Creating Readers with Savannah Campbell

#30 Stop Following Textbooks With Fidelity!


Listen Later

Textbook adoption committees seem to be in every district right now. States are passing legislation.  Publishing companies are "coming to the rescue." And teachers are being told to follow programs with fidelity.

But what happens when the program itself is overloaded, inconsistent, or simply not aligned with how children actually learn to read?

In this episode, I’m diving into one of my biggest frustrations in literacy education: the idea that good teaching means reading directly from a script. We’ll talk about why textbooks should be treated as tools rather than sacred documents and why teacher expertise still matters more than any boxed curriculum.

✨ In this episode, we discuss:

• Why many core reading programs prioritize compliance over learning
• The problem with “activating background knowledge” when students don’t actually have it
• Why all vocabulary words should NOT be taught the same way
• What it really means to adapt a curriculum responsibly
• Why fidelity should never come at the expense of student learning

At the end of the day, programs can provide structure, but they cannot replace thoughtful, knowledgeable teachers who know their students best.

If this episode resonates with you, share it with a teacher, coach, administrator, or district leader who needs the reminder that professional judgment still matters.

Links Mentioned:

Blog post on Building Background Knowledge

My new book on teaching vocabulary!*

 

*As an Amazon affiliate, I may earn a small commission on any products purchased through my link, at no additional cost to you!

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Creating Readers with Savannah CampbellBy Savannah Campbell

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

24 ratings


More shows like Creating Readers with Savannah Campbell

View all
Angela Watson's Truth for Teachers by Angela Watson

Angela Watson's Truth for Teachers

1,250 Listeners

Clutterbug - Real-Life Hacks and Tips to Declutter, Organize and Clean your Home Fast by Clutterbug

Clutterbug - Real-Life Hacks and Tips to Declutter, Organize and Clean your Home Fast

2,108 Listeners

Melissa & Lori Love Literacy ® | Science of Reading for Teachers by Supported by Great Minds

Melissa & Lori Love Literacy ® | Science of Reading for Teachers

434 Listeners

Raising Good Humans by Aliza Pressman

Raising Good Humans

1,888 Listeners

Science of Reading: The Podcast by Amplify Education

Science of Reading: The Podcast

646 Listeners

Don't Miss This Study by Emily Freeman & David Butler

Don't Miss This Study

3,700 Listeners

Reach All Readers by Anna Geiger

Reach All Readers

211 Listeners

Stellar Teacher Podcast: A Podcast for Upper Elementary Teachers by Sara Marye, Literacy Teacher, Elementary Teacher

Stellar Teacher Podcast: A Podcast for Upper Elementary Teachers

205 Listeners

Together in Literacy by Emily Gibbons & Casey Harrison

Together in Literacy

134 Listeners

Literacy Talks by Reading Horizons

Literacy Talks

62 Listeners

Route2Reading by Amie Burkholder

Route2Reading

26 Listeners

The Knowledge Matters Podcast by Knowledge Matters

The Knowledge Matters Podcast

174 Listeners

Chalk & Talk by Anna Stokke

Chalk & Talk

80 Listeners

Progressively Incorrect by Zach Groshell

Progressively Incorrect

44 Listeners

Literacy in Color: A Science of Reading Aligned Podcast for Educators by Michelle Sullivan • Literacy Coach & Science of Reading Advocate

Literacy in Color: A Science of Reading Aligned Podcast for Educators

53 Listeners