Criminal Mischief

Criminal Mischief

By 657804True Crime
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    241

    Followers

  • Typical duration

    37 min

    per episode

  • If it hooks

    44%

    finish an episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

Criminal Mischief episodes

  • E|185 UPDATES! (Bonus)

    Criminal Mischief: Case Updates — New Evidence, New Outcomes, New Questions

    On this episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio revisits some of the most high-profile and disturbing cases she’s covered—bringing listeners up to speed with major developments, fresh audio, and new perspective.
    These aren’t rehashes.
    These are updates that change the story.
    The Gilgo Beach Murders — Rex Heuerman Sentenced
    One of the most chilling cases in modern true crime reaches a major milestone.
    Carolyn breaks down the sentencing of Rex Heuerman, the alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer, examining what we now know, what remains unanswered, and what this moment means for the victims and their families.
    Featuring newly surfaced audio and commentary, this segment explores how a case that lingered for over a decade finally reached this stage—and what may still lie beneath the surface.
    Karen Read — Acquitted Again… But Not Finished
    After a second acquittal, Karen Read remains at the center of one of the most polarizing cases in recent memory.
    But this story isn’t over.
    With a civil lawsuit looming, Carolyn examines what comes next—legally, publicly, and personally.
    Through new interviews and analysis, this segment explores the divide between courtroom outcomes and public perception, and how a case can evolve even after a verdict is delivered.
    Brendan Banfield — Sentenced, But For How Long?
    The case of Brendan Banfield takes another turn as sentencing is handed down—but the story is far from settled.
    With an appeal already expected, Carolyn unpacks the legal strategy ahead, the potential vulnerabilities in the conviction, and what could come next.
    Featuring fresh audio and investigative insight, this segment highlights how even after sentencing, the fight over truth—and outcome—can continue.
    A New Layer to Familiar Stories
    Each of these cases has been covered before.
    But time changes things.
    New evidence surfaces.
    New voices emerge.
    And the story you thought you understood begins to shift.
    Listen & Follow
    Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode.
    If you’re enjoying the show, take a moment to rate and review—it helps others discover these stories.
    Watch & Subscribe
    Full episodes and video content are available on the Evio Creative YouTube channel.Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next.
    Join the Conversation
    Have thoughts on these cases?Tips? Stories we should cover?

    📲 Instagram: @criminalmischiefpod (or your preferred handle)

    Closing
    The story doesn’t end with a verdict.
    Sometimes—that’s where it really begins.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    36 min
  • E|185 UPDATES!

    Criminal Mischief: Case Updates — New Evidence, New Outcomes, New Questions

    On this episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio revisits some of the most high-profile and disturbing cases she’s covered—bringing listeners up to speed with major developments, fresh audio, and new perspective.

    These aren’t rehashes.

    These are updates that change the story.


    The Gilgo Beach Murders — Rex Heuerman Sentenced

    One of the most chilling cases in modern true crime reaches a major milestone.

    Carolyn breaks down the sentencing of Rex Heuerman, the alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer, examining what we now know, what remains unanswered, and what this moment means for the victims and their families.

    Featuring newly surfaced audio and commentary, this segment explores how a case that lingered for over a decade finally reached this stage—and what may still lie beneath the surface.


    Karen Read — Acquitted Again… But Not Finished

    After a second acquittal, Karen Read remains at the center of one of the most polarizing cases in recent memory.

    But this story isn’t over.

    With a civil lawsuit looming, Carolyn examines what comes next—legally, publicly, and personally.

    Through new interviews and analysis, this segment explores the divide between courtroom outcomes and public perception, and how a case can evolve even after a verdict is delivered.


    Brendan Banfield — Sentenced, But For How Long?

    The case of Brendan Banfield takes another turn as sentencing is handed down—but the story is far from settled.

    With an appeal already expected, Carolyn unpacks the legal strategy ahead, the potential vulnerabilities in the conviction, and what could come next.

    Featuring fresh audio and investigative insight, this segment highlights how even after sentencing, the fight over truth—and outcome—can continue.


    A New Layer to Familiar Stories

    Each of these cases has been covered before.

    But time changes things.

    New evidence surfaces.

    New voices emerge.

    And the story you thought you understood begins to shift.


    Listen & Follow

    Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode.

    If you’re enjoying the show, take a moment to rate and review—it helps others discover these stories.


