
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This video provides a lot of background: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eq3bUFgEcb4 and is also very funny, but it's not necessary to understand this post. If you've watched it you can probably skip to the "Why is Piano Roll Notation Bad?" section.
TL;DR
Music notation is very janky and weird, but attempts to reform it to be "logical" are usually even worse. The specific ways in which they are worse can tell us something about how information can be compressed, particularly when world-histories contain a set of sparse events.
We can extend this logic to sketch out how verbs work in the case of a bouncing spring. Most of the time it follows an uneventful freefall trajectory, punctuated by occasional "bounce" "events" so we can communicate its trajectory as a list of bounces, rather than as a function of position + extension over time.
Music and Frequencies
Let's use the piano as an [...]
---
Outline:
(00:20) TL;DR
(00:58) Music and Frequencies
(03:17) Existing Notation
(06:35) Notation Reform to the Rescue!
(08:04) Why is Piano-Roll Notation Bad?
(09:11) Notes are not randomly distributed!
(10:00) Durations are not uniformly distributed either!
(11:22) Sparsity
(12:27) Semantics
(12:49) The Spring
(14:07) Sidebar: Generalized Geometry
(15:17) Position + Extension Trajectories
(17:21) Sparsity Returns
(17:57) But Why are Verbs Inter-Operable?
---
First published:
Source:
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---
Images from the article:
Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.
By LessWrongThis video provides a lot of background: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eq3bUFgEcb4 and is also very funny, but it's not necessary to understand this post. If you've watched it you can probably skip to the "Why is Piano Roll Notation Bad?" section.
TL;DR
Music notation is very janky and weird, but attempts to reform it to be "logical" are usually even worse. The specific ways in which they are worse can tell us something about how information can be compressed, particularly when world-histories contain a set of sparse events.
We can extend this logic to sketch out how verbs work in the case of a bouncing spring. Most of the time it follows an uneventful freefall trajectory, punctuated by occasional "bounce" "events" so we can communicate its trajectory as a list of bounces, rather than as a function of position + extension over time.
Music and Frequencies
Let's use the piano as an [...]
---
Outline:
(00:20) TL;DR
(00:58) Music and Frequencies
(03:17) Existing Notation
(06:35) Notation Reform to the Rescue!
(08:04) Why is Piano-Roll Notation Bad?
(09:11) Notes are not randomly distributed!
(10:00) Durations are not uniformly distributed either!
(11:22) Sparsity
(12:27) Semantics
(12:49) The Spring
(14:07) Sidebar: Generalized Geometry
(15:17) Position + Extension Trajectories
(17:21) Sparsity Returns
(17:57) But Why are Verbs Inter-Operable?
---
First published:
Source:
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---
Images from the article:
Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.

26,311 Listeners

2,461 Listeners

8,597 Listeners

4,170 Listeners

97 Listeners

1,608 Listeners

10,041 Listeners

97 Listeners

528 Listeners

5,529 Listeners

16,055 Listeners

570 Listeners

138 Listeners

93 Listeners

473 Listeners