You Are Not Broken

259. Lancet Menopause Article Rebuttal - the Menoposse


Listen Later

In this episode, my panel of menopause expert physicians and nurse practitioners discuss the recent four-part article series on menopause published in The Lancet (link below).

We address the agenda behind these articles and the implications for menopause care. The panel strongly disagrees with the claim that menopause is being over-medicalized and emphasizes the importance of hormone therapy in managing menopausal symptoms and preventing long-term health issues.

We also criticize the suggestion that cognitive behavioral therapy should be the first-line treatment for menopause symptoms, highlighting the barriers to access and the lack of evidence supporting its effectiveness.

The panel advocates for a comprehensive and individualized approach to menopause care. The conversation methodically identifies the principal themes discussed in the Lancet article on menopause.

We cover topics such as biased review articles, the citation of the author's own studies, the lack of balance in the article, possible reasons for publication, surprising reactions from colleagues, the lack of education and training, the dismissal of women's experiences, ageism in medicine, the importance of treating perimenopause, ignoring the suffering of perimenopause, setting the stage for future health issues, empowerment through hormone therapy, misconceptions about hormone therapy and breast cancer, estrogen's protective effects on breast cancer, lifestyle factors and breast cancer risk, advocating for access to menopause specialists, and the importance of seeing a menopause specialist.

Takeaways

  • The panel strongly disagrees with the claim that menopause is being over-medicalized and emphasizes the importance of hormone therapy in managing menopausal symptoms and preventing long-term health issues.
  • The suggestion that cognitive behavioral therapy should be the first-line treatment for menopause symptoms is criticized due to barriers to access and lack of evidence supporting its effectiveness.
  • The panel highlights the need for a comprehensive and individualized approach to menopause care, taking into account the diverse needs and experiences of menopausal individuals.
  • The Lancet articles were criticized for misrepresenting the benefits of hormone therapy and failing to acknowledge the impact of menopause on mental health and overall well-being. Review articles should present a balanced view by citing studies that prove and disprove a point, rather than cherry-picking data.
  • The Lancet article on menopause fell short of presenting a balanced view and may have been rushed for publication.
  • Many healthcare providers lack education and training on menopause, leading to dismissive attitudes towards women's experiences.
  • Hormone therapy is an important tool for treating perimenopause and menopause symptoms and can have protective effects on breast cancer.
  • Advocacy is needed to improve access to menopause specialists and expand telehealth services.
  • https://www.thelancet.com/series/menopause-2024

    FirmTech sponsors this podcast today. Go to

    ⁠⁠myfirmtech.com and enter code NOTBROKEN for 15% off today.

    Our other amazing podcast sponsors

    To learn more about Solv Wellness and their products for female pelvic health, visit ⁠⁠solvwellness.com⁠⁠ for 30% off your first purchase of any product. Discount automatically applied at checkout.

    Women of all ages deserve to feel fantastic. And we can—because there is relief to be found. Go to ⁠⁠myalloy.com⁠⁠ to start your virtual appointment today. Use code NOTBROKEN20 it's good for $20

    off any purchase, one time use, and expires July 31, 2024


    Listen to my Tedx Talk: ⁠Why we need adult sex ed⁠

    Take my NEW Adult Sex Ed Master Class: https://www.kellycaspersonmd.com/adult-sex-ed

    Join my membership to get these episodes ASAP, a private facebook group to discuss and my private accountability group for your health, hormones and life support!

    ⁠www.kellycaspersonmd.com/membership

    ---
    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/kj-casperson/message

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    You Are Not BrokenBy Kelly Casperson, MD

    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8

    4.8

    878 ratings


    More shows like You Are Not Broken

    View all
    Well Beyond 40 by JJ Virgin

    Well Beyond 40

    1,099 Listeners

    HOT For Your Health by Dr. Vonda Wright

    HOT For Your Health

    132 Listeners

    Not Your Mother's Menopause with Dr. Fiona Lovely by Discussions on women's health, the peaceful passage of menopause, peri-menopause and hormonal balance for all women.

    Not Your Mother's Menopause with Dr. Fiona Lovely

    274 Listeners

    Energized with Dr. Mariza by Dr. Mariza Snyder

    Energized with Dr. Mariza

    987 Listeners

    The Dr. Hyman Show by Dr. Mark Hyman

    The Dr. Hyman Show

    9,282 Listeners

    The Peter Attia Drive by Peter Attia, MD

    The Peter Attia Drive

    7,999 Listeners

    Health By Heather Hirsch by Heather Hirsch

    Health By Heather Hirsch

    207 Listeners

    Everyday Wellness: Midlife Hormones, Health, and Science for Women 35+ by Everyday Wellness™

    Everyday Wellness: Midlife Hormones, Health, and Science for Women 35+

    1,206 Listeners

    The Hormone Solution with Karen Martel by Karen Martel Hormone Specialist

    The Hormone Solution with Karen Martel

    328 Listeners

    Better! with Dr. Stephanie by Dr. Stephanie Estima

    Better! with Dr. Stephanie

    610 Listeners

    Hit Play Not Pause by Hit Play Not Pause

    Hit Play Not Pause

    722 Listeners

    The Dr. Tyna Show by Dr. Tyna Moore

    The Dr. Tyna Show

    1,655 Listeners

    Dr. Streicher’s Inside Information: Menopause, Midlife, and More by Lauren Streicher, MD

    Dr. Streicher’s Inside Information: Menopause, Midlife, and More

    367 Listeners

    All About You With Dr Shauna Watts by Dr Shauna Watts

    All About You With Dr Shauna Watts

    8 Listeners

    The Tamsen Show by Tamsen Fadal / Authentic Wave

    The Tamsen Show

    281 Listeners