    Watch & Subscribe

    Full episodes and video content are available on the Evio Creative YouTube channel.
Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next.


    Join the Conversation

    Have thoughts on these cases?
Tips? Stories we should cover?

    📩 [email protected]
📲 Instagram: @criminalmischiefpod (or your preferred handle)


    Closing

    The story doesn’t end with a verdict.

    Sometimes—that’s where it really begins.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    29 min
  • E|184 Deadly Secrets (Bonus)

    Criminal Mischief — The Murder of Jonathan Willett

    What happens when love turns into control… and control turns into something far more dangerous?
    In this episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio examines the brutal murder of Jonathan Willett at the hands of his former girlfriend, Devyn—a case that begins as a volatile breakup and escalates into a chilling act of violence that few saw coming… but many, in hindsight, recognize the warning signs of.
    Drawing from official interrogation recordings, court transcripts, and interviews with investigators, Carolyn reconstructs the final days leading up to the murder—uncovering a pattern of obsession, manipulation, and escalating tension that ultimately ended in tragedy.
    This is not just a story about one crime.
    It’s a portrait of domestic violence in its most insidious form—where control disguises itself as love, where warning signs are minimized or ignored, and where the line between emotional abuse and physical violence quietly disappears.
    In this episode, we explore:
    • The relationship between Jonathan and Devyn—and how it began to fracture
    • The behavioral patterns that signaled escalation
    • The moments leading up to the murder
    • Devyn’s interrogation—and what she chose to reveal
    • The prosecution’s case and courtroom revelations
    • The broader implications of domestic violence and coercive control
    Through firsthand accounts and documented evidence, Criminal Mischief brings listeners inside the investigation—step by step—allowing the truth to emerge not as speculation, but as something far more unsettling:
    A sequence of choices that, once set in motion, could not be undone.
    Because the most dangerous part of cases like this isn’t always the violence itself—
    It’s how predictable it can be… once you know where to look.
    Listen & Follow
    Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts.
    Watch & Subscribe
    Full episodes available on YouTube: Evio Creative
    Contact
    [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    39 min
  • E|184 Deadly Secrets

    Criminal Mischief — The Murder of Jonathan Willett

    What happens when love turns into control… and control turns into something far more dangerous?

    In this episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio examines the brutal murder of Jonathan Willett at the hands of his former girlfriend, Devyn—a case that begins as a volatile breakup and escalates into a chilling act of violence that few saw coming… but many, in hindsight, recognize the warning signs of.

    Drawing from official interrogation recordings, court transcripts, and interviews with investigators, Carolyn reconstructs the final days leading up to the murder—uncovering a pattern of obsession, manipulation, and escalating tension that ultimately ended in tragedy.

    This is not just a story about one crime.

    It’s a portrait of domestic violence in its most insidious form—where control disguises itself as love, where warning signs are minimized or ignored, and where the line between emotional abuse and physical violence quietly disappears.

    In this episode, we explore:

    • The relationship between Jonathan and Devyn—and how it began to fracture

    • The behavioral patterns that signaled escalation

    • The moments leading up to the murder

    • Devyn’s interrogation—and what she chose to reveal

    • The prosecution’s case and courtroom revelations

    • The broader implications of domestic violence and coercive control

    Through firsthand accounts and documented evidence, Criminal Mischief brings listeners inside the investigation—step by step—allowing the truth to emerge not as speculation, but as something far more unsettling:

    A sequence of choices that, once set in motion, could not be undone.

    Because the most dangerous part of cases like this isn’t always the violence itself—

    It’s how predictable it can be… once you know where to look.


    Listen & Follow

    Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts.

    Watch & Subscribe

    Full episodes available on YouTube: Evio Creative

    Contact

    [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    38 min
  • E|183 The Unravelling (Bonus)

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Episode: The Murdaugh Murders


    A powerful name.

    A quiet town.

    And a story that unraveled everything.


    ⚖️ The Case

    In this episode, Carolyn Ossorio takes you deep into the shocking murders tied to Alex Murdaugh—a once-prominent attorney from a legal dynasty in South Carolina.

    What began as a tragic discovery quickly spiraled into one of the most complex and disturbing cases in recent memory.


    📞 The 911 Call

    It starts the way these stories often do:

    A frantic call.

    A husband claiming to have found his wife and son brutally murdered.

    But even in those first moments…

    Something doesn’t sit right.


    🔍 The Investigation

    As law enforcement begins to dig deeper, the narrative begins to shift.

    • Timelines tighten

    • Alibis fracture

    • Financial crimes surface

    And the man at the center of it all?

    He’s no longer just the caller.

    He’s the focus.


    🎙️ Inside the Interrogation

    Through police interviews and recorded interrogations, we hear the evolution:

    👉 Confidence turning to contradiction


    👉 Control slipping into pressure


    👉 A story that can’t hold together

    Because the more that’s uncovered…

    The harder it becomes to explain.


    🧾 The Evidence

    Court records reveal a web far bigger than the murders themselves:

    • Financial fraud

    • Abuse of power

    • A lifetime of manipulation

    And at the center of it all:

    A man who believed the system would protect him.


    ⚖️ The Trial

    The courtroom becomes the final stage.

    Where:

    • Evidence meets narrative

    • Emotion meets strategy

    • And the truth—whatever it is—can’t hide forever

    The verdict doesn’t just close a case.

    It exposes a legacy.


    🧠 The Takeaway

    This isn’t just a murder story.

    It’s about:

    👉 Power


    👉 Control


    👉 And what happens when both begin to collapse

    Because when someone builds a life on manipulation…

    It doesn’t fall apart quietly.


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts


    📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel


    📱 Follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook


    Because the most dangerous people…

    Aren’t the ones hiding in the shadows.

    They’re the ones who think they own the light.





    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    33 min
  • E|183 The Unravelling

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Episode: The Murdaugh Murders


    A powerful name.

    A quiet town.

    And a story that unraveled everything.


    ⚖️ The Case

    In this episode, Carolyn Ossorio takes you deep into the shocking murders tied to Alex Murdaugh—a once-prominent attorney from a legal dynasty in South Carolina.

    What began as a tragic discovery quickly spiraled into one of the most complex and disturbing cases in recent memory.


    📞 The 911 Call

    It starts the way these stories often do:

    A frantic call.

    A husband claiming to have found his wife and son brutally murdered.

    But even in those first moments…

    Something doesn’t sit right.


    🔍 The Investigation

    As law enforcement begins to dig deeper, the narrative begins to shift.

    • Timelines tighten

    • Alibis fracture

    • Financial crimes surface

    And the man at the center of it all?

    He’s no longer just the caller.

    He’s the focus.


    🎙️ Inside the Interrogation

    Through police interviews and recorded interrogations, we hear the evolution:

    👉 Confidence turning to contradiction


    👉 Control slipping into pressure


    👉 A story that can’t hold together

    Because the more that’s uncovered…

    The harder it becomes to explain.


    🧾 The Evidence

    Court records reveal a web far bigger than the murders themselves:

    • Financial fraud

    • Abuse of power

    • A lifetime of manipulation

    And at the center of it all:

    A man who believed the system would protect him.


    ⚖️ The Trial

    The courtroom becomes the final stage.

    Where:

    • Evidence meets narrative

    • Emotion meets strategy

    • And the truth—whatever it is—can’t hide forever

    The verdict doesn’t just close a case.

    It exposes a legacy.


    🧠 The Takeaway

    This isn’t just a murder story.

    It’s about:

    👉 Power


    👉 Control


    👉 And what happens when both begin to collapse

    Because when someone builds a life on manipulation…

    It doesn’t fall apart quietly.


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts


    📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel


    📱 Follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook


    Because the most dangerous people…

    Aren’t the ones hiding in the shadows.

    They’re the ones who think they own the light.





    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    48 min
  • E|182 Hollywood: Part Seven - It's Showtime! (Bonus)

