The party continues as Chelsea & Donny begin their sensible rebrand by covering the 2004 hit, "A Cinderella Story" with co-hosts of "Beyond the Blinds" podcast, Kelli and Troy. The hosts stay true to their brand of tormenting their guests (see also: Danielle Prescod; season 2, episode 9) as it is revealed quickly that Kelli's arch nemeses (nemesi?) are Hilary Duff AND Chad Michael Murray, the two stars of this movie. Chelsea tries to make it up to her by spilling some CMM that she has collected over the years. Donny & Chelsea find their Halloween costumes for next year (it's not the lackluster Cinderella dress), and the group discusses the infamous "Laugh out loud" texting scene in addition to the joys of AOL chat rooms (shout out to Blair, 16/f/LA!)

To hear (or watch) this recap in its unedited, unhinged entirety, head to our newly launched Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/iamthecuteone

For our merch, check out iamthecuteone.com

Follow Us on Social Media!

Chelsea: @ohnochels

Donny: @realdonnywood

Support the show

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices