People sometimes wonder whether certain AIs or animals are conscious/sentient/sapient/have qualia/etc. I don't think that such questions are coherent. Consciousness is a concept that humans developed for reasoning about humans. It's a useful concept, not because it is ontologically fundamental, but because different humans have lots of close similarities in how our cognition works, and we have privileged access to some details of our own cognition, so “it's like what's going on in my head, but with some differences that I can infer from the fact that they don't act quite the same way I do” is a useful way to understand what's going on in other peoples' heads, and we use consciousness-related language to describe features of human minds that we can understand this way. Consciousness is the thing that a typical adult human recognizes in themselves when hearing others describe the character of their internal cognition. This [...]

---

First published:
June 9th, 2025

Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/q9A9ZFqW3dDbcTBQL/against-asking-if-ais-are-conscious

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.