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Episode 182: Hollywood — Part 7: The Finale
    It was never going to end quietly.
    After years of calculated hits, shifting patterns, and rising confidence, the man known only as Hollywood finally made the mistake that ended it all:
    He took the wrong money.
    💰 The Trap
    In this final chapter, we hear directly from the detective who tracked him down.
    Because this time, the vault wasn’t just holding cash.
    It was holding a tracker.
    Within minutes of the robbery, law enforcement had a live signal—and a location.
    The hunt was over.
    🚐 The Confrontation
    On a busy street in Seattle, in the pouring rain, the getaway van was surrounded.
    No escape routes.No time to think.
    Just pressure—and a decision.
    🔫 The Shootout
    What followed wasn’t an arrest.
    It was chaos.
    • Gunfire in the streets
    • Civilians nearby
    • Officers closing in
    A full-scale shootout that turned a calculated criminal career into something desperate and unpredictable.
    ⚠️ The Escape
    And somehow…
    He got away.
    But not for long.
    Because once the system catches up to you—once it knows where you are, how you move, and how you think—
    The ending becomes inevitable.
    🎬 The Parallel
    If this feels familiar…
    It should.
    The comparisons to Point Break are impossible to ignore.
    The thrill.The confidence.The escalation.
    And ultimately…
    The collapse.
    Except this wasn’t a movie.
    This was real.
    🧠 The Final Takeaway
    Hollywood didn’t fall because he wasn’t smart.
    He fell because he couldn’t stop.
    Because at a certain point, it’s no longer about the money.
    It’s about the momentum.
    🎧 Listen & Follow
    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts

    📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel

    📱 Follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook

    Because in the end…
    It’s not the plan that gets you caught.
    It’s the moment you stop thinking you can be.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    33 min
  • E|182 Hollywood: Part Seven - It's Showtime!

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Episode 182: Hollywood — Part 7: It's Showtime!


    It was never going to end quietly.

    After years of calculated hits, shifting patterns, and rising confidence, the man known only as Hollywood finally made the mistake that ended it all:

    He took the wrong money.


    💰 The Trap

    In this final chapter, we hear directly from the detective who tracked him down.

    Because this time, the vault wasn’t just holding cash.

    It was holding a tracker.

    Within minutes of the robbery, law enforcement had a live signal—and a location.

    The hunt was over.


    🚐 The Confrontation

    On a busy street in Seattle, in the pouring rain, the getaway van was surrounded.

    No escape routes.
No time to think.

    Just pressure—and a decision.


    🔫 The Shootout

    What followed wasn’t an arrest.

    It was chaos.

    • Gunfire in the streets

    • Civilians nearby

    • Officers closing in

    A full-scale shootout that turned a calculated criminal career into something desperate and unpredictable.


    ⚠️ The Escape

    And somehow…

    He got away.

    But not for long.

    Because once the system catches up to you—once it knows where you are, how you move, and how you think—

    The ending becomes inevitable.


    🎬 The Parallel

    If this feels familiar…

    It should.

    The comparisons to Point Break are impossible to ignore.

    The thrill.
The confidence.
The escalation.

    And ultimately…

    The collapse.

    Except this wasn’t a movie.

    This was real.


    🧠 The Final Takeaway

    Hollywood didn’t fall because he wasn’t smart.

    He fell because he couldn’t stop.

    Because at a certain point, it’s no longer about the money.

    It’s about the momentum.


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts
📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel
📱 Follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook


    Because in the end…

    It’s not the plan that gets you caught.

    It’s the moment you stop thinking you can be.





    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    48 min
  • E|181 Hollywood: Part Six — Greed (Bonus)

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Hollywood: Part Six — Greed


    The story continues… and the stakes get higher.

    In Part Six of our series on Seattle’s most elusive bank robber—known only as Hollywood—the operation doesn’t just continue.

    It evolves.


    💰 The Escalation

    What began as a bold first hit has now stretched into a three-year run.

    And with time comes confidence.
With confidence… comes risk.

    Hollywood isn’t just robbing banks anymore.

    He’s refining the system:

    • New members brought into the crew

    • Roles becoming more defined

    • Execution becoming faster… cleaner… more ambitious

    And then comes the shift.


    🏦 From Drawers to Vaults

    At some point, the teller drawers stop being enough.

    Too small. Too predictable.

    So Hollywood makes a decision:

    👉 Skip the front lines
👉 Go straight for the vault

    It’s a move that changes everything.

    Higher reward.

    Higher exposure.

    No margin for error.


    🧠 The Pattern Beneath the Chaos

    On the surface, Hollywood looks erratic.

    • Different neighborhoods

    • Sometimes the same bank—two, even three times

    • No obvious geographic logic

    But chaos has a limit.

    Because eventually… money leaves a trail.

    And investigators start to notice something subtle—but critical:

    👉 His spending habits

    Not flashy. Not reckless.

