Decouple

Why Nuclear Energy Has Been a Flop feat. Jack Devanney


Listen Later

At its birth, nuclear energy entered a highly competitive market for electricity generation. Oil was so cheap that it was stealing market share for electricity generation from coal and driving prices to all-time lows. Despite being a brand new technology 1960s nuclear plants were hitting prices of 3 cents/kWh in today's dollars. Gaddafi and OPEC then contributed to the price of oil skyrocketing. All of a sudden, many wanted to build a nuclear plant and early adopters were reaping huge profits. Nuclear energy featured prominently in the 1964 US democratic party platform. Democrats in the USA even threatened private utilities that if they would not build more nuclear reactors the government would start public utilities that would. So what happened? The Rockefeller Foundation was plagued by guilt over its role in supporting the science that led to the atomic bomb. In fact Ernest Lawrence the inventor of the cyclotron wrote to them to tell them that “had it not been for the Rockefeller Foundation there would be no bomb.” In an attempt to atone for its pivotal role the Foundation became invested in promoting the linear no-threshold (LNT) model for radiation-induced harms as a tool to fight atmospheric weapons testing and try to force the atomic weapons genie back into the bottle. LNT was accepted by the nuclear establishment in part because of hubris. The thinking was that it didn't really matter what radiation model was in place and how conservative it was since a core meltdown and radioactive release were thought to be impossible. LNT laid the groundwork for a regulatory paradigm that has plagued the nuclear industry since, “ As low as reasonably achievable. (ALARA) What “reasonably achievable” meant was really “what can you afford?” Because early on nuclear was very profitable in the context of the oil crisis and escalating fossil fuel costs there was a lot of room to maneuver in terms of adding on more and more costly features to reduce radioactive emissions that had no impact on health. The regulatory ratchet only tightens one way, so when the coal industry got its costs under control the inflated costs imposed by ALARA on nuclear prevented it from becoming cost-competitive again. ALARA means that nuclear can never be cheaper than its rivals because it is only reasonable that it spends any difference on measures to reduce any radioactive emissions to near zero. As Jack Devanney the principal engineer and architect of THORCON and author of “Why nuclear energy has been a flop” explains, the boom of nuclear power in the USA in particular was short-lived. No new nuclear plant was ordered in the 20th century after 1974, 5 years before the Three Mile Island accident. Interestingly the safety performance of the pre-ALARA early fleet has been exemplary and TMI was the most recent design. Jack Devanney argues that accidents will happen but emphasizes that their health consequences will be very minor as dose rates that the public experiences that are even 10-20x average background rates are not a health hazard in any meaningful sense.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

DecoupleBy Dr. Chris Keefer

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

140 ratings


More shows like Decouple

View all
Macro Voices by Hedge Fund Manager Erik Townsend

Macro Voices

3,076 Listeners

Odd Lots by Bloomberg

Odd Lots

1,890 Listeners

EconTalk by Russ Roberts

EconTalk

4,275 Listeners

Conversations with Tyler by Mercatus Center at George Mason University

Conversations with Tyler

2,438 Listeners

Columbia Energy Exchange by Columbia University

Columbia Energy Exchange

398 Listeners

Hidden Forces by Demetri Kofinas

Hidden Forces

1,436 Listeners

GoodFellows: Conversations from the Hoover Institution by Hoover Institution

GoodFellows: Conversations from the Hoover Institution

689 Listeners

The Grant Williams Podcast by Grant Williams

The Grant Williams Podcast

1,351 Listeners

The HC Commodities Podcast by Paul Chapman, HC Group

The HC Commodities Podcast

154 Listeners

Dwarkesh Podcast by Dwarkesh Patel

Dwarkesh Podcast

70 Listeners

Cleaning Up: Leadership in an Age of Climate Change by Michael Liebreich, Bryony Worthington

Cleaning Up: Leadership in an Age of Climate Change

79 Listeners

Volts by David Roberts

Volts

618 Listeners

The Great Simplification with Nate Hagens by Nate Hagens

The Great Simplification with Nate Hagens

411 Listeners

Catalyst with Shayle Kann by Latitude Media

Catalyst with Shayle Kann

270 Listeners

Shift Key with Robinson Meyer and Jesse Jenkins by Heatmap News

Shift Key with Robinson Meyer and Jesse Jenkins

112 Listeners