, argued that a medical episode or blackout could explain the crash, pointing to her reported health condition and memory loss after the incident.
Ultimately, the judge ruled the crash was intentional and sentenced Mackenzie Shirilla to life in prison with parole eligibility after 15 years. Years later the case continues to spark debate, especially following Netflix’s "The Crash" documentary, which brought renewed attention to the evidence, the victims, and the unanswered questions surrounding what truly happened that night.
#TrueCrimeRecap #DominicRusso #DavionFlanagan #MackenzieShirilla #NetflixTheCrash #TheCrash

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
21 min
May 23 The Disappearance and Killing of Judy Smith: A Mystery 600 Miles in the Making
In April 1997, Judy Smith, a 23-year-old nurse from Newton, Massachusetts, vanished while on a sightseeing trip in Philadelphia with her husband. Initially, she was seen at the hotel, but when her husband returned from the conference, she was gone. Days of searching turned up no trace, and several confusing sightings suggested she may have traveled alone.
Five months later, Judy’s remains were discovered in a shallow grave in Pisgah National Forest, near Asheville, North Carolina, over 600 miles from Philadelphia. She had been stabbed, and the clothing on her body indicated hiking gear, none of it hers. Her red backpack, a signature item she always carried, was missing. Investigators have never solved how she got there or who killed her. The case remains a haunting mystery.
If you have any information that could help bring Judy’s family answers, contact Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS. Until then, the question remains: what happened to Judy Smith?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
20 min
May 21 The Forgotten Victim Behind Netflix's "Should I Marry A Murderer?"
When 63-year-old charity cyclist Tony Parsons vanished during a bike ride through the Scottish Highlands, his family feared the worst. For years, police searched the remote mountains and forests around Bridge of Orchy but found absolutely nothing. No bike. No body. No answers.
Then, in a twist stranger than fiction, the case suddenly exploded open because of a confession. A man named Sandy McKellar allegedly admitted to his fiancée that he and his twin brother had hit Tony with their truck back in 2017… and instead of calling for help, they hid his body deep in the wilderness.
In this video, we break down the full horrifying story behind Tony Parsons’ disappearance, the massive police search, the shocking role Sandy’s fiancée Caroline played in solving the case, and the heartbreaking truth investigators uncovered years later. We are going to be diving deep into this case in our Members video so keep your eyes peeled for that one as well!
#TrueCrimeRecaps #TonyParsons #ShouldIMarryAMurderer #CarolineMuirhead #SandyMcKellar

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 min
May 19 A Pizza Delivery Gone Wrong on a Quiet Island: The Tessa Van Hart Case
On a quiet winter night in 1994, 23-year-old Tessa Van Hart leaves her job at a small pizza shop on Chincoteague Island, Virginia, to complete what seems like a routine delivery. The address leads her to an empty summer home in a secluded area, and after she leaves, she never returns. Hours later, her car is discovered parked behind a vacant house, and Tessa is found inside the back seat, shot twice in the head, with the undelivered pizza still sitting in the front.The small island community is left in shock. With no clear suspects and limited forensic technology at the time, the investigation stalls for years. Then, more than two years later, a local man named Brian Cherrix comes forward while in custody on unrelated charges. He initially offers secondhand information about the crime, but eventually gives a detailed confession describing how he lured Tessa, assaulted her, and ultimately killed her before later retracting his statement and claiming coercion.Despite inconsistencies, investigators recover a rifle linked to the murder, and other evidence helps secure a conviction. Brian Cherrix is sentenced to death, later executed in 2004 after years of appeals. Tessa’s murder remains one of the most disturbing cases in the island’s history, forever changing the belief that nothing violent could ever happen in such a quiet, close-knit place.#TrueCrimeRecaps #TessaVanHart #ChincoteagueIsland #BrianCherrix #DeathPenalty