    But consistent enough to form a pattern.

    And that pattern?

    It begins to suggest when—and where—he might strike next.


    ⚠️ The Turning Point

    This is where it shifts.

    Because once law enforcement moves from reaction… to prediction…

    The clock starts ticking.

    Not just on the next robbery.

    But on Hollywood himself.


    🔜 What’s Next

    As the net tightens, the question isn’t whether Hollywood will strike again.

    It’s whether he can stop himself.


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts
📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel


    Because in the end…

    It’s not the first score that gets you caught.

    It’s the one you didn’t need to make.





    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    36 min
  • E|181 Hollywood: Part Six - Greed

    🎧 Criminal Mischief

    Hollywood: Part Six — Greed


    The story continues… and the stakes get higher.

    In Part Six of our series on Seattle’s most elusive bank robber—known only as Hollywood—the operation doesn’t just continue.

    It evolves.


    💰 The Escalation

    What began as a bold first hit has now stretched into a three-year run.

    And with time comes confidence.
With confidence… comes risk.

    Hollywood isn’t just robbing banks anymore.

    He’s refining the system:

    • New members brought into the crew

    • Roles becoming more defined

    • Execution becoming faster… cleaner… more ambitious

    And then comes the shift.


    🏦 From Drawers to Vaults

    At some point, the teller drawers stop being enough.

    Too small. Too predictable.

    So Hollywood makes a decision:

    👉 Skip the front lines
👉 Go straight for the vault

    It’s a move that changes everything.

    Higher reward.

    Higher exposure.

    No margin for error.


    🧠 The Pattern Beneath the Chaos

    On the surface, Hollywood looks erratic.

    • Different neighborhoods

    • Sometimes the same bank—two, even three times

    • No obvious geographic logic

    But chaos has a limit.

    Because eventually… money leaves a trail.

    And investigators start to notice something subtle—but critical:

    👉 His spending habits

    Not flashy. Not reckless.

    But consistent enough to form a pattern.

    And that pattern?

    It begins to suggest when—and where—he might strike next.


    ⚠️ The Turning Point

    This is where it shifts.

    Because once law enforcement moves from reaction… to prediction…

    The clock starts ticking.

    Not just on the next robbery.

    But on Hollywood himself.


    🔜 What’s Next

    As the net tightens, the question isn’t whether Hollywood will strike again.

    It’s whether he can stop himself.


    🎧 Listen & Follow

    👉 Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts
📺 Watch on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel


    Because in the end…

    It’s not the first score that gets you caught.

    It’s the one you didn’t need to make.





    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    45 min

About Criminal Mischief

From the publisher's feed

The Murder Chronicles is now CRIMINAL MISCHIEF with Carolyn and Branden. From the creative team that brought you The Shadow Girls and The Devil Within, hosts Carolyn Ossorio and…

Best of Criminal Mischief

Ranked by our users in the last 21 days

More shows like Criminal Mischief

Generation Why: True Crime by Audible Original

Generation Why: True Crime

17,237 Listeners

The Vanished Podcast by Audible Original

The Vanished Podcast

15,105 Listeners

Crimelines® True Crime by Crimelines True Crime

Crimelines® True Crime

4,214 Listeners

Cold Case Files by A&E / PodcastOne

Cold Case Files

8,579 Listeners

MURDERISH by Cloud10

MURDERISH

3,426 Listeners

Hell and Gone: Murder Line by iHeartPodcasts

Hell and Gone: Murder Line

7,409 Listeners

Culpable by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Culpable

22,190 Listeners

The Idaho Massacre by iHeartPodcasts

The Idaho Massacre

6,747 Listeners

Paper Ghosts: The Texas Teen Murders by iHeartPodcasts

Paper Ghosts: The Texas Teen Murders

6,211 Listeners

Crimes of the Centuries by Amber Hunt and Audioboom

Crimes of the Centuries

4,042 Listeners

Unraveled by ID

Unraveled

10,545 Listeners

DNA: ID by AbJack Entertainment

DNA: ID

1,009 Listeners

The Devil Within by EVIO Creative

The Devil Within

2,763 Listeners

Crossing the Line with M. William Phelps by M. William Phelps

Crossing the Line with M. William Phelps

3,434 Listeners

DEVIANT by Cold Open Media

DEVIANT

609 Listeners