Fear Free Childbirth Podcast with Alexia Leachman

Your due date is wrong


Listen Later

Your due date is wrong!
Yep! Well, it might be. In fact, more than likely.
How do I know this? Because the EDD - Estimated Due Date - is one of the biggest [lies/disasters/ trick /hoaxes etc] to affect pregnant women today. And, even though people who should know better (doctors, midwives etc), know better, this lie still stands. It’s a bit like the whole Santa thing, but far more damaging.
WHAT? What? Tell me!!!
And because of this, you’re setting yourself up for a ton of stress in the last month or so of your pregnancy.
So why is it wrong?
The most commonly used method to calculate due dates is also the most inaccurate. Seriously. Let me explain.
The due date system that is widely used by doctors and midwives is based on Naegele's Rule (Franz Karl Naegele OB, 1778–1851).
Naegele’s Rule
According to Naegele’s Rule, the standard definition for gestational term is 266 days from conception to the date of the baby’s birth. This is also defined as 280 days, or 40 weeks, from the first day of the mother’s last menstrual period, a definition which assumes that the mother ovulates on day 14 of a 28 day menstrual cycle. The actual formula used to calculate estimated due date (EDD) is:
(LMP + 7 days) – 3 months = Due Date
This is the formula that was probably used to give you your due date.
In fact, Naegele’s theory originated from a guy called Harmanni Boerhaave, a botanist who in 1744 came up with a method of calculating the Estimated Due Date (EDD) based upon evidence in the Bible that human gestation lasts approximately 10 lunar months.
I don’t know about you, but for me, there is so much wrong with that last sentence, that when I first read it my jaw bruised my big toe. Considering what’s at stake, this calculation method doesn’t exactly inspire me with confidence… and here’s why:
The Bible?
Like HOW long ago?! You would think that given how many people have been born since then, that we would have built up a pretty good picture of this whole human gestation thing. You know maybe, even taken the time to take a closer look to see if the assumptions we’re using are appropriate…. You’d think?!
“…based on evidence in the Bible…”
Since when is the Bible a reliable source of evidence? Or indeed a reliable authority on the passage of time. The Bible said that the Earth was created in seven days, and yet most of us have accepted that that is highly unlikely, if not downright impossible. But yet here we are using an idea from the Bible to tell women when they can expect to bring their mini human into the world. What makes this unforgivable in my mind is that this rule is NOT based on scientific or empirical evidence or research. Yes, you read that right… it is NOT based on empirical evidence or research. None whatsoever. Not even 100 year old scientific research when hospitals were a lot muckier than they are now. No! We’re talking about times when women gave birth along side cattle and donkeys in barns by candlelight.
Can you tell that this makes me mad? But, it gets worse…
“…that human gestation lasts approximately 10 lunar months”
Lunar cycles?!! Seriously? OK.. Well let’s follow this line of thought and see where it takes us.
A quick check online will tell you that there are five different lunar months ranging in length from 27.3 days to 29.5 days, but the one that is widely used is the synodic month, which wikipedia describes as “how long it takes on average to pass through each phase (new, half, full moon) and back again” and which lasts 29.5 days. So if the Bible assumes that human gestation lasts approximately 10 lunar months then according to my calculations 10 x 29.5 = 295 days.
Now if you recall, Naegele’s Rule says that human gestation is 280 days. So, given that 10 lunar months gives us 295 days… we’re already hitting some problems… Let’s do some more maths..
295 - 280 = 15 days difference
This is 15 days LONGER than the 280 days gestation period that is being used and that we’v...
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Fear Free Childbirth Podcast with Alexia LeachmanBy Alexia Leachman

  • 4.1
  • 4.1
  • 4.1
  • 4.1
  • 4.1

4.1

69 ratings


More shows like Fear Free Childbirth Podcast with Alexia Leachman

View all
The Birth Hour - A Birth Story Podcast by Bryn Huntpalmer

The Birth Hour - A Birth Story Podcast

2,169 Listeners

Informed Pregnancy Podcast by Independent Podcast Network | Informed Pregnancy

Informed Pregnancy Podcast

451 Listeners

Birthful by Adriana Lozada

Birthful

672 Listeners

Australian Birth Stories by Sophie Walker

Australian Birth Stories

180 Listeners

Evidence Based Birth® by Rebecca Dekker, PhD, RN

Evidence Based Birth®

1,011 Listeners

Mommy Labor Nurse by Liesel Teen

Mommy Labor Nurse

1,290 Listeners

Down to Birth by Cynthia Overgard & Trisha Ludwig

Down to Birth

532 Listeners

The Hypnobirthing Podcast by The Nurture Nest

The Hypnobirthing Podcast

179 Listeners

Midwife Pip Podcast by Midwife Pip

Midwife Pip Podcast

3 Listeners

What To Expect by iHeartPodcasts

What To Expect

200 Listeners

Giggly Squad by Hannah Berner & Paige DeSorbo

Giggly Squad

14,961 Listeners

The Midwives' Cauldron by Katie James and Dr Rachel Reed

The Midwives' Cauldron

148 Listeners

Birthing Instincts by Dr. Stuart Fischbein + Midwife Blyss Young

Birthing Instincts

648 Listeners

Learning To Mom ™ Motherhood Podcast for First Time Moms, New Moms and Expecting Mothers by Laila | The best mom podcast for first time moms! If you're looking for a natural pregnancy podcast, postpartum podcast, baby's first year podcast, birth podcast, podcast about birth, podcast about pregnancy, motherhood podcast, new mom podcast, ent

Learning To Mom ™ Motherhood Podcast for First Time Moms, New Moms and Expecting Mothers

190 Listeners

The Great Birth Rebellion by Dr Melanie Jackson

The Great Birth Rebellion

78 Listeners