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 min
May 16 The Deadpool Killer: Wade Wilson’s Shocking Crime Spree
Wade Wilson was convicted of first degree murder. 13 days later, the death penalty was recommended. Wade doesn’t bat an eye. But he makes a bizarre hand signal that's got everyone talking!What do you think that was all about? And do you think the jury made the right decision?#TrueCrimeRecaps #WadeWilson #DeadpoolKiller #SerialKiller #Murders

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 min
May 14 Jeffrey Epstein’s Secret Jail Note Just Got Unsealed and It Changes Everything
Before Jeffrey Epstein was found dead in his jail cell in August 2019, there was another disturbing incident just weeks earlier that raised serious questions inside the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York.After guards found Epstein injured on the floor of his cell on July 23rd, conflicting stories immediately emerged. Epstein reportedly claimed his cellmate, former police officer and convicted murderer Nicholas Tartaglione, may have attacked him. Tartaglione denied it completely, saying he woke up to find Epstein unconscious and called for help himself. Investigators later concluded there was no evidence linking Tartaglione to the incident and officially classified it as an attempted suicide.Now, years later, a newly unsealed handwritten note allegedly written by Epstein has resurfaced, adding another bizarre layer to one of the most controversial jail deaths in modern history. From missed guard checks and policy failures to disputed medical findings and conflicting witness accounts, this case continues to fuel debate and speculation nearly seven years later.#TrueCrimeRecaps #JeffreyEpstein #NicholasTartaglione #Epstein

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
21 min
May 12 Michael Marin Swallowed Cyanide in Court After He Got a Guilty Verdict
Michael Marin lived a life most people could only imagine. A Yale-educated lawyer, investment banker, pilot, and Everest climber, he built a reputation for going all-in on everything he did. But in 2009, after his luxury Phoenix mansion went up in flames under suspicious circumstances, that larger-than-life image began to crack. Investigators quickly uncovered signs of arson: multiple ignition points, accelerants, and a financial motive that painted a very different picture.As Marin fought the charges, his life unraveled. His fortune disappeared, his legal defense weakened, and the man who once thrived on control found himself facing the possibility of decades in prison. At trial, prosecutors argued the fire wasn’t an accident... it was a calculated attempt to escape financial ruin. Marin maintained his innocence, but the evidence told a different story.Then, in May 2012, everything came to a shocking end. Just moments after the jury returned a guilty verdict, Marin collapsed in the courtroom after secretly swallowing cyanide. He died shortly after, leaving behind a delayed email to his son that confirmed what many feared: this was planned. What began as a suspicious fire turned into one of the most disturbing courtroom deaths ever caught on camera.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
11 min
May 09 Prosecutors Release Evidence Brief Detailing What They Believe Happened to Celeste Rivas Hernandez
A newly released nine-page preliminary brief has laid out a chilling roadmap of the evidence prosecutors intend to use against musician David Anthony Burke, known as d4vd. The filing alleges a dark, years-long history of grooming that began when Celeste was just 11, eventually turning into a sexual relationship. According to the D.A.’s office, the motive was purely professional: Celeste allegedly threatened to expose their relationship, which would have destroyed Burke’s career and multi-million dollar deals just as his debut album was about to drop.The brief details an incredibly calculated and gruesome cover-up that allegedly took place right under the public's nose. Prosecutors claim that after Celeste was killed, Burke used an alias to order a body bag, chainsaws, and an inflatable pool to dismember her in his garage. While Celeste’s remains were allegedly hidden in the trunk of his Tesla, Burke continued his life as a rising star, even embarking on a national tour and performing songs with themes that mirrored the real-life horror investigators would later uncover.This mountain of evidence, which includes DNA found in his garage and plastic fragments from a pool embedded in her remains, led to Burke being charged with murder under special circumstances. While his defense team maintains his innocence, prosecutors are pushing for the highest penalties. That’s the latest in the case and we’ll keep you updated as it unfolds.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
16 min

About True Crime Recaps

From the publisher's feed

Hosts and storytellers Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend piece together the most gripping true crime cases the world can't stop talking about. From infamous serial killers to today's headline-making…